Editor’s note: Visit this special site to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
With the start of jury selection in the Aibonite Courtthe trial against Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera He faces his first challenge starting this Tuesday: find 12 people capable of deciding the case only with the evidence presented in court, despite extensive media coverage.
The challenge is not minor. Over the past few months, the case has remained at the center of public conversation due to the separate trial against his mother, Elvia Cabrera Riveraco-accused with Aviles Cabrera for the murder of the teenager Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years oldoccurred in August 2025.
This process has generated constant coverage on television, radio, written press, digital platforms and social networks, where testimonies, videos, photographs and evidence have been exposed. which has been admitted, until this moment, as part of the test parade carried out by the Public Ministry.
“We know that it will be difficult to find people who in Puerto Rico have not been exposed to the test, to the evidence, without Anthonieska having had the opportunity to defend herself,” said the lawyer. Rocio Revelles Ponceof the Society for Legal Aid (SAL)one of the defendant’s defenders.
Likewise, he commented that “it has not been visualized” that the accused testifies during the trial. He added that requesting a change of jurisdiction in response to the extensive media coverage of the case is also not being considered, maintaining that the dissemination has been so extensive that it even transcended the United States.
“Jury selection began today, but the reality is that this young woman has been tried since day one. Here tests have been passed, sworn statements have been discussed here, all kinds of photographs have been passed around without Anthonieska having had the opportunity to defend herself,” added Revelles Ponce.
To questions from the press, he added: “We are going to see how feasible it is, with all the coverage it has had, with the transmission of the evidence in the mother’s case (Elvia Cabrera Rivera), to get people who have not been exposed not only to comments, but to the paraded evidence that has been absolutely published.”
Despite the challenge of finding an impartial jury, Revelles Ponce – who together with lawyers Maria Soledad Saez and Athelyn Jimenez Emmanueli makes up the defense – indicated that changing from a “jury trial” to a “court of law” for the judge to evaluate the evidence is not on the table.
Along the same lines, Saez stated that the extensive coverage of the case has not revolved around evidence presented during the judicial process. In his opinion, much of the public discussion has been based on interpretations outside the trial. “There have been people discussing the case in the media and making adjudications of guilt,” he said.
Precisely, the media exposure was one of the main arguments of the defense when requesting that the panels of candidates called to form the jury be discarded. The lawyers argued that potential jurors could be “contaminated” by the information disclosed.
1 / 6 | Evidence in images: the raid on Elvia Cabrera’s house. The Police executed a search and seizure warrant at the residence of the accused, Elvia Cabrera Rivera. – Judiciary
However, the judge Juan A. Reyes Colon rejected the request. In its resolution, it determined that the appropriate mechanism to guarantee impartiality is not to replace the panels, but rather the selection process, where the parties can identify and exclude those who do not meet the conditions to be impartial.
During the first day of selecting potential jurors, 27 candidates appeared in court, 14 men and 13 women. However, 19 of them were excused for medical and personal reasons, so only eight remained in the room at the end of the day.
As part of the judicial process, the officer gave initial instructions to the candidates and warned them about the extensive media coverage of the case. He emphasized that they should refrain from reading, listening or seeing information related to the trial, which continues on July 6 and 24 in the morning.
“Our justice system requires that a fair and impartial trial be guaranteed.. To achieve this, they must observe the following behavior until they render the verdict,” said Reyes Colon, who warned potential jurors that they cannot discuss the case with anyone.
“Likewise, they are told that no event that occurs outside the courtroom can affect their willingness to evaluate evidence. They will not be able to search for information, investigate or visit places that have to do with the case.”the judge instructed.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
“During this process, they are being ordered that they cannot listen to, read or watch news reports, radio reports, social media reports, podcasts or any other media about the case or the people involved in the process. They must completely discard and not consider any information obtained by any of these media or by any other source,” he stressed.
The man stated in the room that “you will not comment or discuss this information among yourselves or with other people or on social networks or in any other media.” Likewise, he mentioned that, although they hear references to places, “under no circumstances will they be able to visit them during this process.”
For her part, the prosecutor Belinda Brignoni He acknowledged to the press that jury selection “is going to be a long process,” at a time when six new panels of jury candidates have been named for July 24.
To questions from The New Day Regarding how complicated the process could be, Brignoni explained that that is what the process of disqualifying potential jurors is for. “Both the Public Ministry and the defense and the questions that his honor (the judge) already asked are aimed at finding the suitable jury,” he stressed.
“If that jury, for any reason, has any bias or any circumstance that prevents it from participating in this specific case, that jury is challenged, whether motivated or peremptory. For this, the prosecutor and the defense have a number of peremptory and motivated challenges if there is a reason,” he concluded.
But concern about the impact of media coverage is not new. During jury selection in the trial against Cabrera Rivera, the defense warned that the “media noise” could influence the candidates and affect the impartiality of the process, an approach that resurfaces in the case of his daughter.
Therefore, the task takes on an additional dimension because both processes, although separate, are closely linked. Much of the evidence presented during Cabrera Rivera’s trial makes direct reference to Aviles Cabrera, including photographs and messages taken from cell phones.
