The defense of Anthonieska Aviles Cabreraone of those accused of the murder of the teenager Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario16 years old, occurred in Aibonitehe insisted before the Supreme Court in that it is not appropriate to charge him with the crime of murder in the first degree.
In a reconsideration document, which consists of 10 pages, the legal representation of Aviles Cabrera requested the highest judicial forum of Puerto Rico to reevaluate its determination not to dismiss the charge of first-degree murder contained in the indictment.
The Supreme Court has not yet issued a resolution on the reconsideration brief, which addresses legal figures such as “attenuated murder” and “sudden pendency,” and gives relevance to amendments introduced in 2014 by the Legislature to the Penal Code.
The graduate Emma Cristina Torres Martinez, of the Society for Legal Aid (SAL)Appellate Division, presented to the Supreme Court the brief in which the defense sets out the arguments that must be considered to dismiss the charge.
Currently, Aviles Cabrera and his mother Elvia Cabrera Rivera They face two charges each of first-degree murder and violation of the Weapons Law for events dating back to August 10, 2025, when the victim was injured on the Roberto Colon detour.
Although the case against Cabrera Rivera is already in the jury trial stage, with the parade of 12 witnesses over 13 days, that of Aviles Cabrera will begin on June 29. At the moment, it has not been reported whether it will be by jury or court of law.
“We request the review of a determination that declared the dismissal of the indictment of first-degree murder inadmissible, since during the preliminary hearing no evidence was presented that there was a concert and common agreement to murder on the night of the events, nor was it proven that before the sudden fight the petitioner had the purpose or plan to murder or cause serious bodily harm or that she had gone armed to the detour that night,” the letter says.
He adds that “according to the evidence presented, on the night of the events, the Petitioner did not have any problems or confrontation before the sudden fight occurred that she entered with the purpose of stopping.”
“In the middle of that fight, the Petitioner and the deceased grabbed each other by the hair and during the fight, without any pause or cooling time, the petitioner received a sharp object with which Gabriela Pratts was allegedly killed. The fight ended the moment Gabriela Pratts fell to the floor,” says the document presented on June 22.
In the reconsideration brief, it is alleged that “the factual situation that occurred in the instant case does not constitute the crime of first-degree murder since there is no evidence that the petitioner had the intention of murdering that night before she was involved in the sudden fight that broke out.”
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
The appeal states that upholding the accusation for the crime of first-degree murder has the effect of violating due process of law by “exceeding the reasonable contours of interpretation when there is a total absence of evidence” that Aviles Cabrera had the intention to murder before the fight.
The defense alleged that the amendments to Law 246-2014 incorporated attenuated murder and replaced the “outburst of anger” with mental or emotional disturbance sufficient as a reasonable excuse, which made the criteria for the application of this crime more flexible.
Likewise, he indicated that the amendments in law recognize the figure of sudden quarrel, associated with sudden fights, which do not require prior provocation, as long as the existence of a confrontation without the intention of killing is demonstrated.
“The accusation of first-degree murder is not appropriate and sustaining it results in a failure of justice by ignoring the changes accepted by law in the figure of attenuated murder, so we very respectfully request reconsideration,” states the letter in reconsideration.
1 / 6 | Evidence in images: the raid on Elvia Cabrera’s house. The Police executed a search and seizure warrant at the residence of the accused, Elvia Cabrera Rivera. – Judiciary
The defense maintained that there is no evidence of coordination between the accused or intention to kill the victim during the fight. Furthermore, he stressed that the Prosecutor’s witnesses do not allow us to specify who caused the fatal wound to Pratts Rosario.
“On the night of the events, several fights broke out simultaneously, a riot broke out. There is no evidence that the petitioner made verbal statements to Gabriela Pratts while they were fighting or that she continued hitting Gabriela Pratts’ body when she fell to the ground,” he indicated.
The defense referred to the testimony of Gabriela Figueroa Arroyo, who stated that Aviles Cabrera allegedly told her: “Gaba, Gaba, I stabbed her,” and that later, in a conversation on the TikTok application, he told her: “You will simply do what mommy says.”
“At no time is there evidence that the petitioner stated that she had intended or would have wanted to kill Gabriela Pratts. Nor did Gabriela Figueroa observe the moment in which Gabriela Pratts fell or who injured her before she died. Gabriela Figueroa’s expressions regarding the message she alleges she received from the petitioner through the TikTok application (indicating that she was going to do what her mother told her) in no way evidence that there was a plan to murder Gabriela Pratts,” he emphasizes.
The defense argued that the Public Prosecutor’s evidence only demonstrates that the death occurred during a sudden unplanned fight, which, in their opinion, does not support a charge of first-degree murder.
