Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
Aibonito – Room 1 of the Aibonite Court remained silent while the Prosecutor’s Office took the step that the family of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario expected from the beginning of the process: to file the case against Elvia Cabrera Rivera for the crime of the minor under 16 years of age.
Although it will now be up to the 12 members of the jury to issue a verdict of guilty or not guilty, the case for the murder – perpetrated with a knife – on the Roberto Colon bypass, near the urban area, is finally approaching its outcome.
The events date back to the night of Sunday, August 10, 2025, when the Great Municipal Summer Closing was being held. In the midst of the party atmosphere, a brawl escalated into an attack that left Pratts Rosario and his best friend injured.
The young woman was transported by emergency to the Menonita Hospital, where Dr. Carla Mercado certified the absence of vital signs at 12:35 am on Monday, August 11, 2025. The victim, nicknamed “Lela,” would turn 17 the next day.
His death opened an investigation that led the Aibonito Prosecutor’s Office to file, on August 19, 2025, two charges for the crimes of first-degree murder and violation of the Weapons Law against Cabrera Rivera and his daughter. Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera, 18 years old.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
During the process, the testimonies presented by the Public Ministry attempted to reconstruct the moments before and after the attack. In fact, the Prosecutor’s Office maintained with its theory that both defendants acted in common and mutual agreement to commit the crime.
According to the accusation presented against both defendants, the murder weapon was a sharp object “about one inch wide and five inches long, with a sharp tip, or a similar object that could be considered a knife.”
As part of the development of this case, Cabrera Rivera faced a preliminary hearing stage that lasted three days —October 17, 21 and 23, 2025— before the superior judge Marielem Padilla Cottoof the Aibonite Courtwho determined cause for trial.
Subsequently, the Judicial Center carried out one of the most important steps of the criminal process: the selection of the 12 jurors who would have the responsibility of evaluating the evidence that would be presented during the trial against the accused.
The removal of the jury began on February 13 and ended on April 15, 2026. The main jury panel was made up of eight women and four men. In addition, six substitutes were chosen, of which four were women and two men.
1/8 | In photos: the sheets with messages that have marked the case of Gabriela Nicole. In the middle of the trial for the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, there have been several occasions in which a sheet with a message has been spread on the Aibonito Panoramic Route, on the way to the court. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
However, the panel of alternate members suffered an unexpected loss, after a woman who was a relative of the agent was excluded. Gerardo Berrios Padillaattached to Criminal Investigation Corps (CIC) of Aibonito and key witness in the case.
With the jury finally constituted, the trial in its substance began on May 1, with the presentation of opening statements. Since then, the Prosecutor’s Office developed its theory of the case through an extensive parade of evidence that lasted for months.
In total, the Public Ministry presented more than 55 witnesses at the trial. Of these, 21 appeared in person before the jury, while the rest of the witness evidence was incorporated by stipulation after an agreement between the parties.
The last to testify in the witness chair was the forensic pathologist Javier Gustavo Serrano Serranowho confirmed in court that the victim had 11 stab wounds, including one that passed through the chest cavity to reach the tip of the heart.
Under oath, Serrano Serrano, with more than 24 years of experience in the Institute of Forensic Sciences (ICF), testified that, in his opinion, the number of wounds on the victim showed evidence of an intention to cause him, at least, “bodily harm.”
To date, it has not been established which murder weapon was used in the crime. During the judicial process, reference was made to three possible objects: a blade, a pink comb with a stainless steel blade hidden in the handle and an awl.
Regardless of what weapon was used, the crime left a family marked by pain. The victim’s mother, Lisandra Rosario Berrioswas hoping to save her daughter’s life, but received devastating news.
“I thought they were going to give me my daughter alive. Even if it was with machines or whatever, but they told me that she had arrived without vital signs, that she had eight stab wounds. I went crazy. I threw myself over all the chairs in the hospital,” she said in her statement.
After hearing the pain of a mother who lost her daughter, the judicial process returned to the key moment of the accusation: the Public Ministry’s theory about how the attack occurred and the participation that, according to their witnesses, each of the two accused had.
Leshandra Pesante Rodrigueza close friend of Aviles Cabrera, testified that on the night of the crime she observed when the accused rummaged in her purse and took out with her right hand a pointed and sharp awl, which she later gave to her daughter Anthonieska.
“He put it (the wallet) in my hands. I stayed in shock. I kept thinking about what’s going on here. She leaves for the revolu. They were on top of each other. I was thinking about what was going on here. “I had my wallet in my right hand,” he said.
“After there, I noticed that Lela (the victim’s nickname) was lying on the floor. She was face up. She had her arms outstretched. I threw the purse on the grass and ran to where ‘Lela’ was. I fell to the floor and grabbed her arm to feel her pulse. She had no pulse,” he stated.
Another important testimony was that of JNRS16 years old, cousin of the victim, who stated that on the night of the crime she saw “Lela” lying in the shape of a fetus on the floor, trying to cover herself with her arms, and that “Antho” was kneeling, as in the area of her legs.
“Antho stopped and walked back to the middle of the road. I go to where Lela and Lela had the suit up to her waist. You couldn’t see her navel. And I started to say to her: ‘Lela, get up, Lela, get up, please,’ and at that moment he closed his eyes,” he said.
After the attack, the witness stated that Cabrera Rivera took her Coach purse with one hand and, with the other, picked up a “fine” object from the ground, which she tried to hide. “Elvia looked at me and said: ‘You didn’t see anything’!’ I told her: ‘go f***’ because I was upset,” he concluded.
