
The split ruling of the Supreme Court from the United States that children born in USA are citizens under the Fourteenth Amendment — even if their parents are in the country illegally or only temporarily — exposed deep fissures in the justices’ positions on the issue and among themselves.
The court’s two black justices, notably, had very different views on American citizenship in the context of Reconstruction after the Civil War.
Tuesday’s decision rejects an order that President Donald Trump issued at the start of his second term, declaring that children born to people who are in the United States illegally or temporarily are not American citizens.
The majority, composed of the president of the Court, John Roberts, and Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, Amy Coney Barrett and Ketanji Brown Jacksondetermined that being born on American soil and being subject to American law is sufficient for citizenship.
Several dissidents, including judges Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alitosay that birth alone is not enough: the child’s parents must have a deeper political allegiance or relationship with the United States.
Jackson’s direct disagreement with Thomas’s dissent highlights an important fissure between legal minds. Here are the judges in their own words:
Chief Justice John Roberts
Much of Roberts’s opinion was a history lesson on English common law, in which he concluded that birthright citizenship has always depended primarily on the place of birth, not the immigration status or domicile of one’s parents.
“Citizenship, then and now, was the right to have rights: to participate freely in our political community. The framers of the Fourteenth Amendment extended that promise to ‘every person born free in this land.'”Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the court, citing the congressional debate over the amendment. “Today we keep that promise.”
“We broke no new ground today,” Roberts said from the bench as he read the court’s majority opinion.
Judge Clarence Thomas
Thomas, who wrote the lead dissent, dissented from the majority opinion and argued that children born in the United States are not automatically American citizens.
The basis of his argument, among other things, is that the court ignored evidence from the Reconstruction debates that suggested that citizenship depended on a deeper relationship with the country. Following the Civil War, the United States endured a series of political and constitutional battles over how to define the civil rights and citizenship status of formerly enslaved African Americans.
“The Citizenship Clause was enacted for people who were born in this country and called it home. It was enacted for freed slaves like Dred Scott, who had ‘a domicile’ here and therefore had the right to sue as a citizen,” Thomas wrote in his dissent, concluding that Reconstruction was a remedy aimed at freed slaves to restore citizenship to an unjustly excluded group.
“In my judgment, the Citizenship Order is not unconstitutional on its face,” Thomas wrote, referring to Trump’s executive order. “The Order is consistent with the original meaning of the Citizenship Clause, at least to the extent that it applies to children born to parents, here legally or illegally, who are not domiciled in the United States.”
Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson agreed with the opinion in its entirety, but wrote to respond to Clarence Thomas’s dissent, arguing that Thomas fundamentally misunderstands what the Reconstruction Amendments—the Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments—were intended to accomplish.
“Despite its long-standing support for a ‘colorblind’ ConstitutionJustice Thomas now surprisingly suggests that the Citizenship Clause was a race-conscious remedial measure, relating only to ‘freed slaves like Dred Scott,’ but that narrow view of the Fourteenth Amendment bears little bearing on the history of its ratification.”
“The Reconstruction Amendments were an anti-caste, anti-subordination reset for the nation, not a mere localized treatment for the dark stain of slavery.””.
“The Court’s conception of a colorblind Constitution and the Government’s limited, group-specific reading of the Citizenship Clause—and the main dissent—are two sides of the same coin, stemming from a basic misunderstanding of the relevant history.”
