Aibonite – Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
In the final stretch of the trial against Elvia Cabrera Riverathe judge Luis S. Barreto Altieriof the Aibonite Court, He perceived that the tension between the Prosecutor’s Office and the defense was beginning to escalate, so, before the day continued, he decided to intervene.
“I’m going to tell you something, you both have to calm down,” said the man in Room 1, addressing the prosecutor Silda Rubio Barreto and the defense lawyer Mayra Lopez Muleroalthough shortly after he extended his message to the other members of the case.
“I know that the case is already in a final stage and when cases are in a final stage the parties get a little more emotional than they have been throughout the entire process and I understand that, but I want to carry out this process with the same elegance that you have had throughout the entire time,” he said.
Barreto Altieri went further and made it clear that he would not tolerate confrontations between the parties in the case of the murder of the teenager Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years oldwho was mortally wounded during a brawl on the Roberto Colon detour.
“I’m not going to allow the bickering to start. I know that when the cases reach their final stage, tempers begin to stir a little, but I’m not going to allow it… There are still some witnesses. We can’t let this start to escalate like this. Did you understand me, lawyer? Did you understand me, prosecutor? Did the other prosecutors understand it? Did the other lawyers understand?” he said.
1/7 | In photos: the sheets with messages that have marked the case of Gabriela Nicole. In the middle of the trial for the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, there have been several occasions in which a sheet with a message has been spread on the Aibonito Panoramic Route, on the way to the court. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
The 18th day of the trial took an unexpected turn when Miriathny Dyalian Aviles Rodriguezhalf-sister of the co-defendant Anthonieska Aviles Cabreraassured that two prosecutors intervened and pressured her during the moment she gave her sworn statement on September 2, 2025 at the Aibonito Prosecutor’s Office.
The young woman, 18 years old, is one of the most important eyewitnesses in the case. Although he reiterated to the jury that he saw his half-sister attack Gabriela Nicole, he assured that originally he could not accurately describe the object he had in his hands and could only say that it was something sharp.
“While I was giving my statement on September 2 (2025), first, the prosecutor (of the Aibonito District, Ernesto) Quesada (Ojeda) threatened me that I am telling lies and that I have 99 years in prison,” said Aviles Rodriguez, before the astonished gaze of everyone present in the room.
“I was sitting on September 2 in the Aibonito Prosecutor’s Office and, while I was saying what had happened, the prosecutor (Brenda Liz Soto Santiago) told me to say it like a pen,” she added during an explosive revelation that could completely change the course of the notorious case.
After the witness’s controversial expressions, the Prosecutor’s Office offered its version to the press. Rubio Barreto explained that the comparison with a “pen” was used only as a reference to the size of the object allegedly used in the crime and not to describe its characteristics or content.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
However, the witness went one step further by stating that she felt afraid. “First, the prosecutor (Quesada) told me that I was lying and that I had 99 years in prison. He told me upset. I felt afraid… The second time, (the prosecutor) told me to say (that the object was) like a pen,” he said.
The witness insisted that she was never able to fully describe the object because she only observed that it was “sharp” and “pointy.” Likewise, he maintained that, when he gave his sworn statement on September 2, 2025, his mother was not present during the process. “She could not be present… They only told her to come and sign the statement,” he stated.
When Lopez Mulero asked him during cross-examination who gave that instruction, he identified prosecutor Soto Santiago.
The reconstruction of that night
Before the controversy, Aviles Rodriguez reconstructed, step by step, what happened on the night of August 10, 2025. He narrated that he attended the Great Municipal Summer Closing in Aibonito and, later, went to the La Placita Martinez business with his partner, Karelin Plata Diaz, and three other people to buy drinks.
There he observed Cabrera Rivera and his daughter Anthiany Aviles Cabrera serving drinks at the bar. The group later reached the Roberto Colon detour, where, as he described, multiple fights began at the same time. He explained that he argued with his sister because she disapproved of his romantic relationship and that, during that exchange, he received a blow to the mouth.
1 / 6 | Evidence in images: the raid on Elvia Cabrera’s house. The Police executed a search and seizure warrant at the residence of the accused, Elvia Cabrera Rivera. – Judiciary
While trying to talk to her again, he said that the atmosphere was chaotic. “Everyone was fighting,” he summarized. Likewise, he reported that he fell to the ground and, when he tried to get up with the help of his partner, he observed Anthonieska attacking the victim.
“I see Antho who is giving Gabriela a closed fist towards the left side of the hip.“, declared the witness, who indicated that her half-sister had blood.
At a certain point in the testimony, the Prosecutor’s Office tried to get him to narrate what happened immediately after that alleged attack. However, the defense objected because it was reference evidence and the judge upheld the objection.
Later, when the jury returned to the courtroom, the young woman explained that it was while she was in a municipal parking lot that she learned that the victim had been stabbed. She said that was when she began to put together the pieces of what she had witnessed and concluded that her half-sister was the one who had fatally injured the teenager.
The defense sought to separate Elvia from the crime
If the Prosecutor’s Office focused its efforts on strengthening the story about the alleged perpetrator of the stabbing, Cabrera Rivera’s defense took advantage of each response to try to disassociate their client from the murder.
Lopez Mulero conducted an extensive cross-examination during which the witness admitted a series of aspects that favor the defensive theory. He confirmed that he never saw the accused with a weapon in her hands. He accepted that he also did not observe her removing an object, handing it to someone or passing it to her daughter.
He acknowledged that he never saw her take anything out of a purse and, in fact, he did not even see her carrying a purse during the events. He also responded that he never heard Cabrera Rivera give instructions to Anthonieska to attack the victim or say expressions such as “put her in,” “kill her” or similar.
He also accepted that he never observed mother and daughter talking about how to commit the murder. And finally, he responded that he never saw the accused physically harm Pratts Rosario. He even admitted that, according to his perception, Cabrera Rivera seemed concerned about the teenager’s condition.
The voice message that came back to haunt her
The defense also cited a voice message sent by the witness herself to her partner on August 11, 2025, just hours after the crime. In the recording, Aviles Rodriguez described the fight he had with his sister and the chaos that took over the detour.
“Everyone turned into a figure eight, everyone started running… from the stab wound and I didn’t see all that,” he said in the audio.
1 / 5 | Outside the court: relatives of Gabriela Nicole Pratts demand justice. Relatives of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario arrived at the Aibonito Court to demand justice. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
The recording contrasted with the version he later offered to the authorities and with the testimony he gave this Friday before the jury.
During cross-examination he also admitted that he only observed one blow. He recognized that Anthonieska’s fist remained clenched throughout the attack. He accepted that he was never able to fully see the object inside that hand. “The complete object does not“he responded.
A trial that enters its final stretch
With 51 witnesses already presented in the process – 16 in person and 35 by stipulation – the trial against Cabrera Rivera enters its decisive stage.
Cabrera Rivera and her daughter face two charges each for the crimes of first-degree murder and violation of the Weapons Law, specifically for the use and/or carrying of a knife.
It should be noted that, once the extensive cross-examination of the defense concluded, the Prosecutor’s Office conducted a brief redirect interrogation with the purpose of clarifying various aspects of the testimony that had been questioned during the day.
At that stage, the Public Prosecutor’s Office sought to reinforce the witness’s statements about what she said she had observed the night of the crime and to dispel the impression that the cross-examination may have left regarding the description of the object and the allegations of pressure.
