A key point of the war against Iran increasingly has to do with control of the Strait of Hormuz, a narrow, bent-elbow-shaped channel that for decades was a relatively safe and reliable transit route for the export of oil and natural gas from the Middle East.
By saying that a provisional truce gave it the right to establish the conditions under which ships would pass through the strait, and to threaten—and shoot—at vessels that did not use its preferred route, Iran has attempted to exert its control over that sea lane and gain an advantage in negotiations with Washington.
On Monday, U.S. President Donald Trump attempted to tip the balance, reimposing a blockade on Iran and declaring that the United States controls the strait and would charge ships tolls for safe passage, essentially copying Iran’s strategy.
He made the announcement at a time when the United States and Iran have intensified their attacks on each other to strengthen their control over the strait and threaten to engage in an all-out confrontation again.
The world has long considered the Strait of Hormuz—which runs between the coasts of Iran and Oman—to be a free-to-use international sea lane. However, shortly after being attacked by the United States and Israel on February 28, the Iranian government claimed sovereignty over the strait, which caused a strong disruption in global energy markets and sent prices skyrocketing.
This is a more detailed look at the facts:
Both Iran and the United States say they control the Strait of Hormuz
In a post Monday on his Truth Social social network, Trump wrote that the United States “will, from now on, be known as the guardian of the Strait of Hormuz.”
1/7 | In pictures: the Strait of Hormuz, the 33 miles whose closure could paralyze the global economy. Iran’s Parliament has called for closing the Strait of Hormuz following the US attacks on Saturday night. The closure of the route, through which, according to National Geographic, more than 20 million barrels of oil and between 20% and 30% of the world’s liquefied natural gas (LNG) transit every day, would represent obstacles in the global economy, especially in China, as CNN reports. – AFP
But the Iranian Revolutionary Guard, which controls the Islamic Republic’s ballistic missile arsenal, says it is Tehran that controls the strait. “We will not allow a dishonest and child-killing army from the other side of the world to continue its illegal interference in the Strait,” the Revolutionary Guard said on Sunday.
According to the Convention of the United Nations On the Law of the Sea, established in 1982, no country has the right to claim international waters, and all ships have the right of unobstructed passage.
Although neither the United States nor Iran have ratified the convention, “that does not matter, because it has become universal custom, so all States can rely on it in any circumstance,” explained Marc Weller, director of the International Law Program at the University of Cambridge.
However, Tehran and Washington have used tools to exercise control over that route and restrict maritime traffic.
“We have two nations, both very capable — the United States because it has the most powerful Navy in the world, and Iran because it is well positioned geographically to affect trade throughout the Strait of Hormuz and can exert significant control,” said Raymond Waid, who leads the maritime industry group at the New Orleans law firm Liskow & Lewis and is a former Navy officer.
The Kpler maritime data agency reported that crossings decreased by around 52% between Friday and Monday compared to the same period the previous week. Some 14 ships crossed the strait on Sunday. Before the war, about 130 did so daily.
Iran says it has made “sincere” efforts to ensure the safety of maritime transport
The ability to disrupt shipping in the Strait of Hormuz gives Iran leverage over the global economy.
Tehran used this influence early in the war by attacking transiting ships and, in some cases, demanding payments to allow the vessels to pass. The simple fear of being attacked by Iranian drones or speedboats was enough to deter maritime traffic.
After a provisional ceasefire was announced last month, Iran insisted that ships must register with the newly created Persian Gulf Strait Authority so that their crews and cargo could be verified.
Tehran also requires ships to use only a route close to its coast, rather than the southern route around the coast of Oman, where the US military had begun guiding ships. Iran has placed mines in the central part of the strait, so few ships have attempted to transit through that route.
Tehran is suspected of attacking ships that have used the Oman route. The UK Maritime Trade Operations Centre, which issues maritime security alerts, said it had received reports of six ships being attacked in the strait, near Oman, since June 25.
Iranian officials claim their right to manage traffic through the strait
Washington and Tehran have debated what they agreed to regarding the strait. U.S. officials say the interim agreement signed last month called for reopening the crucial sea lane while a more permanent solution to the war was negotiated.
For their part, Iranian officials have stated that a clause in the provisional agreement gave them the right to manage maritime traffic and that, as long as they did not collect fees for 60 days, it was up to them to decide the conditions of their operation.
The provisional agreement stated that Iran would “do its best to ensure the safe passage of commercial ships free of charge for 60 days, only from the Persian Gulf to the Sea of Oman and vice versa.” It also urged Iran to “dialogue with the Sultanate of Oman to define future management and maritime services in the strait.”
The United States now announces that it will charge a fee for safe passage
Washington reported on Monday that it will charge a 20% toll on cargo transported through the strait “in order to cover all costs necessary to guarantee protection and security in this highly volatile area of the world.”
That’s something the United States had previously opposed, and any attempt by the White House or the Iranian government to charge tariffs would violate international rules on freedom of navigation.
The new U.S. plan echoes a previous claim by Iran — which it opposed — that it could charge tolls of up to $2 million per ship.
1 / 20 | From Hormuz to the Panama Canal: the most important maritime points for world trade. For centuries, the Strait of Hormuz (Hormuz, in English), which connects the Persian Gulf with the Gulf of Oman and, in turn, with the Arabian Sea and the Indian Ocean, has played a critical commercial role. According to the United States Energy Information Agency (EIA), 21% of the crude oil traded worldwide passes through Hormuz. In the photo, a view from space taken in April 2021 and released by the United States National Aeronautics and Space Agency. (NASA, https://www.nasa.gov/image-article/strait-of-hormuz/) – Capture
Countries can charge ships fees for a specific service when transiting an international strait, explained Weller, the international law professor. For example, Chile charges fees in the Strait of Magellan for pilotage and other services that guarantee safe passage, he said.
“It would be possible to charge a fee, but it must be proportional to the service provided,” he added. “So it’s not something that Iran should make a profit from. It’s not about $2 million per ship or anything like that.”
The International Maritime Organization, the United Nations body that oversees safety and security measures in international shipping, said the agency was waiting for more information on Trump’s proposal, but added that its stance against tolls for the maritime passage remains unchanged.
On Monday night, Abbas Araghchi, Iran’s foreign minister, seized on Trump’s support for tolls to mock him and legitimize Iran’s position.
“The president of the United States is absolutely right,” he posted on the social network
This story was translated from English to Spanish with an artificial intelligence tool and was reviewed by an editor before publication.
