Federal officials said this week that the pain people feel when they have an intrauterine device (IUD) inserted may be more than doctors’ promise of “just a pinch.”
Lidocaine, a local anesthetic, “may be helpful in reducing patients’ pain” when IUDs are inserted, according to a new recommendation from the U.S. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), which also encourages doctors to have a conversation with patients about pain management.
Women have taken to social media to advocate for more pain management options, even recording and posting videos to document their grimaces, screams and tears when having IUDs inserted. But complaints about pain aren’t limited to the small, long-lasting contraceptive device.
Many relatively quick outpatient procedures can cause pain, including biopsies and exams of the uterus and cervix. Gynecologists and patients say there needs to be more conversations about options for local anesthetics — as well as other alternatives for pain relief during these procedures.
Pain relief options
Using lidocaine spray or gel as a local anesthetic and other pain treatments — such as ibuprofen or an anesthetic injection — are safe for most patients and can be effective, gynecologists say.
The CDC’s new recommendation is just that — not a strict guideline. And Rachel Kingery, a spokeswoman for the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, said in an emailed statement that there is no timetable for the group to provide clearer guidance on pain management for office-based procedures.
All of Dr. Cheruba Prabakar’s patients who get an IUD inserted also receive a local anesthetic spray at a minimum. The owner of Lamorinda Gynecology and Surgery in Lafayette, California, near Oakland, also schedules 45-minute appointments for her patients where she can thoroughly answer their questions and discuss their concerns.
Some places offer even stronger options. In March, following requests from its patients, the Planned Parenthood League of Massachusetts office added sedation options for IUD insertions and certain procedures in which doctors remove suspected cancers. Patients are not completely asleep, just drowsy.
Dr. Luu Ireland, an obstetrician/gynecologist with Planned Parenthood League of Massachusetts and the UMass Memorial Hospital Network, said there are gentler options for pain management, such as anti-anxiety pills and local anesthesia.
“I can’t tell you how many patients I’ve seen who choose less effective birth control methods or give up birth control (completely) because they’re afraid to undergo the procedure.”she said about IUDs.
Prabakar believes the biggest barrier to more patients having their pain taken seriously isn’t cost or equipment. It’s time and trust.
“There are a lot of patients with a history of trauma, a history of shame,” said Prabakar, who serves as an advisor to the Alliance for Women’s Health and Prevention. “They can barely tolerate a speculum, let alone some of these other procedures.”
Gynecology students should be taught from “day one” how trauma affects patients, said Dr. Deborah Bartz, an obstetrician-gynecologist at Brigham and Women’s Hospital who also teaches at Harvard Medical School.
That includes how anxiety levels and trauma can affect the level of pain a patient feels when she visits the gynecologist, and how people who have never given birth may be at higher risk for pain during such visits, she added.
Research shows that health care professionals regularly underestimate the pain of IUD insertion. Women of color are less likely to have their pain taken seriously by doctors and nurse practitioners; extensive research shows that black people receive insufficient pain treatment compared to white patients.
“If women have had their pain ignored since they were little girls and menstruating, they are more likely to be predisposed to experiencing trauma in the health care system,” said Kate Nicholson, executive director of the National Pain Advocacy Center, a nonprofit focused on policy change.
In defense of medication
When guidelines—or gynecologists—fall short, the onus may fall on the patient to speak up.
“(In obstetrics and gynecology) there’s this culture of, ‘Women are strong. We can do this without painkillers.’ But why? Why is that?” said Sarah Friedberg, a mother of three from Massachusetts who first experienced pain at the gynecologist when she had an IUD inserted 20 years ago — despite taking an over-the-counter painkiller.
Friedberg’s periods were always exceptionally heavy, and after having three children, her doctors recommended removing her uterus. In August 2022, she went to have blood drawn and other tests done in preparation for a hysterectomy. A doctor said they would need to take some tissue samples from inside her uterus.
This was the first time she had heard of the need for a biopsy and she had not taken anything for pain leading up to the procedure. Friedberg said no and that she needed to reschedule the appointment.
“I’m a person who, if I don’t like the nail polish I’m getting, I would never say, ‘Let’s not do that,’ or ‘This is wrong,’ or ‘I want something different,’” Friedberg explained. “In general, I like not to cause a fuss.”
She read about what the biopsy would entail in general terms. She found an option online — lidocaine spray — and asked her doctor for it. She had to search, but her doctor found it.
His defense paid off: he was not in extreme pain.
Friedberg hopes the updated CDC guidelines will mean women — including her daughter, when the time comes — will have a different experience at the gynecologist.
“But it’s very, very late,” he said. “It’s 2024. Get moving.”
What questions should I ask my gynecologist?
— What are my options for pain control? You will likely be prescribed one of three levels: oral (ibuprofen), local anesthesia (lidocaine spray or gel), or injection (paracervical block). Sedation may be an option, but you will likely need to book it in advance and arrange for someone to drive you home.
— How will I know how much pain I might feel? Everyone’s pain threshold is different, and your anxiety and stress levels can play a role. Talk to your doctor about your past experiences and concerns, even if you’re just nervous.
— What if my doctor won’t listen to me or provide the medication I request? Continue to advocate for yourself and come armed with knowledge. Experts agree that patients often don’t know their options, and the new CDC guideline encourages gynecologists to talk to patients first. You can always seek a second opinion if needed and time permits.
It’s not that complicated — it’s not “rocket science” — said Cheryl Hamlin, an obstetrician and gynecologist in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and director of reproductive care for the American Medical Women’s Association. Doctors just need to inform patients about their options, answer their questions and let them decide.
