Aibonite – Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
On the nineteenth day of the jury trial against Elvia Cabrera Riveraa witness who arrived at the place where the tragedy occurred minutes before the outcome told this Wednesday before the Aibonite Court the moments of tension that culminated in the crime of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years old.
Reynaldo Jose Fernandez Maldonado, couple of Lismary Torres Rosario, older sister of the victim, was the fourth witness to testify during the day that began at 9:00 am and lasted until after 6:30 pm in room 1 of the Aibonito Judicial Centerpresided over by the judge Luis S. Barreto Altieri.
Fernandez Maldonado, 22, explained under oath that on the night of Sunday, August 10, 2025, he arrived at his residence and received a call from his friend. Dylan Yadhiel Berrioswho invited him out, so he ended up in a business in the urban area where the Great Municipal Summer Closing was being held.
During the interrogation of the prosecutor Myriam Nieves Verathe young man reported that he visited several businesses with friends, including his partner, until they later moved to the Roberto Colon detour area, where later in the night his sister-in-law was fatally stabbed.
He narrated that at one point he went out with some friends to the La Placita Martinez business to buy a bag of ice, while Pratts Rosario went in his friend Dylan’s vehicle to buy food. Later, both groups met again in the detour area.
It was there where, according to her testimony, tension began to rise that began with a dispute between the half-sisters of Anthonieska Aviles Cabreraco-defendant in the case and daughter of Cabrera Rivera. He reported that he tried to intervene to separate the people involved in the brawl, including his partner.
“I’m trying to separate Lismary, but she gets into a fight again. At that point, Elvia was hitting Lisandra (my mother-in-law). I’m still trying to separate Lismary. I separated her and Dylan was shouting the name ‘Lela’ at me. When I realized, Lela was already on the floor. (I see) Antho covered in blood. He was talking to Elvia, telling her something,” stated Fernandez Maldonado.
The witness indicated that he does not remember where Miriathny Aviles Rodriguez, Aviles Cabrera’s half-sister, was at that time, but he did explain that his attention was focused on helping Gabriela Nicole. Precisely, he recounted how he helped put the victim in a car to take her to the Menonita hospital.
Prosecutor’s Office tries to present expression after the crime
During the testimony, Fernandez Maldonado stated that, after the crime, he observed that Aviles Cabrera was nervous. At that time, the Aibonito Prosecutor’s Office tried to present as evidence an expression that, according to the witness, Aviles Cabrera made minutes after the incident.
For these purposes, Rule 109 of Evidence was activated to discuss, without the presence of the jury, the admissibility of the approach. Fernandez Maldonado stated that, between three or four minutes after the crime, he heard Aviles Cabrera say to his mother: “And now what do I do?”
1/8 | In photos: the sheets with messages that have marked the case of Gabriela Nicole. In the middle of the trial for the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, there have been several occasions in which a sheet with a message has been spread on the Aibonito Panoramic Route, on the way to the court. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
He added that he observed that the young woman had blood on her hands, although he clarified that he could not specify what he was doing later because he was focused on caring for Gabriela Nicole. However, the judge determined that the expression would not be admitted as evidence.
Barreto Altieri also reminded the Prosecutor’s Office that the matter was previously resolved and requested that it not be raised again during the process. Then, a brief recess was declared and, when the proceedings resumed, the testimony in the courtroom continued.
“(Lela) was not reacting. Her eyes were looking up. Her hands were clasped,” indicated the young man, who added that, after the victim was taken to the hospital, he went to his residence to look for a frise for Pratts Rosario. However, while returning to the medical institution, he received the news that the teenager had died.
On the way, he said, he found his partner, who was in the middle of the road and, he said, looked “very disoriented,” was “alone” and “screaming.” At that moment, he added, he took her to the hospital and went to ask if Pratts Rosario had in fact died.
The witness confirmed that, while he was at the medical institution, he was approached Leshandra Pesante Rodriguezanother witness in the case, who told him that she observed how Cabrera Rivera took something out of her purse and then gave her her purse to hold.
During cross-examination, the attorney Alberto Rivera Ramosone of the defense lawyers, Fernandez Maldonado stated that he did not see anyone attacking the victim with a sharp object. He added that he also did not see the accused hand a sharp object to his daughter. “No,” he answered.
Regarding what Pesante Rodriguez told him in the hospital, the witness commented that “it was something,” without establishing whether it was a sharp object and how much of it. He also did not detail whether it was a pointed object.
The trial continues on Friday, July 17 at 9:00 am, but starting next week, sessions will be held on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays.
“We are trying to finish,” the judge indicated.
