
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Monday restored a murder conviction in the disappearance case of Etan Patz, a 6-year-old boy who disappeared in New York City in 1979.
The justices, by a vote of 6 to 3, accepted the appeal of New York prosecutors, who had asked them to overturn the decision of a federal appeals court that overturned the verdict. The three liberal justices disagreed.
Prosecutors had been preparing to try the man, Pedro Hernandez, for the third time. His first trial ended in a nullity.
A unanimous panel of the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit overturned Hernandez’s conviction for murder and kidnapping in the second trial because of the way the judge responded to a question from jurors.
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg had called the basis for overturning the conviction “a flimsy argument” that essentially ignored a five-month trial with 66 witnesses.
The justices agreed, in an unsigned opinion, that federal courts should not second-guess state court decisions under a 1996 federal law that sought to reduce federal courts’ oversight of state criminal trials.
“The Second Circuit exceeded its authority in holding that Hernandez is entitled to relief,” the justices wrote.
Hernandez, 64, has been serving a sentence of 25 years to life in prison.
Bragg, a Democrat, welcomed the high court’s decision.
“This office has remained steadfast in its pursuit of justice for Etan and the Patz family and will continue to support this important conviction,” the prosecutor stated in a statement.
Hernandez’s lawyers expressed themselves “terribly disappointed” by the ruling.
“We firmly believe that an innocent man is in prison for a crime he did not commit,” said attorneys Harvey Fishbein and Alice Fontier.
Hernandez admitted to the crime during a police interrogation, but his lawyers maintain that he falsely confessed because of a mental illness that sometimes caused him to hallucinate. They stressed that the admission came after police questioned him for about seven hours before reading him his rights and recording the interview. Hernandez then repeated his confession on tape at least twice.
Etan disappeared while walking to the school bus stop in midtown Manhattan on May 25, 1979. Hernandez, a resident of Maple Shade, New Jersey, was then working at a nearby convenience store, but did not become a suspect until 2012.
Etan was among the first missing children to appear on milk cartons, and the anniversary of his disappearance became National Missing Children’s Day.
Hernandez has already been tried twice. A jury failed to agree in 2015, and then a different panel of jurors found him guilty in a new trial in 2017.
During deliberations, the 2017 jurors asked a complicated question: If they decided that Hernandez did not voluntarily confess when he had not yet been read his rights, should they dismiss his other confessions? The judge at the time responded simply: “the answer is no.” The jury proceeded to convict him.
In overturning that verdict, the appeals court said the jury question should have received a more complete answer, including the possibility of downplaying all confessions.
This story was translated from English to Spanish with an artificial intelligence tool and was reviewed by an editor before publication.
