Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
He Supreme Court of Puerto Rico denied a second urgent motion for reconsideration presented by the defense of Anthonieshka Aviles Cabreraaccused of the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario16 years old, related to its processability.
“Evaluated the urgent second motion for reconsideration presented by the petitioning party, it is ruled out. Adhere to what was resolved. Notify yourself immediately,” indicates the one-page resolution issued yesterday afternoon, Friday, by the judicial forum.
With this action, the petitioner exhausted the opportunities available before the highest judicial forum to request the review of the appealed resolution, so the determination of the Aibonito Court “that the accused is prosecutable” prevails.
In turn, it was determined that the decision “means that the accused understands the nature of the judicial process she faces, can adequately collaborate with her lawyers in the preparation of her defense and is in a position to continue the criminal process.”
On June 4, the Society for Legal Assistance (SAL) presented a petition to the Supreme Court requesting the reversal of a ruling issued by the Court of Appeals, in addition to the suspension of the trial until its processability was reassessed.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
In its approach, the defense alleged that the Court of Appeals acted incorrectly in confirming the determination of the Aibonito Court, which had rejected a request to stop the start of the trial in order to evaluate the defendant’s prosecution.
According to the SAL, Aviles Cabrera, 18, who is being tried as an adult for the murder of Pratts Rosario, is a student in the Special Education Program, has an intellectual disability, and sufficient evidence was presented to meet the required standard.
It should be noted that at the beginning of the judicial process, in September 2025, the young woman was declared not prosecutable. However, after a second evaluation, a favorable determination was issued to continue the judicial process against him for the murder case.
Since then, no judicial forum on the island has accepted the defense’s approaches to action. However, the legal team has maintained that the young woman has cognitive functioning equivalent to that of a minor her age.
Both Antonieshka Aviles Cabrera and her mother, Elvia Cabrera Rivera, face two charges each of first-degree murder and violations of the Weapons Law, for the use and/or carrying of a knife. Both have separate judicial processes.
Cabrera Rivera faced his 16th day of jury trial as recently as yesterday, Friday. Meanwhile, jury selection in the trial against Aviles Cabrera began last Tuesday.
During the first day of selection, 27 candidates – 14 men and 13 women – appeared before the court. However, 19 were excused for medical and personal reasons, so only eight remained in the room at the end of the day.
As part of the process, the judge gave initial instructions to the candidates and warned them about the extensive media coverage of the case. He emphasized that they should refrain from reading, watching or listening to information related to the trial, which will continue on the morning of July 6 and 24.
“We know that it will be difficult to find people who in Puerto Rico have not been exposed to the test, to the evidence, without Anthonieska having had the opportunity to defend herself,” said the lawyer. Rocio Revelles Ponceof the SALTone of the defendant’s defenders.
He indicated that, for the moment, “it has not been visualized” that the accused will testify during the trial. He also added that there is no contemplation of requesting a change of jurisdiction due to the extensive media coverage of the case, maintaining that the exposure has been so extensive that it has even transcended the United States.
For his part, Judge Juan A. Reyes Colon explained in court to the potential jurors that “in our justice system it is required to guarantee a fair and impartial trial.”
He also instructed them that no external events should influence their evaluation of the evidence. “They will not be able to search for information, investigate or visit places related to the case,” he warned.
The events that gave rise to this case occurred on the night of August 10, 2025 when several fights occurred on the Roberto Colon detour, in Aibonito. As a result, Pratts Rosario and another 16-year-old minor suffered stab wounds.
Both victims were transported in separate vehicles to the emergency room of the Menonita hospital in Aibonito. However, at 12:35 am on August 11, 2025, Dr. Carla Mercado certified the death of Pratts Rosario.
For his part, the teenager who was injured recovered and recently testified in the trial against Cabrera Rivera. In court, the possibility has been raised that the end of a pink comb was the object used in the alleged attack..
