The alleged confession that Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera would have made her best friend, in which she admitted to stabbing Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario16 years old, was admitted as evidence in the jury trial being followed against Elvia Cabrera Rivera.
This was reported by the superior judge Luis S. Barreto Altieri, of the Aibonito Court, by announcing this Wednesday, during the beginning of the thirteenth day of the jury trial against Cabrera Rivera, his decision on the pending controversy.
“The Public Prosecutor’s Office proved with a preponderance of evidence that the statements were made during the conspiracy,” the judge determined. “They are admitted in evidence,” he said, before requesting that the 12 members of the jury enter the courtroom.
The alleged confession and other statements attributed to Aviles Cabrera were admitted under Rule 803 of Evidence, which includes several exceptions to the prohibition of presenting reference evidence or “hearsay.”
This rule allows certain statements made outside of court to be admitted as evidence because they are considered sufficiently reliable, even when the person who issued them is not testifying at that time before the judicial forum.
1 / 26 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
In this criminal case, the court’s determination implies that the jury will be able to hear the testimony about the expressions that Aviles Cabrera allegedly made and assess its weight along with the rest of the evidence presented during the trial.
Last Wednesday, Gabriela “Gaba” Figueroa Arroyo testified against Cabrera Rivera, mother of her best friend and also a co-defendant in the case. During his testimony, he reiterated that Aviles Cabrera confessed to him that he had allegedly stabbed Pratts Rosario.
The admission was made 15 minutes after leaving the Roberto Colon detour, near the urban center of the municipality, where Pratts Rosario, affectionately known as “Lela”, was mortally wounded during a brawl.
Likewise, Figueroa Arroyo maintained that, after that alleged confession and after the death of Pratts Rosario, Aviles Cabrera wrote to him through the TikTok application that he should only do what his mother—in reference to Cabrera Rivera—told him.
Although Figueroa Arroyo had already made these statements during the preliminary hearing, his testimony now takes on greater importance when presented to the jury, which will have the responsibility of determining the guilt or innocence of the accused.
During the last hearing, the prosecutor Silda Rubio Barreto He stated in court that the alleged instruction shows that Cabrera Rivera was the one who gave the orders to his daughter. Therefore, he asked the judge to admit said information as evidence in the court case.
“(Evidence) how the two of them agreed to, in some way, silence (the witness),” he said. “Here, the one who gave the orders, in accordance with those messages, was the accused to the other co-accused,” he added, trying to convince the man.
However, the attorney Mayra Lopez Mulerolegal representative of the accused, said that “those admissions are admissible against the person who made them, but not against Elvia, but now they have invented a theory that the expressions were made in the course and advancement of the objective of a non-existent conspiracy.”
