Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
Aibonite – For the first time before a court, the best friend of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario16, recounted under oath what happened on the night of August 10, 2025, when the teenager was murdered and he was also injured with a knife, in a testimony considered one of the most anticipated.
On the 15th day of the trial against Elvia Cabrera Riveraaccused of the crime, the young man identified by the initials CGR, 17 years old, entered room 1 of the Aibonite Court at 9:04 a.m. this Wednesday holding a stress ball in his hands. He then took a seat on the witness stand.
Subsequently, a victim support technician was authorized to enter the courtroom, a key figure in preventing revictimization, reducing stress and guaranteeing a safe and dignified environment in judicial processes for people who have gone through traumatic events, such as a murder or other violent incidents.
As is customary, the 12 main members of the jury and the five alternates made their entrance and then the prosecutor’s questioning began. Silda Rubio Barreto. As part of the initial framing of the testimony, CGR stated that Pratts Rosario’s name was familiar to him, since they were best friends.
As for the afternoon of Sunday, August 10, 2025, she recalled that, between 5:00 pm and 6:00 pm, she was at the house of her best friend, whom she nicknamed “Pratts,” helping her put some curls in her hair, since they were planning to attend the Great Municipal Summer Closing, an activity that was being held that day in the square.
They were going for the summer closing
At that moment, he recalled that there were only four people in the residence: CGR, Pratts Rosario, her cousin—whose name is unknown—and Paola Sofia Carpena Solivan. “Later, when we were all ready, we left for the summer closing on foot,” said the youngest, visibly nervous.
Speaking in a low tone, which on several occasions caused the judge to intervene to draw his attention, the witness added that, once they arrived in the urban area of the municipality, he remembers that they went to the El Maestro Liquor Store business, where they were talking with Pratts Rosario’s family.
Dressed in black clothing and with a necklace that had a transparent figure in the shape of an angel, he said that, at that moment, Pratts Rosario, Carpena Solivan, a cousin of his, and him were there. Later, he indicated that the group moved to the Picadera business, then to the Monument, and they returned to El Maestro.
“We were talking to each other: Pratts, Fabiola (sister of Miriathny and Anthonieska ‘Antho’), Lismary (sister of the victim) and I don’t remember who else. Afterwards, we were at the Monument and in front of the Master (on the other side of the road) are Antho and Miriathny,” commented the witness.
“They (Anthonieska and Miriathny) came to talk to Fabiola. We finished and went down to the detour (Roberto Colon). There was me, Pratts, Paola, Dylan (Pratts Rosario’s friend), Rey (Reinaldo, the boyfriend of Lismary Torres, Pratts Rosario’s sister). I don’t remember who else. We walked down,” stressed the young man.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
Gabriela “was normal”
At that moment, he assured that he noticed that Pratts Rosario “was normal.” “We went to look for food. (There was) Dylan, me, Pratts and Paola. (We went) to town in Dylan’s vehicle. We were going to eat some triplets, they were closed. Then we passed by McDonald’s, it was full and we decided to return to the detour,” he said.
It was at that moment, according to his story, that he decided to call his brother, who is nicknamed “Papucho”, to go pick him up at the detour. Meanwhile, he said he remained “chatting” with Pratts Rosario and Carpena Solivan. “She (Pratts Rosario) was calm. We were on the verandah (on the detour),” he said.
Immediately afterwards, he commented that he observed that his brother “Papucho” had arrived at the detour aboard a green Vitara and accompanied by his friend Luis. “Later, I say goodbye to Pratts (Rosario) because I’m leaving. She was calm. I sat in the green Vitara and started using my cell phone,” commented the teenager.
“Later, I see that Anthonieska, Anthiany, Miriathny, someone in a blue suit (who does not remember her name) and Elvia arrive (at the detour). I was using the cell phone for about four minutes. I was writing to my best friend. Then, I see that Fabiola, Miriathny, Lismary, Anthiany and Antho are talking,” he added.
“I don’t remember who else was there. They were arguing. From what I saw, I see Anthiany and Lismary arguing. Anthiany punches Lismary in the face. (There) they started fighting, (but) I don’t remember well (who). At that moment, I don’t remember where Pratts was. They started fighting (all of them),” he commented.
1 / 6 | Evidence in images: the raid on Elvia Cabrera’s house. The Police executed a search and seizure warrant at the residence of the accused, Elvia Cabrera Rivera. – Judiciary
He didn’t see where Elvia was
The witness indicated that at that moment he did not see where Cabrera Rivera was while the situation occurred. He added that he later decided to get off the bus he was on because he didn’t see Pratts Rosario, so he went out to look for her. That’s when she realized someone was hitting her.
