:format(jpeg):focal(2000x829:2010x819)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/IYBC6KACRVG2HO6ZNDO3CNMARM.jpg)
Speaker of the majority in the House of Representatives, Angel Matos Garciaanticipated today, Thursday, that the House Project 1821, which proposes to criminalize the exposure of minors to “drag shows”, will not proceed in the legislative process.
“As chairman of the Rules and Calendar Commission, that will never see the sunlight of the chamber”assured the representative of the Popular Democratic Party (PPD), in a telephone interview with El Nuevo Dia. “With so much to do in the penultimate legislative session, persecuting the trans community is not the north,” he said.
The bill that proposes to amend the Penal Code of Puerto Rico seeks to classify “obscene exposure in front of minors” as a crime.
The measure, within this “obscene exposure”, includes “impersonating the male or female sex with clothing alluding to the male or female sex, without being limited to the use of wigs, masks or grotesque makeup in an establishment, open or closed facility, public or private, restaurant, theater, public thoroughfare or any property where artistic activities are carried out or that provide children’s or family entertainment.
The legislative piece –submitted by the representative of Dignity Project Lisie Burgos Muniz– would impose penalties of three years in jail or a fine of $5,000 to “any person who exposes, facilitates, performs, participates, promotes or organizes” “obscene exposures” in front of minors.
The representative opined that the project joins a “painful repertoire of legislation presented by the Dignity Project that in no way contributes to effective legislative work.”
“There is no state of necessity, there is no study, there is no statistic that leads us to conclude that Puerto Rico has a crisis of misinformation for our children in relation to drag”added the Carolina representative district legislator, who described the legislation as “the deepest expression of hate, misinformation and ridicule.”
A dangerous move beyond drag
For Inaru Nadia de la Fuente Diazactivist of The Umbrella Leatherthe project targets trans people in Puerto Rico, not just those who do “drag”, an art that includes performance, dance, music and makeup, and which was popularized by the various communities that make up the LGBTQ+ community.
“On the surface, yes, this would seem to be aimed at people who do drag, but the way the project is developed and created, the ambiguity it has within it, allows for a number of interpretations that are directed to trans people, specifically not to have us on the street”indicated De la Fuente Diaz to The new day.
Precisely, the language included in the bill refers to “grotesque makeup”, the use of wigs and “impersonating the male or female sex”, but does not define any of the concepts.
Matos Garcia classified the broad language of the project as “subjective”, which could include the criminalization of cultural presentations, the interpretation of characters that include drag and even people who wear wigs after hair loss due to health conditions.
Meanwhile, De la Fuente Diaz commented that “the person who discriminates if this (proposed) law were passed, who discriminates does not really distinguish between a person who does ‘drag’ and a trans person, and that is what people do not understand . Trans women are going to be the most reported if this type of law is passed, because a homophobe or a transphobe on the street cannot distinguish between a person who does ‘drag’ and a trans person, for this person it will be the same“, he pointed.
In addition, he stressed that the United States jurisprudence that obscenity is not protected if it lacks artistic value, which the project cites in its introduction, would not apply to “drag”, since “‘drag’ is an art”. , pointed out the activist.
Childhood as justification
As written, the cameral project seeks to criminalize the exposure of children to “obscene” content. This is the same justification given by Republican lawmakers in states like Florida, Arizona, Tennessee, and Colorado, where bills have been proposed or passed. similar measures.
However, for De la Fuente Diaz, this is more of an excuse, which in turn responds to the unprecedented visibility that trans people are having. “If, in effect, they wanted to protect children, they would be constantly developing legislation created to help children in one way or another,” she pointed out.
In fact, this is not the first time that the Dignity Project has sought to intervene with “drag” presentations for exposure to children. As recently as last June –when LGBTQ+ Pride Month is celebrated–, Senator Joanne Rodriguez Veve criticized the fact that storytelling was offered to children as part of the “Express Yourself Glitter Pride.”
“I do not know exactly how the events will take place in the announced activity that motivates these expressions. I don’t know if, in effect, the organizers intend to recreate in PR the scenes of states and countries where ‘drag queens’ read stories to children in schools, libraries and other spaces. But, if this were the case, I maintain, drag queen shows are shows for adults, which adults have a perfect right to attend. Not the kids. Let the children be children,” Rodriguez Veve wrote at the time.
Later, the administration of the T-Mobile District tried to adjust the activities of the event, which caused the producers –the organization Waves Ahead Puerto Rico– to move the celebration to their headquarters, on Avenida Americo Miranda. In the activity, drag artists and LGBTQ+ activists read stories to children.
In a previous interview with The new daythe clinical psychologist Irma Torres-Rivera He opined that he does not consider that the art of drag has a negative impact on children. However, he emphasized that children should not be exposed to hypersexualized content, which can also be seen in advertising, social networks and television, among others.
The new day He tried, on multiple occasions, to obtain an interview with the representative Burgos Muniz, but at the time of this publication it has not been granted.
