Four years ago, the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) received a landmark report alleging that the top leaders of the country’s largest Protestant denomination had long downplayed allegations of clergy sexual abuse, intimidated victims and hindered reforms.
The convention’s 2022 annual meeting passed a resolution apologizing to victims of abuse, mentioning several of them by name. In addition, he authorized a series of reforms that included the creation of a database of Church workers against whom credible accusations were made.
It seemed to mark a moment of reflection within the SBC, in line with the broader #MeToo and #ChurchToo movements, as well as a recognition that sexual abuse by clergy extended far beyond the high-profile scandal of the Catholic church.
However, prominent survivors and advocates have largely stopped trying to push for change in the SBC after witnessing what they see as increasingly faltering efforts at reform.
And now, a contrary version has reached the highest levels of the convention leadership. Prominent members of the Southern Baptist Convention espouse the view that, although sexual abuse has occurred in the SBC, it never reached a “crisis” level.
Sexual abuse has become politicized
The newly elected president of the SBC, Florida pastor Willy Rice, has described the 2022 report prepared by the consulting firm Guidepost Solutions as a “partridge hunt.” Rice stated that some people, for political reasons, “used” the issue as a weapon against this large conservative denomination.
Texas megachurch pastor Jack Graham, former president of the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC), also denied there had ever been a “systemic sexual abuse crisis” in the denomination.
“This whole thing has been nothing more than a reckless deception that has cost us not only millions of dollars, but also incalculable damage to our testimony,” Graham recently posted on the social network X, alluding to the costly lawsuits and the impact on the SBC’s reputation.
For survivors, those words are traumatic, but not surprising.
“Everyone who saw us lead reform also saw us suffer verbal attacks, smears, harassment, and ultimately be discarded,” survivor Tiffany Thigpen posted on X. He attended the 2022 annual meeting to advocate for reform, but has avoided recent meetings.
Rice said churches should provide training on abuse prevention, report “any indication of illegal activity to appropriate authorities” and care for victims.
“The sexual abuse reform initiative was certainly weaponized, just as the #MeToo movement was weaponized in secular culture,” Rice said. He drew a comparison with the accusations of sexual assault against the judge of the United States Supreme Court, Brett Kavanaughwho denied them and described them as politically motivated.
Rice said churches, like other youth organizations, have learned a lot about this issue.
“To the extent that there have been occasions where Baptist churches or institutions have not adequately handled cases of abuse, that has harmed our witness,” Rice acknowledged at a news conference held at the conclusion of the SBC annual meeting earlier this month in Orlando, Florida. “We have tried very hard over the last few years to correct that situation.”
The refusal to view sexual abuse as a crisis—a view that was once marginal in the SBC—is increasingly becoming mainstream. Rice’s only rival for the SBC presidency, Josh Powell, took a similar stance.
Rice was elected at an annual meeting where delegates also approved a constitutional ban on SBC churches having female pastors, a measure that must be ratified next year.
They do not pursue any political objective
Christa Brown—a survivor of sexual abuse by an SBC pastor and a longtime advocate for reform—said that if anyone was politicizing the issue of abuse, it was the people involved in the SBC’s power struggles, not the victims.
“For victims of clergy sexual abuse, there has never been anything to gain by coming forward. On the contrary, it almost always comes at a high personal cost,” he said by email. “There is no political agenda.”
He added that “there is no place within the SBC where a person who has suffered sexual abuse by a pastor or church collaborator can safely report it and receive an appropriate response. I have been working in this area for more than two decades, and this reality has not changed.”
The convention’s 2022 annual meeting authorized the creation of a database of Church workers credibly accused of sexual abuse, as well as the creation of a task force to oversee reforms. The working group was later disbanded without the database being created, in part due to liability concerns.
The matter was referred to the religious denomination’s Executive Committee, which, in turn, is referring churches to existing databases on sex offenders, while focusing on abuse prevention and education.
Brown said sexual abuse by members of the clergy is especially traumatic. Abusive religious leaders often use the religious language of spiritual authority and forgiveness to manipulate a child’s trust.
“Sexual abuse by clergy has a dynamic of its own (and this is something most SBC leaders just don’t seem to understand…or don’t want to understand),” he wrote.
Jules Woodson, a survivor who at previous meetings advocated for anti-abuse reforms in the SBC, said on
2019 report uncovered allegations of sexual abuse
SBC skeptics of the idea of a systemic abuse crisis often turn to numbers.
A 2019 report titled “Abuse of Faith”reported by the Houston Chronicle and the San Antonio Express-News, revealed that about 380 Southern Baptist church leaders and volunteers faced sexual abuse allegations over the past two decades, with more than 700 victims. The newspapers relied on publicly accessible records, such as arrests, lawsuits, and confessions.
Skeptics stated that, for a religious denomination with more than 40,000 churches and millions of faithful, these figures were regrettable, but they were not symptoms of a general crisis.
However, advocates point out that cases of abuse often go unreported, especially when the abuser is in a position of authority and often receives protection from other Church leaders.
By comparison, a landmark report on the Catholic Church by the John Jay College of Criminal Justice benefited from access to internal Church documents about cases that had not been made public. The report revealed that more than 4,000 priests were accused of abuse between 1950 and 2002, representing approximately 4% of those practicing at the time.
“Given that the publicly reported cases (which are largely based on criminal convictions) are just the tip of the iceberg, people should be horrified at what the size of that tip reveals about how enormous the SBC clergy sexual abuse iceberg almost certainly is as a whole,” Brown wrote.
The Guidepost report concluded that survivors were repeatedly met with “resistance, evasions and even outright hostility from some” members of the denomination’s Executive Committee. According to the report, those in charge of the main churches did not report the abusers either to the police or to their congregations.
Two of the people mentioned in the Guidepost report sued the SBC for defamation; Their cases are still pending.
Critics have also questioned the report’s depiction of cases involving the women, arguing that they were consensual relationships that, while sinful, did not constitute abuse. The women themselves described these acts as assaults or abuse in their statements before the court.
However, victims’ advocates say there is more than enough evidence of failures at high levels, even beyond Guidepost’s criticism of the Executive Committee. They cite the 2018 firing of the seminary’s influential rector, Paige Patterson, for his handling of rape allegations, as well as multiple allegations of abuse against the late Paul Pressler, who was once a dominant figure in SBC politics.
Pastor Bruce Frank of North Carolina, who chaired the Sexual Abuse Task Force created in the wake of the “Abuse of Faith” report, said survivors have understandably lost hope in religious reforms.
“We’ve accomplished something. It’s not been what many people who have been through it could reasonably expect,” said Frank, pastor of Biltmore Church, based in Arden, North Carolina.
He favored creating a database of pastors against whom credible accusations have been made, in order to prevent predators from moving into unsuspecting congregations.
“Ultimately, how do you protect the largest possible number of people in a decentralized structure with loose ties, in a place that relies heavily on volunteers?” he said.
