
He Panel on the Special Independent Prosecutor (PFEI) determined that it will not appoint a special prosecutor against the mayor of Toa Alta, Clemente “Chito” Agosto Lugardodue to a controversy related to the appointment of an official in his administration.
The determination came after the agency evaluated the investigative file, its annexes and the evidence collected during a preliminary investigation of the Department of Justice. The Panel concluded that there was no sufficient cause to initiate an independent investigation of a criminal nature.
The organization accepted the recommendation of the Secretary of Justice, Lourdes Gomez Torresafter the Division of Public Integrity and Comptroller Affairs concluded that the controversy responded to “interpretive and administrative differences over the scope of the discretion conferred on the mayor.”
The investigation arose from a complaint filed by the president of the Municipal Legislature of Toa Alta, Lourdes Rodriguez Decletregarding the appointment of the director of the Recreation and Sports Office.
Rodriguez Declet alleged that the mayor submitted the appointment to the Municipal Legislature even though the nominee did not meet the established academic requirement and that, even after the legislative rejection, he insisted on keeping her in office.
Justice evaluated possible violations for misappropriation of public funds and breach of duty. However, it concluded that the elements of these crimes were not established, since neither a loss or illegal diversion of funds nor a deliberate action aimed at failing to comply with a ministerial duty was identified.
According to the Justice report, the mayor’s actions responded to an erroneous legal interpretation of the validity of the Municipal Legislature’s rejection, but did not constitute criminal conduct.
For his part, Agosto Lugardo defended the appointment under the argument that the Municipal Legislature did not act within the corresponding term nor adequately complete the evaluation process established in its regulations, so he understood that the nomination had been confirmed by virtue of law.
The municipal administration also maintained that keeping the official in office responded to criteria of administrative efficiency and generated an estimated annual savings of $4,896 for the municipality, although the statement did not specify how this saving would be produced.
However, Justice concluded that the mayor lacked the authority to unilaterally confirm an appointment rejected by the Municipal Legislature. According to the Justice report, if he understood that the vote had been invalid, he should challenge it through a judicial review process, instead of overturning the rejection on his own.
Even so, the agency determined that this action, although possibly irregular in the administrative sphere and based on an erroneous legal interpretation, did not constitute criminal conduct.
