Jury petition causes debate in the new trial for the La Tombola Massacre

Jury petition causes debate in the new trial for the La Tombola Massacre

The jury evaluating the evidence in the federal new trial against Alexis Candelario Santana for the call “La Tombola massacre“ closed its second day of deliberations without having delivered a verdict.

The two days of deliberation already exceed the time it took the jury of the first trial in this case to deliver a verdict, in March 2013, when Candelario Santana was found guilty. That verdict was reversed on appeal due to an error by the judge who presided over the case at the time, Jose A. Fuste.

The seven men and five women on the new jury have sent Senior District Judge Francisco Besosa several notes with questions.some of which provoked an extensive debate between lawyers and prosecutors.

In response to the questions submitted yesterday, Wednesday, the parties agreed that the jury should be told that they had to rely on what they remembered hearing during the trial at the Federal Court of Old San Juanas well as the pieces of evidence that were handed over to them.

However, from the questions submitted today, Thursday, it appears that jurors have had difficulty recalling all the testimony on which the case presented by the federal prosecutor’s office.

In addition to the murders, the shooting left 19 people injured. (Jose R. Madera)

An hour after beginning to deliberate this morning, the jury indicated that, after verifying the evidence delivered, they did not find information on one of the witnesses, Caleb Castro Rentswho was one of the 19 people injured on October 17, 2009 during a shooting at the “La Tombola” business, where eight people and an unborn baby were murdered.

Castro Rentas testified as a witness for the Public Ministry in the first trial of this case. Because he passed away before the second trial was held, he was unable to testify, so his 2013 testimony was read in open court.

The federal prosecutor’s office agreed to be provided with the transcript, while the defense opposed it. The judge ruled by telling the jury that “all the evidence has been presented, including any evidence or information about Caleb Castro Rentas. No further information will be given. They must depend on the collective memory of Caleb Castro Rentas.”

An hour later, the jury sent another note stating: “We request the list of all witnesses who have participated in this trial.” The petition opened a debate of more than an hour between the parties.

Multiple weapons of different calibers were used in the shooting.
Multiple weapons of different calibers were used in the shooting. (LUIS ALCALA DEL OLMO)

He federal prosecutor Victor Acevedo He maintained that “there is nothing improper” in delivering a list of names that are part of the evidence in the case, without giving information about the content of their testimonies.

“There are no arguments there. There are 40 charges based on 38 witnesses… It’s the second time they’ve asked. It is obvious that it has been difficult for them to remember,” said Acevedo, who acknowledged that “I have been in this case for seven years and sometimes I still have a hard time remembering all the names.”

For their part, defense attorneys Francisco Rebollo and Kendy Pimentelargued that the answer should be the same, that they depend on their memory.

They maintained that handing over the list of names of witnesses at this stage of the proceedings was to mention some of the victims.

“We would be creating an exhibit,” said Rebollo.

“Clearly they are looking to find out if Caleb Castro Rentas testified. It was something that the prosecution should have clarified in its closing argument. (Giving the list) is opening the final arguments, ”he added.

After Judge Besosa evaluated similar issues in other cases sent to them by the parties, he resolved by handing over the list of names, several of which were already in the instructions given to the jury.

In the end, Rebollo objected to including the titles of witnesses who were law enforcement officers, but the judge upheld them.

Deliberations will continue tomorrow, starting at 9:00 am

Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media is a News and Entertainment Website & Channel. Kumneger Media in addition to News and Entertainment it is the hub of Politics, Movies, Drama, Music, Comedy, Documentary and More!