Washington – When Markwayne Mullin took over as Secretary of Homeland Security following the firing of Kristi Noem, he pledged to remove the department responsible for carrying out the Donald Trump administration’s mass deportation policy from the headlines.
But just a few months after Mullin took office, the department is once again squarely at the center of controversy, after three people died in encounters with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents in a span of less than a week.
The events represent the first big test for Mullin, who promised a firm hand for a department shaken by the conduct of his predecessor and the Trump administration’s immigration raids.
As he grapples with rising violence, he is forced to strike a balance between the pressures of a White House eager to carry out mass deportations and his former colleagues in Congress demanding answers, all while trying to ease tensions in American cities over the deaths.
“When he took office, Secretary Mullin said his goal was to get the department out of the news,” Democratic Rep. Seth Magaziner said on the House floor Tuesday. Then, waving a newspaper, he added: “Well, now they’re back on the damn front page.”
Mullin’s strategy is a drastic change from Kristi Noem
Mullin, a former senator from Oklahoma, was a surprise choice to lead the massive department following Noem’s firing after two American protesters were shot to death by federal immigration agents in Minneapolis earlier this year.
As secretary charged with carrying out the government’s goal of mass deportations, Noem pushed an aggressive style of immigration enforcement in which she took center stage, including, most notably, a visit to a detention center in El Salvador. He was quick to speak out publicly about controversial events and weighed in on both Minneapolis shootings with statements in which he accused the dead protesters of being agitators.
1 / 28 | Pain and fury in the streets of Minneapolis after the death of a woman during an immigration raid. Citizens protested at the scene of the shooting involving federal law enforcement officers. -Tom Baker
President Trump, who made mass deportations a central promise of his second administration, eventually distanced himself from Noem over a $200 million ad campaign and her handling of the Minneapolis operation.
Mullin promised a different approach, while remaining committed to delivering on the president’s priorities. His first trip as secretary was not to promote immigration enforcement, but to observe hurricane recovery efforts in North Carolina. Noem used to accompany her agents on immigration raids; Mullin has not.
Since becoming secretary and following the violence in Minneapolis, the administration has also avoided unpopular and flashy immigration operations in American cities, and has moved to a more discreet approach that has largely diverted media attention from the offensive. Under Mullin, ICE is also backing away from a plan to use warehouses to detain migrants.
But immigration arrests continue under his direction and often with little notice: ICE arrested 10,000 people during a five-day period in late June, averaging about 2,000 arrests per day. And legal avenues to immigrate have also faced new restrictions.
Since Mullin took office, Trump has praised the secretary as “incredible” and “amazing,” and congratulated him for resigning his Senate seat to lead the Department of Homeland Security.
For months, it seemed like Mullin’s change of approach was working. Although civil rights advocates and activists accused the department of mistreating immigrants under his leadership, Mullin’s less confrontational style seemed to keep the department out of the spotlight.
Deaths linked to ICE put the spotlight back on Mullin and his department
But the events of the past week have posed a new challenge for Mullin, as he walks a tightrope between his more moderate approach and the president’s demands.
“Trying to deal with competing public policy goals is a challenge for any Cabinet secretary, but Mullin has it worse than most,” said Tom Warrick, a former counterterrorism official at Homeland Security who now works at the Atlantic Council.
“In the case of Homeland Security, the White House wants to, at the same time, meet its immigration quotas and maintain public trust, and how that is achieved — even with the funding that Mullin has available — is a really difficult challenge,” he noted.
ICE agents in Houston and Maine shot and killed people in their cars during immigration operations. In Florida, a man fleeing from ICE agents died in a car crash.
1 / 13 | In images: the impact in Maine after the death of Johan Sebastian Duran, a young man shot in an ICE operation. On the morning of Monday, July 13, an operation by the United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement Service (ICE) in Biddeford, Maine, ended with the death of Colombian Joan Sebastian Guerrero, a 26-year-old young man. – Jaime Moreno
Mullin has not commented publicly on the deaths, while the department’s public affairs office has only released brief statements after each one.
Behind the scenes, Mullin — who frequently talks about how he shares his cell phone number with members of Congress and encourages them to call him directly — has chatted with lawmakers and shared information, including conversations with both of Maine’s senators.
And after the second shooting death in Maine, as criticism mounted from both protesters and Mullin’s former colleagues in Congress, ICE was ordered to suspend most vehicle stops.
Trump increases pressure on Mullin over vehicle stops
That decision infuriated Trump supporters.
Conservative influencer Nick Sorter called it a “TOTAL CAPITULATION to the left,” in a post on
A day later, Trump appeared to contradict the directive by writing in a social media post: “we must be strong, tough and smart and WE CANNOT give up one of ICE’s most important and effective tools to fight crime, THE TRAFFIC STOP!”
Mullin then republished Trump’s words, adding that people in the country would be “arrested and deported wherever they are.” He later wrote in X that he and the president are “on the same page.”
It was not immediately clear whether vehicle stops had resumed.
But it showed the friction between Mullin’s attempts to remain calm and the president’s demands that illegal immigrants — whom the administration has in many cases portrayed as criminals — be arrested in large numbers.
Democrats have lashed out at the new secretary, saying they see little change in the department.
“Secretary Mullin, if he wants to, and if he has the support of the White House, has the ability to put ICE under control and make them comply with the law,” said Representative Joaquin Castro, Democrat of Texas. “So either he has no interest in doing it, or the White House doesn’t support him, or the agents are just out of control.”
Republican lawmakers have come to Mullin’s defense.
“I think the secretary has accomplished what he wanted to do to try to change the environment there,” said Rep. Andrew Garbarino of New York, who as chairman of the House Homeland Security Committee has asked the Department of Homeland Security for a bipartisan briefing on ICE’s use-of-force policies.
“I don’t think anyone is celebrating that ICE is back in the headlines,” Garbarino said.
This story was translated from English by an AP editor with the help of a generative artificial intelligence tool.
