Provo, Utah – Lawyers for the man accused of killing conservative activist Charlie Kirk will question the reliability of DNA evidence that, according to the prosecution, links the accused to the alleged murder weapon, when the week-long hearing continues on Wednesday.
A member of Tyler Robinson’s defense team questioned an FBI DNA analyst Tuesday about the techniques she used to link Robinson to a rifle found wrapped in a towel at Utah Valley University, where Kirk was shot in September while addressing a crowd.
Defense attorney Michael Burt cast doubt on the analyst’s conclusions, an issue that will likely come up again during the five-day preliminary hearing.
“You cannot link Mr. Robinson to the samples tested,” Burt concluded.
Utah County Deputy Prosecutor Ryan McBride responded that the reliability of the DNA evidence could be tested if the case went to trial. He suggested that the preliminary hearing was not the right time to address that issue.
“The point is that there are explanations that lend themselves to different interpretations and arguments,” McBride said. “The court will determine at trial whether they meet the reliability threshold.”
1/21 | What is known about Tyler Robinson, the suspect arrested for the murder of Charlie Kirk? A relative of the alleged murderer of conservative commentator Charlie Kirk was the one who handed over to the police Tyler Robinson, the suspect who killed him, who would have “confessed or insinuated” to be the author of the crime, the governor of Utah, Spencer Cox, reported this Friday. Photo released by the Utah Governor’s Office shows Tyler Robinson. – Utah Governor’s Office via AP
The prosecution intends to seek the death penalty in this case. They are trying to convince Judge Tony Graf that they have enough evidence to put Robinson on trial for aggravated murder.
Robinson has not yet commented on the charges and his attorneys have not commented on his guilt or innocence. However, they have tried to have the death penalty ruled out, so far without success.
The prosecution must demonstrate that it has sufficient evidence to hold a trial
FBI analyst Amanda Bakker said that after Robinson’s roommate provided a DNA sample for comparison, she was able to rerun her tests and attribute all the DNA to two people.
Investigators found the towel and the suspected murder weapon — a bolt-action rifle with a shell casing — in a wooded area near where Kirk was shot.
The DNA found on the towel matched that of two people, according to Jennifer Faumuina of the State Bureau of Investigation. One of them was Robinson’s roommate, Lance Twiggs, and the other was, most likely, Robinson himself, he said. Twiggs, a key figure in the prosecution’s case, will not testify in person this week, but prosecutors have indicated they plan to present a recorded statement.
Prosecutors allege that Robinson confessed in a note he left Twiggs, who was also his romantic partner, which read: “I’ve had the opportunity to take down Charlie Kirk and I’m going to take advantage of it.”
In surveillance video from the day Kirk was killed, which was shown at trial, Robinson could be seen climbing over a railing to get onto a rooftop, ducking and running to a spot overlooking where the activist was speaking, former State Bureau of Investigation agent David Hull testified Tuesday.
Hull claimed that after shooting Kirk, Robinson ran back across the roof, dropped to the ground and fled on foot.
The defense fights back
Defense attorney Kathryn Nester questioned Hull’s handling of the crime scene on the day of the shooting. He also asked about a bullet that was found on campus, in a location other than the supposed location of the shooting.
Hull claimed that the source of that bullet had been traced to a law enforcement officer who had “unloaded” his gun, ejecting an unfired bullet.
Prosecutors maintain that the shooting endangered others attending the event on Kirk’s campus, constituting an aggravating circumstance that could make the crime punishable by death under Utah law. Robinson also faces potential sentencing enhancements based on the prosecution’s allegation that he attacked Kirk for his political views.
During one of Robinson’s several appearances on campus on Sept. 10, Hull claimed the defendant went to the amphitheater where Kirk was later shot and contacted representatives of Turning Point USA, a group co-founded by Kirk that mobilized the conservative youth vote to help Trump win a second term.
The investigator did not provide details about what occurred during that encounter or whether members of Kirk’s security team were present.
Robinson surrendered after the shooting. Prosecutors allege that he sent a text message to Twiggs saying he had attacked Kirk because he “had had enough of his hate.”
Robinson’s defense team on Tuesday rejected the idea that he was hostile to Kirk’s political views. Defense attorney Richard Novak attempted to block the prosecution from presenting a statement outlining Turning Point USA’s traditional Christian values.
“This says nothing about Mr. Robinson’s state of mind,” Novak said, referring to the statement by David Engelhardt, a member of Turning Point USA’s board of directors. “I do not believe this court should decide — based on the record before it — where, if at all, politics and religion intersect.”
This story was translated from English to Spanish with an artificial intelligence tool and was reviewed by an editor before publication.
