
BELLEVUE, Washington — The United States Supreme Court may be deeply conservative, but it is not simply a seal of approval for President Donald Trump, Justice Elena Kagan said Thursday.
Kagan, one of three liberal justices on the Supreme Court, told an audience of attorneys and judges from the Ninth Circuit of the United States in Bellevue, Washington, that at decisive moments and on some important issues “the Supreme Court has held back the executive branch.”
The court has ruled in favor of the Trump Administration in the vast majority of cases brought before it so far, including largely endorsing its tough immigration policy and expanding Trump’s authority over federal regulatory agencies. However, Kagan highlighted key rulings in which the president did not get what he intended, such as decisions rejecting Trump’s widespread tariffs and his attempts to strip birthright citizenship from the children of people who are in the United States illegally.
“Is this court very conservative? Does it do a lot of things that go off the script of the conservative legal movement and that, in my opinion, are deeply wrong? Well, yes,” Kagan said. “But is this court a kind of puppet of the current Government? I think absolutely not.”
Polls have revealed that public trust in the Supreme Court is at historic lows in recent years, and several critics of the current court have suggested that the justices act for political reasons. Trump has personally and in very harsh terms attacked the judges who rule against him. A liberal justice, Ketanji Brown Jackson, declared in May, after the court overturned a majority-black district in Louisiana and weakened the Voting Rights Act, that the institution risked being viewed as a political institution.
Chief Justice John Roberts, who has sided with the court’s liberal justices in some key cases, such as birthright citizenship and tariffs, has disputed the perception that the justices are “political actors,” calling it a misunderstanding.
Kagan, who is often seen as a bridge-builder, echoed that approach in her remarks Thursday, following her appearance before Congress alongside conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett last week, addressing security threats and other issues facing the Supreme Court.
Kagan reiterated her support for the creation of a commission made up of retired judges to ensure compliance with the Supreme Court’s first ethical code, approved in 2023 amid an avalanche of criticism over undeclared travel and gifts from wealthy benefactors to some justices. Although justices are taking the code of ethics seriously, there are divergent opinions in court about how or whether it should be applied, and no conclusion has yet been reached, he said.
From the stand, Kagan also offered her insight into a historic moment from the Court’s last session, when Trump himself had a front-row seat during hearings on his birthright citizenship decree. He was the first sitting president to attend oral hearings.
For the justices, it was largely a “non-event,” Kagan said. Trump sat to the side, in an area relatively far from the bench usually reserved for members of Congress, and the court made no announcement about his presence. Many attendees couldn’t see it, he noted.
“It was like someone came in, sat down, and then had to listen to an argument,” Kagan said.
The president remained in the room for about half of the lengthy arguments and left when the opposing side began to present its arguments.
This story was translated from English to Spanish with an artificial intelligence tool and was reviewed by an editor before publication.
