Without having been cited by the Puerto Rico Police, Elvia Cabrera Rivera and his two daughters Anthonieska and Anthiany Aviles Cabrera They went during the afternoon of Monday, August 11, 2025, to the Aibonito district headquarters, but they remained silent.
This was revealed by the agent Angel Torres Romeroattached to the Homicide Division of the Criminal Investigation Corps (CIC) of Aibonitowho assumed the reins of the investigation into the crime of the minor Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years old.
During the prosecutor’s interrogation Silda Rubio Barretomentioned that the three women relied on the Fifth Amendment, which means that they exercised their constitutional right to remain silent so as not to incriminate themselves on the instructions of their lawyer.
Before initially going into these details, the prosecutor requested to activate Puerto Rico Rule 109 of Evidence, which caused the jury to be removed from courtroom 1 while the admissibility of this part of the agent’s testimony as evidence in the case was discussed.
“I was notified that a lady arrived with her two daughters at the barracks. It was Elvia with her two daughters. No one had summoned them. Nor had anyone summoned Gabriela Figueroa Arroyo “Gaba”, who before they arrived, also arrived at the barracks in the company of her parents,” he said.
He indicated that he proceeded to take them to the interview room and read them the “Miranda Warnings for Suspected Persons in Custody,” which remind people that they have the right to remain silent and refuse to answer questions.
These aspects of the agent’s statement were not heard in the electronic transmission, so they could only be heard initially by Judge Luis S. Barreto Altieri, of the Aibonito Court, the prosecutors, the defense and the public present in the courtroom.
“They read the warnings and decided not to do the interview. They informed me where they lived because I requested it. They did not provide any information related to the complaint. What Elvia told me was that she did not want to be interviewed because her attorney informed her so,” Torres Romero said.
According to the evidence presented, Cabrera Rivera signed the legal warnings at 1:58 pm on August 11, 2025 and “exercised the right not to testify,” as did his daughters Anthiany and Anthonieska, who did the same at 2:00 pm and 2:10 pm, respectively.
“I also asked them about the vehicle she owned and where she lived because I wanted to corroborate what Gabriela Figueroa Arroyo had told me on instructions from the prosecutor, who had already given instructions to search the house,” he commented.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
After this part of the testimony, the parties argued in open court the reasons why it should or should not be admitted as evidence. Attorney Alberto Rivera Ramos stated that, if it were admitted, the rights of his client should be preserved.
With this, he alleged that the agent violated his client’s constitutional right by stating the specific reason why he availed himself of the Fifth Amendment, a right that protects any citizen not to incriminate himself when he is suspected of a crime.
He even warned that this aspect of the testimony could trigger a mistrialwhich in criminal law translates as “mistrial” or “nullity of trial.” That is, a trial is interrupted or invalidated before reaching a verdict.
However, the judge did not accept the approach regarding the mistrialbut he did order to partially protect what would be declared before the jury. After this, a 20-minute recess was declared. Then, work resumed and the jury was ordered to enter the room.
With the 12 main members of the jury and the five alternates present at the hearing, the prosecutor resumed the focused interrogation on the arrival of the accused and her daughters to the barracks, but the testimony was limited to indicating that they did not want to offer expressions.
1 / 6 | Evidence in images: the raid on Elvia Cabrera’s house. The Police executed a search and seizure warrant at the residence of the accused, Elvia Cabrera Rivera. – Judiciary
He noticed cuts on Anthonieska’s fingers and hand.
Likewise, Torres Romero revealed that, when Aviles Cabrera, also co-accused of the Pratts Rosario crime, took the pen to sign the document on the warnings in law, he noticed that she had cuts on her fingers and right hand.
The agent indicated that this corroborated that the version offered by Figueroa Arroyo to the Police “was the correct one.” He explained that, before Cabrera Rivera and her daughters arrived at the barracks, Figueroa Arroyo had already gone to the facilities with her parents.
In that interview, Figueroa Arroyo stated that on the night of Sunday, August 10, 2025, when Pratts Rosario was seriously injured, Aviles Cabrera, near the La Placita Martinez business, showed her his bloody hands and told her: “Gaba, Gaba, I stabbed her.”
Pending to elnuevodia.com for the expansion of this news.
