
Between complaints of “constitutional usurpation” and alleged partisan political revenge, the delegation of the New Progressive Party (PNP) in the Senate approved this Thursday the legislation aimed at restructuring the Judiciarya measure that minorities classified as a “democratic dismantlement”, but that the parliamentary majority defended because they understood that it resolves a historical debate on the administration of the courts.
“It is one thing to organize the lower courts, establish jurisdiction and regulate appointments within the constitutional framework, and quite another to use legislation to redefine the structure of the Judiciary and subordinate its independence to the convenience of the political moment,” said the senator. Jose A. Santiagoof the Popular Democratic Party.
“The line between legitimate regulation and constitutional usurpation is not blurry, it is clear, and this measure crosses it”added Santiago, during the debate that lasted two hours.
Since its presentation, the Senate Bill 1096approved with 18 votes in favor and seven against, faced opposition from various judicial structures and experts in Constitutional Law, who pointed out that it violates the separation of powers that the magna carta establishes among the regulatory functions of the plenary session Supreme Court and the executive authority of the presiding judge, a position held Maite Oronoz Rodriguez since 2016.
Approved in the Senate on the last day allowed for it in this ordinary session, it went to the House of Representativesbut it was not attended to, remaining pending for the next cycle, in August.
“To say that, in some way, this project aims to take away powers from the president of the Supreme Court is to lie, and it is to lie knowing the falsehood that is being said”expressed, for his part, the president of the Senate and author of the piece, Thomas Rivera Schatz.
“If we were wrong in approving this legislation… whoever thinks so can go to court, they can take us and make the case,” Rivera Schatz added. “The Constitution has always said that the Judicial Power of Puerto Rico will be exercised by the Supreme Court. “Any person of average intelligence understands that.”
As part of the discussion in the chamber, a floor amendment was approved that reversed a previous change and returned the minimum professional experience requirement to seven years, instead of five, to hold the position of judge of the Court of First Instance.
“This unfortunate moment is the ‘we sweep’ attitude that you (PNP) repeat to us, becoming the total unfortunate banquet of another era. It is the same pattern that we have seen in other democracies that are emptying themselves from within, not by coup d’etat, but by legislation or executive orders.“Santiago pointed out.
Since the promulgation of the Constitution of the Commonwealth in 1952, the presiding judge has had the power to appoint the administrative judges of each judicial region and appoint the assistant directors who work under the director of the Office of Court Administrationfunctions that opponents of the project consider would now pass to the full Supreme Court, creating dislocations in the management of the Judicial Branch.
“What this project does is clarify exhaustively, clearly and directly, what has been, since 1951, the debate about who administers the Judicial Branch and, Although it is true that the majority of the associate judges of the Supreme Court belong to the honorable New Progressive Party, the first thing that everyone has to remember is that they are legal experts, those called to defend the Constitution“said the senator Roxanna Soto Aguiluof the PNP.
For her part, the spokesperson for the Puerto Rican Independence Party, Maria of Lourdes Santiagorecognized the partisan nuance that has surrounded the island’s courts, recalling that, in the past, the colloquial way of referring to the Supreme Court was as the “second popular committee of Puerta de Tierra”. However, he harshly criticized the PNP’s measure, warning that “Two evils together do not make a good and revenge should not be a principle that guides legislative action”.
Regarding the legislative intention to prospectively eliminate the category of municipal judge to standardize the structure of the Court of First Instance, Santiago pointed out that the municipal courts represent an important service in access to justice by addressing matters, such as the attention of protection orders by Law 54 and requests for forced mental health hospitalizations (Law 408).
Other measures approved this Thursday were the Senate Bill 782to strengthen the organizational structure of the municipal police; and the Senate Joint Resolution 195which allocates $4.7 million from revenue generated by “on-road gambling machines” to distribute among several municipalities, in order to strengthen their operations and the provision of essential services.
Also, they were approved House Bill 1316, which proposes creating a special mechanism to facilitate the registration in the Property Registry of municipal plots located in urban centers; and the House Bill 1304to eliminate the mandatory container scanning model at ports.
