
Some “jeans” that fit you perfectly. The ideal series of Netflix for a Tuesday night. Your only soulmate. Modern life promises that, with enough alternatives, you can happily find the best of everything.
However, Behavioral scientists say the growing avalanche of choices—whether when shopping, socializing, or finding a partner—is having the opposite effect.
The idea that having more alternatives is always better is deeply rooted in Western culture. However, research shows that having too many options can lead to anxietyindecision and, paradoxically, less satisfaction with what is ultimately chosen, explained Barry Schwartz, professor emeritus of psychology at Swarthmore College and author of The Paradox of Choice.
“There are hundreds of studies showing that you can have too much of a good thing,” Schwartz stated.
To reduce mental noise, he recommended limiting the number of decisions made. The brain will thank you.
More options usually generate more confusion
Schwartz offered several examples of situations in which having more alternatives ended up hurting people.
For Medicare Part D prescription drug plans, people who lived in states with more options were less likely to choose one, he said. The same goes for investments in 401(k) plans: the more alternatives a company offered, the less likely its employees were to sign up, even when the employer matched part of their contributions.
Less consequential decisions are no different.
Schwartz cited a widely known study that showed gourmet food store shoppers purchased more jars of artisanal jam when offered six flavors, rather than a broader selection of 24.
In a later study, students were more likely to complete an assignment for extra points when they could choose from six topics, rather than 30.
Schwartz’s research extended these findings to examine emotional responses to this phenomenon.
“Instead of feeling liberated by all those options, you become paralyzed,” he explained. “You can do anything, but you can’t determine which of all those possibilities you should choose.”
People also tend to make worse decisions because a greater number of alternatives means more chances of getting a bad outcome, he said.
Furthermore, once someone finally chooses among all the possibilities, they may feel less satisfied with even a good decision, due to the fear that a better option existed.
Schwartz indicated that the problem of dissatisfaction is particularly intense among those who always aspire to achieve the best, people whom psychologists call “maximizers”.
“Maximizing people especially suffer from the proliferation of options”he pointed out. “Only the best is enough.”
This tendency does not occur in all people or in all situations, Schwartz clarified. Car enthusiasts, for example, may enjoy examining the details of a nearly unlimited number of options when purchasing a new vehicle.
“But you don’t feel that way when you go to buy jam,” he said.
The brain does not like to make decisions
Daniel Willingham, professor of psychology and neuroscience researcher at the University of Virginia, explained that this phenomenon occurs because the brain is designed to prevent people from having to think constantly.
Solving problems requires more energy than using memory, a characteristic linked to the survival mode developed during evolution, Willingham said.
When a person is faced with a goal, whether it is an immediate need like responding to a threat or a longer-term one like finding shelter, the mind first looks for what has worked before. The problem-solving part of the brain only activates afterwards.
“Another way of saying it is, if you’re thinking, things aren’t going well.”he expressed.
That explains why people sometimes go through parts of their daily routine on autopilot, he added.
During the day, they face hundreds of situations in which they could act differently, but they almost always take the same route to get to work.
Schwartz noted that the proliferation of choices has also become intertwined with identity during the age of social media, in which everyone can easily compare their decisions to those of other people.
“When all you have to choose from is Lee’s and Levi’s, no one expects the jeans they buy to fit perfectly,” he said. “But when there are 2,000 options, then of course you hope they fit perfectly.”
Limit your options and move on
David Epstein said that, after researching his book Inside the Box: How Constraints Make Us Betterbegan to move away from his maximizing tendencies.
Now you limit the times you have to make decisions. For example, when he found a T-shirt that fit him, he bought 10 of the same ones in different colors.
With this he followed the example of Herbert Simon, psychologist and winner of the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1978, who had three sets of clothes and ate practically the same thing every day.
Simon coined the term satisfyinga combination of the English words satisfying and sufficingwhich is about establishing good enough criteria to make a decision and then moving forward.
Epstein sets such rules for himself when shopping online, starting by focusing on the purpose of the item he needs.
“When I find one that does that job, I buy it, rather than reading all the reviews and getting stuck thinking, ‘Well, this other one has all these extra features.’”
Willingham and Schwartz recommended delegating some decisions.
If you’re looking for a new phone, for example, find a friend who’s happy with theirs and buy the same model.
For bigger decisions, like financial planning, you’ll be happier if you turn to someone else’s professional knowledge, Willingham said.
“If you’re thinking, ‘Well, I’m a smart person, I can figure this out,’ I think nine times out of 10 you’re kidding yourself,” he said.
Schwartz acknowledged that change can be difficult for people who have trouble making decisions. But he assured that it is worth it.
“Over time, you find that you find it easier to make decisions, you end up more satisfied with what you choose, and suddenly you have two extra hours every day.”he concluded.
