Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
In moments when the trial against Elvia Cabrera Rivera enters its final stage and heads toward jury deliberation, Judge Juan A. Reyes Colon issued a gag order on Wednesday in the separate trial against his daughter and co-defendant, Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera.
The order prohibits the Public Prosecutor’s Office, the defense and their respective witnesses from commenting, giving an opinion or making extrajudicial expressions about the evidence and judicial events related to the case for the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario16 years old.
“Taking into consideration the procedural stage in the cases at hand and in response to the high public interest that this has permeated society and the media”the court determined to impose the restriction, the court document details.
The measure does not prevent the parties from disclosing information about the calendar of the process, the content of the motions, their processing or the resolutions issued by the court.
However, Reyes Colon warned that any non-compliance could lead to a sanction for contempt.
The judge maintained that the determination responds to a balance between the constitutional rights of the parties, including freedom of expression and due process of law.
1/7 | In a prayer circle: family and loved ones honor the memory of Gabriela Nicole. In a critical stage of the trial against Elvia Cabrera, the family of the murdered minor Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario joined in a prayer circle. – Pablo Martinez Rodriguez
“We conclude that, if this strict measure is not taken, it could cause harm to the jury, contrary to the rights of the parties and the healthy administration of justice”said the robed man.
The order arises while the selection of the jury that will evaluate the evidence against Aviles Cabrera continues, a process that is expected to resume tomorrow, Friday, in the Aibonito Court.
The young woman’s defense has repeatedly stated that the extensive media coverage of the trial against Cabrera Rivera could have exposed potential jurors to testimonies, photographs, videos and other evidence directly related to her client.
Even, He requested that the trial be postponed for at least six months after the trial against his mother was completed, arguing that public dissemination of the case compromised the possibility of selecting an impartial jury. Both the Aibonito Court and the Court of Appeals rejected the approach.
Jury selection in the case against Aviles Cabrera began on June 29. During the first day, 27 candidates appeared before the court – 14 men and 13 women – but 19 were excused for medical and personal reasons, so only eight remained in court at the end of the day.
As part of the process, Reyes Colon gave initial instructions to the candidates and warned them about the extensive media coverage of the case. He emphasized that they should refrain from reading, watching or listening to information related to the trial and from discussing it with other people.
The continuation of the selection process also occurs after the defense also exhausted its resources to challenge the determination that Aviles Cabrera is indictable to face trial.
On July 3, the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico denied a second urgent motion for reconsideration filed by the Society for Legal Aid (SAL).
“Having evaluated the urgent second motion for reconsideration presented by the petitioning party, it is ruled invalid. Adhere to what was resolved. Notify yourself immediately”the highest judicial forum then indicated.
With that decision, the Aibonito Court’s determination that the defendant is prosecutable prevailed.
At the beginning of the judicial process, in September 2025, Aviles Cabrera had been declared not prosecutable. However, after a second evaluation, the court determined that the criminal proceedings against him could continue.
Aviles Cabrera and Cabrera Rivera face charges of first-degree murder and violations of the Weapons Law for the death of Pratts Rosario, which occurred after several fights that occurred on the night of August 10, 2025 on the Roberto Colon detour, in Aibonito.
The teenager and another 16-year-old minor suffered stab wounds. Both were taken to the Aibonito Mennonite Hospital, where Pratts Rosario was pronounced dead at 12:35 am the next day.
The other young man survived and testified during the trial against Cabrera Rivera.