“I headed towards the fight. I see the one in the blue suit punching Pratts (Rosario) from behind. I don’t know who she is. I hadn’t seen her before. She was hitting him here (said the young man touching the upper part of his shoulder, just on the right side),” he said. “My reaction was to separate them. I separated the one in the blue suit,” he commented.
“I see Anthonieska grab Pratts by the hair. There was a vehicle nearby. I tried to (separate them), as if to stop him from grabbing her hair. I took Anthonieska’s hands out so she would stop pulling her hair. I didn’t see Elvia. When everything was over, I take Pratts in my arms and I see that Dylan and Rey are coming to pick her up,” he said.
However, the witness did not indicate who stabbed his best friend nor who attacked him. “About five minutes passed. (During that period of time), I was in the fight. They stabbed me in the back, near the spine. I didn’t see who stabbed me,” she said, reiterating that her friend suffered injuries in the incident.
“(I) had her (my friend) in my lap. There I realized that I had blood because my back felt wet. When the fight ended, I took her (Pratts Rosario) in my arms. She was stiff,” said the young man, while the sobs of the victim’s mother, Lisandra Rosario Berrios, could be heard in the living room.
1 / 5 | Outside the court: relatives of Gabriela Nicole Pratts demand justice. Relatives of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario arrived at the Aibonito Court to demand justice. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
“I was dizzy”
“I stopped and went to my brother, who was in the Vitara. The (bus) was at a distance from this wall to the other wall (about 35 feet). I don’t remember (what my brother was doing). I was dizzy. I see that someone gives me a yellow cloth and I put it on the wound. I don’t remember (who gave me that cloth),” he said.
This part of the story is important because it contrasts with what the victim’s aunt-in-law had indicated in the courtroom, Bethsaida Carattini, who assured that the minor, who supposedly called her “aunt,” had come to her requesting her help. However, at no point in his testimony did the minor mention her.
“I didn’t see her (Elvia). (They) put me in the green Vitara. I go to her mother’s house and throw myself into bed. Afterwards, my mother sees me with a lot of blood and decides to take me to the hospital. She took me to the Menonita hospital in her white Toyota bus. First, they wouldn’t let me go to the hospital. There were some patrols because there was an accident,” the young man commented.
Continuing his story, he mentioned that at that moment his mother got out of the vehicle and asked for help from one of the people he remembered had been on the detour. With this, he referred to Yandriel Davila Felicianowho, along with another young man, came to his aid and then helped him complete the journey to the hospital on foot.
“(The next thing I remember is that) I was on a stretcher praying that Pratts would not die. Afterwards I don’t remember much because of the medications. I felt bad because of the injuries,” said the young man, before three images were projected in the room: two of his back and the wound he suffered, and another of him on a stretcher.
1/9 | “Meeting for peace”: Aibonitenos carry out a march and vigil after violent incidents. Hundreds of people marched at the “Meeting for Peace” in Aibonito, in a call from the Parish of Aibonito to end acts of violence. – Supplied
He doesn’t remember what he told the police.
“When I was in the hospital, I saw some guards. I don’t remember how they were dressed. They were asking me what happened. I don’t physically remember what I looked like or what I said to them,” the witness mentioned, going into another detail that also becomes important because it contrasts with other testimony.
And the agent Alfredo Fortier Soto declared under oath on May 1, the day the parade of evidence in the trial began, that CGR pointed out Aviles Cabrera, 18, who is being judged as an adult in the case, as the person who hurt her best friend the night of the tragic incident.
“(After that) they took me by ambulance to San Juan to the Medical Center. I don’t remember (how long I was in the Medical Center),” said the minor, who also did not remember who the prosecutor was who conducted the interview after the events. “I don’t know the name. I was feeling bad,” he was heard saying in the room.
He indicated that, regarding the clothes he had on the night the crime occurred, he kept them in his house. Later, he gave it to a “girl with glasses,” who he also could not identify. “I don’t remember the name,” he pointed out, thus closing one of the most anticipated testimonies in the notorious judicial process.
For its part, the defense declined to cross-examine the witness. This is the third time that the accused’s legal representation refuses to ask questions of a witness from the Prosecutor’s Office.
The morning culminated with the stipulation of the testimony of the minor’s mother so that she would not have to testify in court. This stipulation confirms that the minor’s clothing was delivered on August 18, 2025 to an agent to be analyzed at the Institute of Forensic Sciences.
