Aibonite – Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
The sixteenth day of the jury trial against Elvia Cabrera Riveraaccused of the murder of the minor Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years old, left a key question in the air: is the end of a pink comb the object used to commit the crime?
During the interrogation of the prosecutor Silda Rubio Barretothe investigating agent Angel Torres Romero explained that, among the evidence at the crime scene, there was the incomplete comb that was analyzed by the Institute of Forensic Sciences (ICF).
“The comb was missing the part where it grips. It had a gap about an inch and a half (wide). The other part was about four or five inches (long).”the agent explained to the Chief Judge Luis S. Barreto Altieriof the Aibonite Court.
The description drew attention because it coincides with that contained in the accusation presented by the Public Prosecutor’s Office, which maintains that the victim was attacked with “a knife, sharp sharp object, approximately one inch wide and five inches long, with a sharp tip, or a similar object that can be considered a knife.”
Torres Romero, of the Homicide Division of the Criminal Investigation Corps (CIC) of Aibonito, confirmed that the comb preserved the part of the cells, but was missing the end. The evidence was removed from a brown paper bag and shown in the courtroom.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
The agent specified that the fragment of the comb was found at the scene during the morning of August 11, 2025, hours after the crime occurred on the Roberto Colon detour. The piece, along with a black shirt, was admitted as evidence.
Directly, the Public Prosecutor’s witness did not indicate that it was the murder weapon, but the prosecutor directed her questions so that the jury and the public present could infer that said object could have been the one that took the victim’s life..
“There are inferences that the jury will be able to make when they have the evidence in their hands,” the prosecutor told the press. “The evidence presented, which you heard, is that the other piece is missing,” added Rubio Barreto, who did not want to provide more details.
“They have to look at the test in its entirety and never forget that the most important thing is that Gabriela Nicole Pratts died there. And, obviously, while the mother is passing the test, she knows more about the investigation and the facts, she was there and perhaps that is why her reaction,” mentioned Rubio Barreto.
For his part, the agent confirmed that, as part of the investigation, only three witnesses have indicated that they saw the accused take something out of her purse: Lismary Torresthe victim’s sister; Bethsaida Carattiniaunt-in-law of the injured party; and a female identified as Leshandra, who has not declared.
On the one hand, the victim’s sister only indicated that she saw the accused take “something” out of her purse. Meanwhile, Carattini maintained that it was a “sharp object,” which is consistent with the story of Leshandra, who would have told the police that it was “as if it were a pen.”
1 / 6 | Evidence in images: the raid on Elvia Cabrera’s house. The Police executed a search and seizure warrant at the residence of the accused, Elvia Cabrera Rivera. – Judiciary
Accused remained silent
On the other hand, the agent revealed that Cabrera Rivera and his daughters Anthonieska and Anthiany Aviles Cabrera They went, hours after the crime, to the barracks without having been summoned by the policebut they remained silent and did not answer questions about the murder.
When asked by the prosecutor, she explained that the three women relied on the Fifth Amendment, which means that they exercised their constitutional right not to incriminate themselves on the instructions of their lawyer, whose name was not mentioned at any time.
“The warnings (by law) were read to them and they decided not to do the interview. They informed me where they lived. They did not provide any information related to the complaint (of the crime). What Elvia told me was that she did not want to be interviewed because her lawyer informed her so,” she said.
The agent also confirmed that Gabriela “Gaba” Figueroa Arroyobest friend of Aviles Cabrera, went to the barracks without having been summoned by the Police. In the interview, he said that Aviles Cabrera showed him his bloody hands and confessed: “Gaba, Gaba, I stabbed her.”
Theft of a vehicle
As part of the documentary evidence, the Prosecutor’s Office projected images from a security camera located in the vicinity of a furniture store, where the moment in which a red Hyundai car belonging to the victim’s mother was stolen was captured. Lisandra Rosario.
The researcher explained that the video corresponds to 12:36 am on August 11, 2025, at the Roberto Colon detour. In the recording, he said, it is observed when a green Vitara bus parks right next to the vehicle that was later stolen.
He added that he became aware of the theft because the victim’s mother came to the scene and informed him that her vehicle “was not where she had left it,” so he proceeded to refer the case to the Aibonito Stolen Vehicles Division.
1/9 | “Meeting for peace”: Aibonitenos carry out a march and vigil after violent incidents. Hundreds of people marched at the “Meeting for Peace” in Aibonito, in a call from the Parish of Aibonito to end acts of violence. – Supplied
The investigator clarified that this investigation was registered under the number 2025-13-005-2630 and was investigated by said specialized division. “It has nothing to do with the murder case because it is a stolen vehicle,” said Torres Romero.
He maintained that the car theft case was clarified and that it was not related to the murder. However, when he was about to reveal who was behind the robbery, he was stopped by the prosecutor and only managed to say that “he was…’s brother.”
Clothes and other details
During the interrogation, the agent also confirmed that the clothing that the Police found at Cabrera Rivera’s residence did not completely match what the accused were wearing on the night of the murder.
In this regard, images from a security camera were shown where, according to what he said, you could see the clothing that, for example, Cabrera Rivera had, which he described as a black short-sleeved shirt, with a bow on the back, and that he had a large purse.
However, holding the shirt that was taken from the residence, and that was marked by a specialized cannon, The witness indicated that this was not what was seen in the videos he analyzed.
The interrogation culminated with the controversial TikTok messages that Aviles Cabrera allegedly sent to her best friend, in which he instructed him to do only what his mother told him.
During cross-examination, the lawyer Alberto Rivera Ramosone of the accused’s lawyers, tried to question the credibility of the testimony by pointing out alleged deficiencies in the investigative process carried out by the Police after the crime.
Rivera Ramos indicated that the Police did not close the perpendicular accesses that led to the detour. “But if people went there and moved their vehicles from there, you don’t know, do you?” the lawyer asked. “I don’t know,” the witness responded in the courtroom.
Likewise, he inferred that the investigating agent did not carry out an exhaustive search to find, for example, the missing piece of the comb. “I did look at the detour,” Torres Romero assured when asked.
In fact, using a measuring ruler, the lawyer led the agent to recognize that the measurements he had on the comb were not correct. “I said approximately,” the witness answered.
The trial will continue on July 8.
