Austin, Texas— The Board of Education of Texas approved this Friday a list of mandatory readings for more than 5 million public school students that includes passages from the Biblebolstering conservative efforts to push Christian teachings into American classrooms.
The Texas State Board of Educationcontrolled by Republicans, approved the list drawn up by detractors, who argued that the titles lacked diversity and blurred the separation between Church and State enshrined in the United States Constitution. Proponents of the measure claim that Judeo-Christian traditions were fundamental to the founding of the nation and that this should be reflected in the curriculum of public schools.
The proposal, which requires the reading of literary works such as “Great Expectations” by Charles Dickens, along with passages from the New Testament, has been closely followed by education experts, who say it appears to be the first of its kind in the country. It represents a change from the usual practice of letting schools or teachers decide what students read.
The implementation will be carried out in a phased mannerstarting with primary school students in 2030.
Texas, home to about one in 10 public school students, has been at the forefront of a conservative-led campaign to incorporate more religion into classrooms. The state also allows public schools to hire chaplains to counsel students, requires the Ten Commandments to be displayed in classrooms, and has approved an optional Bible-based curriculum.
Christianity in the spotlight
Critics say the reading list lacks diversity, blurs the separation between church and state enshrined in the Constitution and leaves teachers and students with little room to decide what to read.
“Texas schools welcome children of all faiths and those of no faith, and all of them should feel welcome,” said Elva Mendoza, legislative communications officer for the progressive organization Texas Freedom Network. “But this sends the message to children that a single religious text – a Christian one – is the only one that deserves to be part of this required reading list.”
Others have welcomed the possibility of imposing the reading of Christian religious texts in public schools. Brooke Mazel, a Lubbock retiree, encouraged the council to adopt biblical materials, saying her children and grandchildren grew up with “a strong faith and family values.”
“America should celebrate our 250th birthday, as we were born as a nation with unwavering Christian values,” Mazel said.
The board also plans to vote this Friday on a social studies curriculum that relates biblical stories to American history.
Texas could be a pioneer
A state law passed in 2023 required that a mandatory list of at least one literary work be taught in each course. The proposed new list contains around 200 texts, including Bible passages, essays and books, far exceeding that requirement.
Antero Garcia, president of the National Council of Teachers of English and a Stanford University professor, said he doesn’t know of any other state that has a required reading list that includes religious texts. According to Garcia, it is usually educators at the district and school level who choose the texts that their students will read.
Kasey Meehan, Program Director “Freedom to Read” by PEN Americaagrees that this measure is “exclusive” to Texas.
Stories from picture books for elementary school students, including “David and Goliath” and “Daniel and the Lions’ Den,” are part of the required reading list. In fourth grade, students will read passages about Jesus from the New Testament.
By high school, students are expected to read several passages about Jesus, including some from his most famous sermon and another in which he urges people to set aside earthly concerns and seek the kingdom of God.
For high school students, the list includes reading specific Bible passages as supplementary material for literary works, including works by Dickens and Jane Austen’s “Pride and Prejudice.”
Diversity under control
“Such strict requirements amount to “almost de facto censorship,” Meehan said, comparing the list to book bans.
“Without a doubt, it has a more conservative ideological orientation,” he said. “It excludes many diverse voices from the reading list.”
The list requires that students who read Shakespeare’s “The Tragedy of Julius Caesar” also read a eulogy for President Ronald Reagan written by former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, a staunch conservative.
Frank Strong, an English and journalism teacher and co-founder of the student advocacy group “Texas Freedom to Read,” said diversity is not only important for students to identify with what they read, but also as a way to learn about different cultures.
Many of the books on the reading list are not controversial, but Mendoza wonders why books like “Chicka Chicka Boom Boom” have to be required reading for kindergarten children.
“Can’t we trust our kindergarten teachers to choose board books?” asks Mendoza.
