:format(jpeg):focal(2285x625:2295x615)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/75BOQF6YIRAV5B2FRKQKD5T2WY.jpg)
On vacation in Chicago this week from Europe, Jelle den Burger and Nirusa Naguleswaran ate at the Dog House Grill: a classic Italian steak sandwich for him, grilled cheese for her.
They both think the way their genders aligned with their food choices was no coincidence. Naguleswaran says women are more likely not to choose meat and worry about how their diet affects the environment and other people.
“I don’t want to be misunderstood, to make men feel attacked,” Naguleswaran, who is from the Netherlands, said with a laugh. He noted that she loves eating meat, but giving it up for climate reasons was more important to her. “We just by nature care about others.”
Now, scientists can say with more confidence than ever that gender and meat-eating preferences are linked. An article published this week in Nature Scientific Reports shows that the difference is almost universal between cultures, and that it is even more pronounced in more developed countries.
Researchers already knew that in some countries men ate more meat than women. And they knew that people in richer countries ate more meat in general. But the latest findings suggest that when men and women have the social and financial freedom to make decisions about their diets, they diverge even more from each other: Men eat more meat and women eat less.
This is important because around 20% of global planet-warming greenhouse gas emissions come from animal-based food products, according to previous research from the University of Illinois. The researchers behind the new report believe their findings could sharpen efforts to persuade people to eat less meat and dairy.
“Anything that can be done to reduce meat consumption among men would have a greater impact, on average, than among women,” said Christopher Hopwood, a professor of psychology at the University of Zurich and one of the authors of the paper. The work was funded by Mercy for Animals, a nonprofit organization dedicated to ending animal agriculture. Hopwood said he is not affiliated with the organization and is not an activist.
The researchers asked more than 28,000 people in 23 countries on four continents how much of different types of food they ate each day, and then calculated the average consumption of land animals by gender identity in each country. They used the United Nations Human Development Index, which measures health, education and living standards, to rank how “developed” each country was, and they also looked at the Global Gender Gap Index, published by the World Economic Forum.
They found that, with three exceptions — China, India and Indonesia — gender differences in meat consumption were larger in countries with higher development and gender equality scores.
The sheer number and cultural diversity of people surveyed is “a real strength of this,” said Daniel Rosenfeld, a UCLA social psychologist who studies eating behavior and moral psychology and who was not involved in the study.
The study didn’t answer the question of why men tend to eat more meat, but scientists have some theories. One is that, evolutionarily, women may be hormonally programmed to avoid meat that is possibly contaminated, affecting pregnancy, while men may have sought out meat proteins given their history as hunters in some societies.
But even the idea of men as hunters is intertwined with culture, Rosenfeld said. That is a good example of another theory, which maintains that Social norms shape gender identity from a young age and therefore the way people decide to fill their plates.
Rosenfeld, who stopped eating meat about 10 years ago, said his own experience in college “as a guy hanging out with other friends” illustrated the cultural pressure on men to eat meat. “If everyone eats meat and I choose not to, this can disrupt the natural flow of social situations.”
The same cultural factors that shape gender influence how people respond to new information, said Carolyn Semmler, a psychology professor at the University of Adelaide in Australia, who also studies meat consumption and social factors such as gender. Semmler was not involved in this study. In some of her previous work, she studied cognitive dissonance around meat consumption.
In those cases, she noted, women who were presented with information about poor animal welfare in the livestock industry were more likely to say they would reduce their meat consumption. But men tend to go in the opposite direction, she said.
“One participant told me, ‘I think you guys are trying to get me to eat less meat, so I’m going to eat more,’” he said.
Semmler said meat can be important to masculine identity, highlighting, for example, the popular notion of men on the grill. And he said presenting eating less meat as a moral cause can be a sensitive issue. Still, he said, people should be aware of how their food choices affect the planet.
But she and Hopwood recognized how difficult it is to change behavior.
“Men are a tough nut to crack,” Hopwood said.
Jose Lopez, another diner at the Dog House Grill, said men should eat less meat, but said he has generally observed the opposite.
“We are carnivores. Men eat like savages,” she said.
