“What people want is resolution”: they urge greater agility and opt for mediation to avoid tragedies like that of the Caguas Court

“What people want is resolution”: they urge greater agility and opt for mediation to avoid tragedies like that of the Caguas Court

He murder of two brothers in the Court of Caguas due to a neighborhood dispute has led experts to urge that the Judiciary speed up the resolution of this type of cases and that it bet on mediation beyond a court to prevent the lack of resolution from resulting in “acts of despair.”

“(Procrastination) adds fatigue, adds more anger. (…) What people want is resolution, for the laws to intervene, whether on one side or the other. Indecision is what carries the burden, what leads to desperation, because it is a terrible act of desperation to take justice into one’s own hands. What this means is that they have no hope that, in court, the conflict can be redeemed,” said the doctor. Light of Dawn Acevedoprofessor of Political Sciences at the University of Puerto Rico (UPR), Rio Piedras Campus.

He added that disputes between neighbors are more common than is thought on the island and mentioned, as an example, the case – which has been going on for years in the Court of Carolina – against an 86-year-old woman reported by neighbors in Canovanas for a pattern of racial harassment.

“To the extent that an unresolved conflict passes, the greater the violence that accumulates and, at some point, people act on that violence. It seems to me that one of the most important things is dialogue, conversation. You have to have clear conversations with neighbors and, when not, you have to have intermediaries,” he added.

Roy KaraKozian, 34, faces eight charges for the events, including first-degree murder and violations of the Weapons Law. (Carlos Giusti)

At around 4:35 pm on Tuesday, Roy Kara Kozian34 years old and of Lebanese origin, shot the brothers to death Angel Calderon Perez44 years old, and Rosa Judith Calderon Perez45, in front of the entrance to the Investigation Room of the Caguas Court. According to police, they were all at the scene for a stalking protection order case related to a years-long neighborhood dispute.

The administrative director of the Courts, Siegfried Steidelhe specified The new day that the case that ended with the murder of the two brothers was presented in May 2023. However, the neighboring families of the La Guasabara sector, in Caguas, had gone through two previous procedures, in 2021 and 2022, which had already been resolved , according to Judge Steidel.

The case presented, in 2021, by the Law on Disputes and Provisional States of Law (Law 140-1974) ended on June 28, 2022.

“What can be said is that the conflict between them has been going on for years, but the life of the cases has ended at different times. That is, the cases resolve the legal situation involved or address it in the way that the judge understands that it should be addressed in light of the evidence presented, but that does not necessarily remedy the conflicts between people. They have gone to court since December 2021 at different times, but the conflict between them has transcended the life of the cases,” Steidel commented.

To questions about whether, in these cases, there was some type of mediation, he said that “it does not appear from the files that Mediation Centers were used.”

The Judicial Branch has Mediation Centers in its 13 regions, in which they address – among other cases – conflicts between neighbors. The Alternative Dispute Resolution Rules provide: “The court shall have discretion to determine the appropriate time to refer a case to an alternative dispute resolution method.”

“If there had been effective mediation, this would not have happened. If there was mediation, then the mediation failed,” said the doctor. Victor Garcia Torosociologist, criminologist, social worker and retired professor from the UPR.

The events were recorded in front of the entrance to the Investigation Room of the Court of Caguas.
The events were recorded in front of the entrance to the Investigation Room of the Court of Caguas. (Josian Bruno Gomez)

Angela Santana Diazdirector of Bureau of Alternative Methods for Conflict Resolution, specified that the mediation option is available free of charge to any citizen who needs it, without the need to carry out an active process in court. He also assured that conflict mediation is a tool that is used daily.

However, he clarified that “it is completely voluntary.” “If the neighbor refuses to participate, that’s as far as the process goes,” he emphasized.

For its part, samuel osorioconflict mediator of the Peace Agreement program Health Workshop, stated that, in this case, that alternative was absent. “For me, the State failed to refer them to mediation because, in mediation, there is not the decision that a judge can give as to who owns a piece of land, but points of respect are reached,” he said.

Both Osorio and Professor Acevedo recommended that authorities play a more active role in cases related to neighborhood disputes, particularly in monitoring the families involved in the disputes.

“He murders them in court. Symbolically, the message is ‘I don’t even care about the law’. That is to say, there are many elements to look for here; dialogue, education about rights and the limits of our rights, what our social responsibilities are in the contexts where we live, because it is about healthy coexistence,” Acevedo highlighted.

Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media is a News and Entertainment Website & Channel. Kumneger Media in addition to News and Entertainment it is the hub of Politics, Movies, Drama, Music, Comedy, Documentary and More!