Washington – President Donald Trump and his fellow Republicans are taking up a line of attack against Democrats ahead of the midterm elections: they are communists.
In the last week alone, Trump has issued grim warnings claiming that members of the Democratic Party’s rising left are communists who want to “completely destroy the traditional American way of life” and even commit murder. Vice President JD Vance has also pointed to communism as a political shift that is “something we haven’t seen in the United States.” House Speaker Mike Johnson has condemned “radical candidates” who “call themselves and identify as Marxists.”
The Republican Party’s ideological approach has been gaining strength since Zohran Mamdani, a democratic socialist, won the Democratic primary for New York mayor last year. However, this trend has accelerated recently, after democratic socialists won several congressional primaries in New York City last week. The victory in Tuesday’s primary of another democratic socialist, Melat Kiros, for a Denver congressional seat, suggests the trend could extend beyond Manhattan liberalism.
“The Democrats are making it easy for us,” Representative Richard Hudson, Republican of North Carolina and head of strategy and fundraising for the Republican Party in the House of Representatives, said in an interview. “They are nominating extremist liberals, leftists who are disconnected even from the mainstream of the Democratic Party.”
Republicans retain a slim majority
This communications campaign comes as Republicans struggle to maintain their fragile majorities in Congress ahead of the November midterm elections. It equates democratic socialism—which typically focuses on ensuring universal healthcare, increased taxes on the richest, and stricter regulation of businesses—with communism, in which private property is virtually eliminated.
1/7 | A tour of Donald Trump’s Washington DC: this is how the president leaves his mark on the capital of the United States. This combination of images shows Black Lives Matter Plaza on 16th Street NW near the White House on March 10, 2025 (above), as signs and markings were beginning to be removed, and on April 1, 2025, after work was completed.
In addition, there is a risk of overlooking the frustration of citizens – especially among younger voters – with capitalism without limits, at a time of growing income inequality and rising prices.
But it also offers Republicans a much-needed opportunity to refocus the debate on ground they are more comfortable with, after their party spent much of the year on the defensive over the fallout from Trump’s decision to go to war with Iran, which contributed to a widespread rise in prices.
Ralph Reed, the veteran conservative activist who hosted Trump last week at a Faith and Freedom Coalition conference, acknowledged that Republicans face great difficulties this year. However, he noted that Democrats’ recent streak of victories allows Republicans to draw a contrast between “common sense and insanity.”
Democrats are not clear about the direction of the party
This new push could stoke tensions among Democrats, who, while largely united in their dislike of Trump, are divided on the direction of the party. This year’s primaries are shaping up to be a referendum between centrists — eager to correct course after what they see as progressive overreach earlier in the decade — and the left, which advocates even more radical change.
“A lot of this anger has been brewing beneath the surface,” said Joseph Geevarghese, executive director of Our Revolution, an organization founded by U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders, a Vermont independent who is part of the Democratic caucus. “At this moment it is coming to light in a very forceful way.”
However, Rep. Josh Gottheimer, a centrist Democrat from New Jersey, called the victories in Colorado and New York “anomalies.”
“We have to fight tooth and nail to prevent the socialists from taking control of our party,” he said. “Most of them are agitators, not problem solvers.”
Nevada Attorney General Aaron Ford easily prevailed over a more progressive challenger earlier this year in the Democratic primary for governor, in a state Trump won in 2024. As he prepares to take on Republican Gov. Joe Lombardo in the general election, he insisted that candidates like those who won in New York do not represent all Democrats.
He stated that the Democratic Socialists of America “do not represent our party.”
Rep. Susan DelBene, D-Wash., chairwoman of the House Democratic campaign committee, said in a statement that Republicans were “resorting to desperate attacks that, in reality, have nothing to do with economic issues.”
Trump risks going too far with his communism argument
Trump and his fellow Republicans risk missing the mark, at a time when public support for capitalism may not be as strong as it was decades ago.
According to an August Gallup poll, about half of American adults (54%) have a positive view of capitalism, down slightly from 61% in 2010. Democrats have been one of the drivers of this change, but favorable views of capitalism have also declined among independents.
Only 42% of Democrats had a favorable view of capitalism, while 66% had a positive view of socialism. The survey found that both younger and older Democrats have become slightly more receptive to socialism since 2010, but Democrats under 50 are much less likely to have a favorable view of capitalism. Democrats 50 and older have not changed their minds significantly.
“Young voters, who I believe are driving much of the electoral energy we’re seeing, have come of political age in a post-Soviet world,” Geevarghese said. “The attacks do not have the same effect as when Donald Trump came of political age.”
Hudson, who heads the House GOP campaign committee, acknowledged that the communism argument may not have the same impact among all voters, especially younger ones. Therefore, he stated, it is important for Republicans to adapt their message to the needs of each district.
“I’ve never run standardized campaigns where we just repeat the same thing over and over again everywhere,” he said.
1 / 15 | In photos: the faces of Donald Trump and his team after a violent incident at a correspondents’ dinner. President Donald Trump speaks in the James Brady Press Briefing Room of the White House following an unspecified threat during the annual White House Correspondents’ Association dinner, as Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche and FBI Director Kash Patel listen. -Jose Luis Magana
Even so, on Wednesday, during his visit to the newly inaugurated Theodore Roosevelt Presidential Library in North Dakota, Trump once again gave much importance to this issue. He referred to the former president as a “fierce opponent of something called communism.”
“It is the greatest threat to our country, even above World War I, World War II, Pearl Harbor and 9/11,” he said. “It is a bigger threat, potentially bigger than all of those, because it is like a cancer that spreads, and it better be stopped as soon as possible.”
Beverly Gage, a history professor at Yale University who has written about the rise and fall of Senator Joe McCarthy, said the anti-communist policies of earlier eras took hold because there was a large and active Communist Party in the United States and the Soviet Union was the country’s main enemy. However, he noted that Trump’s interest in this issue is notable, given his ties to Roy Cohn, a longtime Trump confidant who previously worked for McCarthy.
“You don’t have to take many steps to go from McCarthy to Roy Cohn and from there to Donald Trump,” he said.
California Governor Gavin Newsom, a possible Democratic presidential candidate, downplayed Trump’s accusations of communism, calling them “nonsense.” In an interview, he stated that the party’s orientation is not so different from the dynamics with which it has managed to operate for decades in California politics.
“I governed in an environment where the DSA was also known as the Progressives,” he said. “This dialectic is very familiar to me, and I don’t give it any more importance than it has.”
This story was translated from English to Spanish with an artificial intelligence tool and was reviewed by an editor before publication.
