
According to recently declassified court documents, a plan to auction more than 100 objects rescued from the remains of the Titanic —including personal belongings, money, kitchen utensils and decorative elements— is encountering opposition from the Government of USA.
RMS Titanic Inc., the company that owns exclusive salvage rights to the famous North Atlantic wreck, wants to sell the artifacts for the first time, despite previous agreements that stipulated they would only be displayed in museums and traveling exhibitions.
The Georgia-based company RMS Titanic proposed auctioning the objects and displaying them on a world tour of four cities, although these locations have not yet been publicly revealed. Court documents filed in the United States referred to the company’s plan to sell objects such as a bronze cherub, a gold nugget necklace and a heart-shaped pendant.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) represents the interests of the United States and monitors the wreck site. The agency maintains that such a sale would violate RMS Titanic’s legal obligations to the site, according to documents ordered released by a judge earlier this month.
Arguing that the auction should be banned, the Government noted that the company “does not request authorization from the Court, does not consider that such authorization is necessary and affirms that there is no impediment to selling” the objects.
Representatives for RMS Titanic did not respond to requests for comment Monday. Their attorneys had previously asserted, in a brief filed in federal court, that the proposed auction agreement would not violate court orders or agreements in place regarding the artifacts.
This is the last attempt to sell Titanic objects
Since 1987, rescue operations have recovered thousands of objects and even fragments of the Titanic’s hull. The RMS Titanic profits from its exposure.
Over the decades, the company has tried to sell objects to finance future exploration and cope with its financial difficulties. However, these attempts were met with strong opposition from US courts, as well as heritage groups and victims’ families. Some of the objects recovered belonged to the ship’s passengers.
However, items kept by survivors or pulled from the water by rescuers can be sold and often fetch considerable sums. A life jacket worn by a passenger sold for just over $900,000 in April, while a gold pocket watch given to the captain of the ship who rescued the survivors sold for nearly $2 million in 2024.
Auction houses say the unwavering fascination with the Titanic — which sank in 1912 after hitting an iceberg on its maiden voyage from Europe to New York, killing more than 1,500 people — and the rarity of the objects add up to high demand and exorbitant prices.
A transatlantic dispute over objects
RMS Titanic wants to auction some of the first objects recovered from the wreck. These objects were transferred to France, where their ownership was granted to the salvage company. The French oceanographic institute IFREMER collaborated with the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in the discovery of the wreck.
The rest of the collection was recovered during subsequent expeditions, and the rescue suit was filed in a U.S. district court in Norfolk, Virginia.
NOAA maintains that the roughly 5,000 objects — regardless of whether ownership was claimed in France or the United States — should remain in a single collection, according to conditions set by the U.S. court. NOAA also maintains on its website that conditions imposed by a French court required that the artifacts not be sold separately and be kept together as a single collection.
The company has argued, among other things, that the US court lacks jurisdiction over the assets claimed in France.
French government representatives did not respond to requests for comment late Monday.
Fragments of history for all to see
Some underwater explorers have been against the idea of selling Titanic artifacts, saying they should be displayed in the public interest.
“I have no problem with objects being recovered from the Titanic, as long as it is done carefully and using appropriate archaeological techniques.”said Greg Stone, a veteran marine explorer and scientist. “I would feel calmer if it were a non-profit initiative.”
Richard Daynard, a law professor at Northeastern University School of Law in Boston and a public interest specialist, said the rules on the display and sale of Titanic artifacts are intended to preserve the wreck for the public benefit, so that they cannot be “acquired by billionaires to flaunt their wealth and power”.
“If it’s something that someone can walk around their house and say, ‘Yeah, I bought it for $5 million and it’s an original Titanic item,’ that’s not good at all,” he said.
