
Dangerous. Sassy. Unprecedented. Unexplored territory.
The reaction in the world of the media has been rapid and forceful to the issuance of judicial summons to five journalists from the New York Times who reported on safety issues related to the new Air Force One, a gift from Qatar; a legal maneuver that is considered a worrying escalation of the Trump Administration’s campaign to control and intimidate independent media.
“The subpoenas mark an extraordinary escalation in President Trump’s efforts to threaten and intimidate independent media outlets, and have a chilling effect on the work of journalists across the country,” said Jodie Ginsberg of the Committee to Protect Journalists.
Media advocates and analysts expressed dismay at this tactic, even after months in which outlets that have drawn the ire of President Donald Trump have come under attack both in court and in the public eye; media access to circles of power has been blocked; and federal agents have searched the home of a Washington journalist.
“They have used the mechanisms of power to intimidate and demonize professional journalists who publish news contrary to the narrative that the Government wishes to convey,” said Frank Sesno, former CNN White House bureau chief and currently a professor of media and public affairs at George Washington University.
He described Friday’s summons as “dangerous and unknown territory, but it is nothing more than an extension of what we have seen from this Government and this president.”
“You don’t like a poll? Sue the Des Moines Register. You don’t like how an interview was edited? Sue ’60 Minutes’. You don’t like the coverage of the given away Air Force One? Order the FBI to investigate and subpoena the journalists for what is, by the way, a public interest story.”
Some of the summonses were delivered to journalists at their homes.
According to the Times, some of the subpoenas were delivered to journalists at their homes. Requested by Jay Clayton, the Manhattan federal prosecutor, they aim to compel journalists to testify before a federal grand jury in Manhattan this week.
The new plane in question, a gift from Qatar in whose remodeling and modernization the Government invested 400 million dollars, entered service last week. However, Trump used an older model of Air Force One to leave a NATO summit in Turkiye.
The Times, citing anonymous sources, reported that the change had come at the behest of the Secret Service, and that the newer plane lacked some of the advanced safety features of the previous aircraft, including anti-missile capabilities. On social media, Trump denied that there were any reasons for security concern.
The subpoenas were issued after FBI Director Kash Patel and other Justice Department officials met at the White House on Friday to discuss the matter, according to a person familiar with the conversations who was not authorized to speak publicly about the matter and who spoke on condition of anonymity. The Times noted that the meeting lasted about eight hours.
The fact that the operation was carried out from the White House itself was especially scandalous for analysts like Sesno, who described this coordination as “unprecedented.”
“This clearly illustrates the pressure and influence that the White House and the president have exerted on law enforcement, which is supposed to be independent and guided by facts, not politics,” he said.
The National Press Club urged the Justice Department to “immediately withdraw these subpoenas and reaffirm a principle that has long distinguished the United States: a free and independent press serves the people, not the Government.”
“Every American should understand what is at stake,” club president Mark Schoeff Jr. said in a statement. “When federal agents show up at journalists’ homes with subpoenas, this is not ordinary police action. It is an extraordinary attack on press freedom that goes against the very essence of the First Amendment.”
The Trump Administration has filed several lawsuits against media outlets
Trump’s animosity toward media outlets whose editorial line goes against his is nothing new. However, in his second presidential term, he has intensified his actions, often resorting to or attempting to use the mechanisms of the federal government. These measures have been carried out both in the courts and in the sphere of public opinion.
The president has sued several media outlets whose coverage he does not like. It has also threatened to revoke television broadcast licenses. The FCC chairman, whom he appointed, intends to sanction shows like ABC’s “The View” — in which some hosts speak out against Trump — by causing the FCC to consider revoking its exemption from equal time rules.
Among the litigation is an escalating conflict between the media and Trump’s Defense Department over journalists’ access to the Pentagon. The Times has filed two lawsuits over a regulation requiring journalists to be accompanied by escorts at the military complex.
The White House has also clashed with The Associated Press over the news agency’s refusal to comply with Trump’s presidential decree renaming the Gulf of Mexico. He has also clashed with The Wall Street Journal over its reporting on Jeffrey Epstein and his ties to the president, including an article describing a sexually charged letter that the newspaper said was signed by Trump.
Last month, the Justice Department issued and later withdrew subpoenas intended to force journalists from The Washington Post and The Wall Street Journal to testify before a grand jury, according to sources familiar with the matter.
The Post confirmed that one of its journalists received a subpoena from the Trump administration as part of a broader campaign against leaks to the media, which in January also included the extraordinary measure of an FBI search of the home of another journalist at the newspaper and the seizure of her electronic devices. The media world was shocked by the search of the home of journalist Hannah Natanson, who was covering Trump’s transformation of the federal government.
The Times is now preparing to battle what its lawyer, David McCraw, has called “this brazen act.”
In an internal memo seen by the AP, the newspaper’s executive editor, Joseph Kahn, criticized the subpoenas and said, “We hope to emerge victorious.” “We have the best legal team in the industry. … The law protects journalists from this type of abuse of power by prosecutors for retaliatory purposes. It is essential that the courts reaffirm that protection and overturn this overreach. We trust they will do so in this case.”
Kahn praised the work of the five journalists — Tyler Pager, Eric Schmitt, Eric Lipton, Adam Goldman and Julian Barnes — and stated that they should know “that all of us, as their colleagues, and all the resources of The Times, are on their side and that we will fight together against this judicial abuse.”
