The controversy in the federal case involving Jensen Medina Cardona and other co-defendants has escalated to a new phase, now focused on the request to inspect the correctional institutions where the Prosecutor’s Office alleges that a drug smuggling conspiracy was executed.
In summary, the defense of 18 of the 34 co-defendants filed a motion before the federal court in which he argues that the government’s case was built around those facilities, so they need to inspect them to adequately prepare for trial before the district judge Silvia Carreno Coll.
“The government built this case around four correctional institutions; it named them in the indictment, alleged that the conspiracy operated within their walls and beyond, and now asks this Court to prevent defense attorneys from inspecting and studying them. That position is untenable,” the defense attorneys noted in the joint motion filed Friday.
The letter arose at a time when the July 9 hearing is approaching, in which the request presented by 18 of the 34 alleged members of the prison gang known as Group 31 will be heard on its merits.accused of conspiring to possess and distribute controlled substances in prisons, according to a document filed in December 2024.
In addition to Medina Cardona – convicted by the state for the murder of Arellys Mercado Rioswhich occurred in 2019 -, the petition is completed by Juan Carlos Ortiz Vazquez, Elias Martinez Rivera, Jose Luis Audain Rodriguez, Moises Mojica Torres, Ernesto Malave Santiago, Jim Almodovar Quirindongo, Ernesto Vergas Rodriguez, Abraham Rodriguez Cruz, Alexander Alvarado Almestic, Edwin Sanchez Rijos, Felix Serrano Roman, Harry Acevedo Mendez, James Santana Gonzalez, Kevin Hernandez Ruiz, Miguel Gonzalez Concepcion, Anibal Ramirez Alicea and Christian Candelario Feliciano.
The epicenter of the conflict: prisons as “case scenario”
For the co-defendants’ attorneys, The correctional institutions are not an isolated element in the case, but rather they became the very scene of the events.. They argued that the theory of federal prosecutor’s office It starts, precisely, from the fact that the alleged conspiracy was within the prisons.
In his writing, They emphasized that it is not possible to evaluate this theory without understanding the real functioning of the Guerrero correctional institutions, in Aguadilla; Las Cucharas, in Ponce; Bayamon 501; and Guayama 1000including its internal dynamics, the movements of the inmates and the physical barriers imposed.
Likewise, they raised questions that, they say, can only be answered through direct observation: how inmates move, whether they can communicate between modules and what real limitations security systems impose. They pointed out that the Prosecutor’s Office had access to the prisons and that they are at a disadvantage.
The fight over the “materiality” of the evidence
One of the most technical – but crucial – points of the confrontation is the “materiality” standard under Rule 16 of criminal procedure, which It is a way to decide if something the defense is asking for really matters in preparing the case. or if it is just a curiosity or a “general” request.
1/8 | Guilty: these are the key people on the last day of the trial against Jensen Medina. Jensen Medina Cardona upon arrival at the last stage of his trial for the murder of Arellys Mercado. – Vanessa Serra Diaz
However, the defense rejected the federal government’s position that the request does not meet that standard. “It is not enough that what is requested bears some abstract logical relationship with the issues of the case,” indicated the lawyers, who mentioned that the inspection could completely change the case.
The defense of the co-accused insisted that they have requested specific elements such as unit plans, movement controls and real conditions of interaction between inmates, which they consider essential to dismantle the Prosecutor’s narrative.
“Prisons are evidence,” the defense maintains
One of the strongest arguments in the brief is that the correctional institutions themselves constitute material evidence of the case. Lawyers argued that official documents or descriptions are not enough, and that the only way to evaluate the government’s theory is to directly observe the physical environment of the prisons.
Along these lines, they affirm that: “The government has already inspected these institutions… The defense has the right to see what the government has already seen. Reading descriptions or reviewing documents selected by the government is not enough. In this case, the institutions themselves are evidence.”
The government: security and institutional control
Meanwhile, the Federal Prosecutor’s Office formally opposed the defense of the co-defendants in the case inspecting the prisons mentioned in the alleged conspiracy, citing mainly “prison security and control concerns.”
“The defendants’ request should be denied because it seeks to inspect places that are not “under the possession, custody or control of the government”… In addition, it should also be rejected because, if granted, the inspections would unnecessarily create a situation that puts the safety of both inmates and Department of Correction and Rehabilitation (DCR) staff at risk,” the federal prosecutor’s office said.
“Finally, the accused do not explain why the requested information is material for the preparation of their defense or why less intrusive alternatives would not be sufficient to obtain it,” he pointed out.
The defense responds directly to this argument by ensuring that it is not about unrestricted access, but rather regulated and supervised inspections. They even propose strict conditions for any visit, including identification of participants, joint supervision and prohibition of contact.
