
He Municipality of Camuy He sued yesterday, Monday, at Department of Natural and Environmental Resources (DRNA) to request that a stoppage order that the agency issued against a project to improve the Penon Brusi recreational area, which, according to the city council, has the required permits, be revoked.
The lawsuit, before the Court of First Instance of Camuy, alleges that DRNA watchers They issued said order on June 24, after visiting the site and concluding that the works were being carried out “in violation of the granted permit.”
The Municipality – which describes the determination of the DRNA as “illegal, arbitrary and inadmissible”– explains that the order is based on “allegations about the discharge points and the stormwater pipe, mentioning the need for the permit of the USACE (United States Army Corps of Engineers) and disagreement with the Categorical Exclusion obtained. The DRNA watchdogs also pointed out that a demarcation permit was needed because the project would allegedly be located in terrestrial maritime zone (ZMT)”.
He adds that said order does not identify “which specific activities that were being carried out at the time of the inspection constituted a violation of the Single Incidental Permit. On the contrary, it is limited to formulating general references related to future components of the stormwater system, without establishing how the work corresponding to Phase I violated any legal or regulatory provision.”
The project in controversy, which seeks to “resolve the problem of stormwater accumulation on the access road to the Penon Brusi recreational area,” includes – in Phase I – the rehabilitation of sidewalks, curbs, electrical improvements, bathroom areas and existing recreational areas.
“The works are of a rehabilitation nature of existing infrastructure, without expansion of the disturbance footprint or intervention in natural areas not previously impacted”legal recourse abounds.
According to the 26-page document, Phase II of the initiative includes the installation of discharge points for the storm drainage system. He adds that the Municipality was in the process of submitting information to the USACE to determine whether or not this work “would require federal authorization.”
“It should be noted that the Municipality, In the project design, I had taken the precaution of not installing the final discharge headwalls until the USACE determined whether a permit was required.precisely, to comply with the regulatory processes applicable to Phase II,” reads the lawsuit.
“Even accepting, solely for argumentative purposes, that the DRNA had some legitimate concern related to the stormwater discharge components projected for a later stage of the project, this could never justify the absolute cessation of independent works that consist exclusively of the rehabilitation of sidewalks, curbs, existing pavement and other surface improvements included within Phase I,” the document argues, emphasizing that said phase was “subject to the final determinations of the DRNA and/or the USACE.”
The lawsuit questions the decision to paralyze all of the works despite the fact that the initial phase does not involve “in any way discharge to bodies of water, nor any activity in the maritime-terrestrial zone, nor any component that would require a USACE federal permit.”.
Among the “concrete and immediate” damages, the Municipality listed work stoppage with contractual commitments with the contractor MJO Builders, LLC; daily loss of committed federal ARPA public funds; failure to comply with the execution deadlines established for the use of ARPA funds; mobilization and demobilization costs of equipment, personnel and materials; deprivation of the citizens of the Municipality of Camuy of a safe and accessible public recreational facility; and harm to the public interest.
The lawsuit asks the Court – among other things – for a provisional interdict prohibiting the DNER from complying with the stoppage order.
