Federal judge returns the lawsuit against manufacturers of insulin and PBMs to the Court of San Juan

Federal judge returns the lawsuit against manufacturers of insulin and PBMs to the Court of San Juan

He Senior District Judge Jay A. Garcia Gregory, ordered today, Wednesday, to return to the Court of First Instance of San Juan the claim filed by the Government of Puerto Ricothrough the Office of Monopolistic Affairs of the Justice Departmentagainst the three main manufacturers of insulin and three of the largest Pharmacy Benefit Providers (PBMs).

Justice filed the lawsuit against the pharmaceutical companies Eli Lilly and Company, Sanofi and new nordiskand against PBMs Caremark PCS Health, Express Scripts and Optum RXin January of this year for allegedly deceptive practices that have increased, for decades, the price of the drug used by patients with diabetes Type 1 and Type 2 to control your blood glucose levels.

The appeal, filed on January 17, 2023, demands the cessation and desist of the alleged deceptive practices, the restitution of the money collected unfairly, payments for damages caused and the disbursement of the profits obtained through the alleged actions that violate the Antitrust Law of Puerto Rico (Law 77 of 1964).

Although the lawsuit was filed in the San Juan Court, one of the PBMs, Express Scripts, filed an appeal on March 17 with the Federal Court for the District of Puerto Rico in which he requested the transfer of the lawsuit to the federal sphere. A few days later, CaremarkPCS Health also filed a motion in support of the Express Scripts request.

In simple terms, Express Scripts and CaremarkPCS Health invoked Article 28 of the United States Code which covers claims filed against federal officials or agencies. Since both PBMs hold pharmacy benefit contracts with federal agencies such as the federal State Department, he Defense Department and with the United States Armed Forcesamong others, (through the FEHBA and TRICARE plans) the companies stressed that the demand should be addressed at the federal level since they act under the orders of “federal officials” (through the aforementioned contracts).

The statute, in essence, allows the “removal” (transfer) of a case filed, at the state level, against the United States or against one of its agencies or officials “for, or in relation to, any act under the control of said agency and /or agent”.

In his five-page memorandum and order, issued today, Wednesday, Garcia Gregory rejected the PBMs’ argument for using federal officer statutes to get the case heard at the federal level.

“The defendants cannot reasonably assert that the actions they took with respect to non-federal contracts were made ‘in the name or on behalf of an official of the United States and under the responsibilities of the office/agency’. Therefore, the removal (return of the case to the state court) is justified because there is not ‘a causal connection between the imputed conduct and the alleged official authority,’ as required by the federal officer removal statute,” Garcia Gregory highlighted in the written.

The senior district judge also rejected Express Scripts’ “indivisibility” argument, noting that “since there are no claims related to federal programs in this case, a ruling in this lawsuit would have no impact on insulin prices.” under any federal program because compensation would be strictly limited to non-federal health plans.”

“Therefore, by dismissing (returning) the case, the state court would not have to address issues related to the defendants’ federal contracts. Defendants would also have no federal defenses since the asserted claims do not involve federal programs or federal (official) actors. Just because defendants conduct business in a particular way does not mean that they cannot do business in a different way than a court order is issued. Furthermore, this court was not convinced that dividing the work defendants do for the federal government from the work they do for their private clients is not possible in this particular case.”, emphasized Garcia Gregory.

The federal judge also based his decision on the fact that policy considerations favor returning the case to state court.

Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media is a News and Entertainment Website & Channel. Kumneger Media in addition to News and Entertainment it is the hub of Politics, Movies, Drama, Music, Comedy, Documentary and More!