Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
Aibonite – On day 23 of the trial against Elvia Cabrera Rivera will mark the beginning of the countdown towards the verdict for the murder of the teenager Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years old, occurred in mid-August 2025 on the Roberto Colon detour.
Starting this Thursday, the judicial fate of the accused will officially be in the hands of the 12 members of the jury, who will begin the deliberation process that will put an end to one of the criminal cases with the greatest public attention on the island.
The jury will enter the designated room at any time to begin the deliberation process, after spending their second night in total isolation following the sequestration order issued by Senior Judge Luis S. Barreto Altieri, of the Aibonito Court.
In summary, Wednesday’s day closed with the final arguments of the Prosecutor’s Office and the defense, followed by part of the extensive instructions given by the judge to the jury, which is made up of seven women and five men.
However, the process was not concluded. Therefore, the judge will continue this Thursday morning giving the legal instructions and, once finished, will appoint a president of the panel so that the jurors can retire to deliberate.
1/7 | In a prayer circle: family and loved ones honor the memory of Gabriela Nicole. In a critical stage of the trial against Elvia Cabrera, the family of the murdered minor Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario joined in a prayer circle. – Pablo Martinez Rodriguez
During that deliberation, the jury will have access to more than 200 pieces of evidence, including photographs, videos, documents and witness statements, which they must evaluate to determine whether the Prosecutor’s Office proved the guilt of the accused beyond a reasonable doubt.
Cabrera Rivera and her daughter Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera They face two charges each for first-degree murder, typified in Article 93(a) of the Penal Code, and for use and/or carrying a knife, under Article 6.06 of the Weapons Law (168-2019).
One of the most relevant aspects of the instructions is that the panel will not be limited to deciding between guilt or not guilt for first degree murder. If you understand that the evidence does not establish that crime, you may consider a verdict of mitigated murder.
The events of this case date back to the night of Sunday, August 10, 2025, when a brawl that occurred on the Roberto Colon detour, in Aibonito, near the place where the Great Municipal Summer Closing was being held, ended in an attack with a knife.
Pratts Rosario, known to her family and friends as “Lela,” received 11 stab wounds. Under oath, the forensic pathologist Javier Gustavo Serrano Serrano He declared in court that one of those wounds reached his heart and was what caused his death.
Although she was transferred to Menonita Hospital, Dr. Carla Mercado certified her death at 12:35 am on August 11, 2025. Instead, the victim’s best friend, Chrisangel Gonzalez Rodriguezsurvived the stab wound he received in the back of his neck.
According to the Public Ministry, both defendants acted in common and mutual agreement to commit the crime using a sharp object that they described as a knife. However, during the trial it was not conclusively established what the weapon was.
During the evidence parade, three possible edged weapons were mentioned: a blade found near the defendant’s residence; a pink comb with a stainless steel blade hidden in the handle, found incomplete at the crime scene; and a punch.
The trial began on May 1 with the evidence parade. The Prosecutor’s Office had more than 60 witnesses; 21 testified in court and the rest was stipulated by agreement between the parties. The defense, on the other hand, chose not to present witnesses. The case was submitted on July 21.
In her final arguments, prosecutor Silda Rubio Barreto asked the jury to find the accused guilty after maintaining that the evidence showed that she gave the murder weapon to her daughter and subsequently carried out acts to hide evidence and influence witnesses.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
“Today Gabriela Nicole’s voice cannot be heard, but the voice of justice is in her hands. I, for Gabriela, for the law, for justice and because I represent the people of Puerto Rico, respectfully request that you issue a verdict of guilty on each of the charges,” Rubio Barreto expressed in his presentation.
The defense, for its part, insisted that the investigation was marked by inconsistencies and that the evidence failed to link Cabrera Rivera to the crime beyond a reasonable doubt. Therefore, he requested a not guilty verdict and reiterated his client’s innocence.
“Justice does not ask for courage to condemn, it asks for honesty to be able to recognize the true facts… Sometimes the most difficult verdict is not guilty, but the correct one,” said Alberto Rivera Ramos, of the accused’s legal team.
