1 / 14 | Manhattan skyscrapers are stabilized after their columns bend. An office skyscraper, which was formerly the headquarters of the pharmaceutical company Pfizer, was evacuated due to fear of a possible collapse of the structure. -Angelina Katsanis
New York – A skyscraper under construction in Manhattan, which was at risk of collapse, was stabilized Tuesday night and authorities lifted some evacuation orders for nearby buildings.
“We have been monitoring the building for many hours and have not seen any movement,” Ahmed Tigani, commissioner of the New York City Department of Buildings, said at a news conference.
As night fell, residents were allowed to return to several of the seven buildings that were evacuated as a precaution.
Crews began emergency repairs Tuesday to stabilize a Manhattan skyscraper after some columns buckled and some levels collapsed, prompting a series of evacuations in and around the site.
The poor state of the work in the 1970s building – which is being converted into luxury apartments – was detected early on Tuesday. Construction workers at the scene and people in nearby buildings, including a school, diplomatic offices and several hotels, in the busy Midtown corridor, were hastily evacuated after firefighters showed up around 8 a.m. Mayor Zohran Mamdani described it as “an extremely serious situation.”
His office later reported that a team had assessed the building “floor by floor” and observed no additional movement of the damaged columns, giving contractors the green light to move forward with emergency repairs. On Tuesday night, workers could be seen shoring up damage inside the gleaming glass and steel skyscraper.
That work is expected to continue, affecting an area of Manhattan near the famous Grand Central station, which is a landmark for travelers and residents as well as tourists.
Fears of collapse prompted evacuation orders
The building, which is the former headquarters of pharmaceutical giant Pfizer, is within walking distance of New York City landmarks such as the Chrysler Building and the United Nations headquarters.
Leila Bozorg, one of Mamdani’s vice mayors, said it is “encouraging” that the building did not appear to be shifting as officials climbed up and passed the damaged floors on their way to the 37th floor, the last one.
But from the street you could see through a large glass window on the 21st floor a highly deformed structural column. The fire department, which also released images of the column, said they found several cracks and sinking floors.
Hours earlier, when asked if there was concern about a collapse, Fire Department Chief John Esposito said that because of the way the steel-frame building is constructed, “it wouldn’t be a total collapse, it would be more of a localized collapse.”
Still, nearby buildings and streets remained evacuated for much of the day, including a school and the Israeli consulate across the street. The old Pfizer building was virtually empty at the time, except for construction workers.
Ramesh Yallappa, a tourist who was evacuated from a nearby hotel, said that when immediate evacuation was ordered on Tuesday morning, he initially feared it was a fire in the hotel.
“At that moment, we were very, very scared,” he said.
Developer says new expansion caused the damage
With more than 1,600 units, developers say the project is the largest office-to-housing conversion in the city’s history. Gensler, the architecture firm spearheading the project, says on its website that it is transforming a pair of 1970s office buildings by adding more than a dozen floors and redesigning an adjacent tower.
Buildings department records show the project has been fined by the city for several safety violations, including glass and metal falling from the building, along with an incident in which a worker fell from a ladder.
Spokespeople for Gensler and MetroLoft, the project’s developer, did not respond to messages seeking comment.
But in a statement to The New York Times, MetroLoft emphasized that the building itself is not at risk of collapse and that no debris fell from the construction site.
Nathan Berman, founder of MetroLoft, told The Wall Street Journal that the damage was likely due to the added weight of widening the top 15 floors or so of the building. Perhaps the two columns that buckled were not adequately reinforced, he told the newspaper.
“Why those two columns in particular and nothing else? We don’t know,” Berman told the Journal. “We are looking into that.”
He maintained that the integrity of the building was not compromised.
“95% of the building, the structure is sound and intact,” Berman told the Journal. “There is no way this corner of a small addition will suddenly tear down this building.”
Experts say more repairs may be needed
Emily Guglielmo, a California-based structural engineer, said the columns that buckled are likely beyond repair, so they will have to be removed and replaced.
“A lot of these things — cracks, warps, sinkholes — these things probably can’t be recovered,” he explained.
Replacing the columns will require rigorous analysis, and repairs will be expensive, experts said.
The short-term solution is to shore up the structure and floors, said Abi Aghayere, a professor of structural engineering at Drexel University in Philadelphia.
Shoring involves installing four-legged scaffolding to temporarily support the load the structure is supposed to support until the columns can be replaced, Aghayere said.
Yi Bao, an associate professor of civil engineering at Stevens Institute of Technology in New Jersey, said the building could have damage beyond the columns that buckled, which could have redistributed loads to other parts of the building.
Ed Miller, a resident of the area, said he walks under the building’s scaffolding several times a day, but will look for other routes home from now on.
“The building was pretty old,” said Miles Grant, who said he used to work at the property. “It definitely needed a lot of work to be ready for residential use.”
This story was translated from English by an AP editor with the help of a generative artificial intelligence tool.
