
The federal prosecutor’s office and the Municipality of Ponce reached an agreement to avoid charges related to risky conditions for the hawksbill turtle in the La Guancha area.
The agreement was signed on June 17 by the mayor of Ponce Marlese Sifrethe lawyer Natalia Cervonihe U.S. Attorney Timothy Henwooddirector of the Criminal Division in Puerto Rico, and by his counterpart from the Financial Fraud and Public Corruption Section, Seth Erbe.
According to the text of the agreement, by October 5, 2023, Ponce officials were notified that the lighting in the La Guancha area “did not comply with regulations related to wildlife, including hawksbill turtles,” a species protected by federal law.
On October 11, 2023, the then mayor of Ponce, Luis Irzarry Pabona press release circulated announcing an initiative to replace the lighting in La Guanchaincluding replacing white bulbs with LED units (Light Emitting Diode) that are imperceptible to the turtles’ eyes.
However, the federal document stated that “from at least August 1, 2023 to October 24, 2024, the Municipality of Ponce did not take adequate measures to ensure compliance with the applicable regulations related to lighting in La Guancha, which could cause the capture and death of hawksbill turtles”.
It notes that, in particular, the Municipality of Ponce placed two mobile lighting towers in the La Guancha parking lot, next to the beach, with “large bulbs that are not safe for turtles, violating applicable regulations.”
The Federal Prosecutor’s Office highlighted that in the aforementioned period of time, in La Guancha, “Approximately 151 hawksbill turtles” were affected – as defined by federal law – because “of the Municipality of Ponce, as a result of the lighting installed and used by officials, employees and representatives of Ponce.”
The document included at least seven dates on which, according to the Federal Prosecutor’s Office, there were turtles that were affected, without specifying whether they died, were injured or what other damage they may have suffered.
“Ponce admits, accepts and acknowledges that, under United States federal law, it is responsible for the acts of its officers, employees and agents that give rise to the activity described,” the city council stated in the federal agreement.
The Federal Prosecutor’s Office agreed to “defer prosecution of the crime in accordance with the terms and conditions.”
The agreement went into effect on June 17 and lasts for three years. The municipality will be subject to monitoring and inspections for an additional year.
The document also stated that as part of the conditions, the Municipality of Ponce must take measures, including replacing dangerous lighting, building and renovating barriers, installing signs, alerting local merchants, relocating merchants away from the shore and planting shrubs.
The inspection reports will be delivered in the first 15 days of the months of January, April, July and October.
After being alerted to the investigation, “(The Municipality of) Ponce cooperated promptly,” including “providing periodic updates on corrective measures taken, meeting with United States (officials), and participating in a voluntary site visit with a prosecutor and agent.”
“Ponce is committed to establishing and maintaining compliance measures and internal controls,” he added. “This agreement can ensure that La Guancha is a safe place for endangered species, while preserving the United States’ ability to prosecute should serious breaches occur.”
