The government of donald trump requested this Monday to Supreme Court clearing the way for an executive order from the president that could significantly change mail-in voting ahead of the November midterm elections.
He Department of Justice He asked the magistrates to suspend, for the moment, the decisions of lower courts that prevent the application of the changes in almost half of the country.
The request comes shortly after Trump gave a prime-time speech in which he reinforced his years-long campaign to sow doubt about the legitimacy of the election. In addition, it could be one of several appeals related to the electoral process that reach the Supreme Court before the midterm elections.
Trump ordered the government in March to compile a “state citizen list” of eligible voters and mail ballots only to people on that list.
Democratic officials from 23 states and the District of Columbia sued, arguing that the Constitution gives the states and Congress, and not the president, the power to set election rules. His lawyers argue that Trump’s proposed changes could open themselves to abuse and cause chaos.
1 / 5 | Resignations and dismissals: the departures that have marked Donald Trump’s team. Donald Trump’s second term has been marked by several departures within his Cabinet. -Matt Rourke
A federal judge in Massachusetts stayed the executive order for the plaintiff states, and a divided panel of the First Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that decision over the weekend.
The executive order mandates that U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services and the commissioner of the Social Security Administration submit federal lists of citizens to state authorities to determine who is eligible to vote. Additionally, it orders the Postal Service to deliver mail-in ballots only to people included on those lists.
The order also requires that ballots be sent in secure envelopes with unique barcodes to allow for tracking. Likewise, it contemplates withholding federal funds from states and municipalities that do not comply with these requirements.
In the appeal, the government maintains that Trump’s order establishes “general policy guidelines” and does not directly dictate how states should administer their elections. Deputy Attorney General John Sauer asked the Supreme Court to suspend the judge’s decision while litigation continues, calling it indefensible.
“And the injunction is especially indefensible because the agencies are still deliberating how, if at all, to implement the decree, and yet the district court has preemptively decided that any action the agencies decide to take will necessarily be unlawful,” Sauer wrote.
He also urged the highest judicial forum to act quickly, arguing that any new measures must come into force in August to have an effect on the November elections. The response to the appeal must be submitted on August 3.
Voting by mail has been one of Trump’s main targets for years, despite the fact that he himself has used that method to vote. The president blamed him for his defeat against Democrat Joe Biden in 2020 and has claimed, without presenting evidence, that he facilitates fraud. He addressed that issue again Monday during a visit to a General Motors facility in Michigan, as he urged Congress to pass his voter ID and proof of citizenship bill.
“And let’s hope there is no vote by mail,” he said, calling that method “intrinsically corrupt.”
Voting by mail has gained popularity among voters of both parties and, according to federal data, around 30% of the votes cast in the 2024 presidential election were cast that way. Furthermore, the process is safe. A 2025 Brookings Institution study found that only about four cases of fraud were recorded for every 10 million votes cast by mail.
The Supreme Court already ruled in June against the Trump administration by determining that states can count ballots received after Election Day.
Trump has presented the proposed changes to his executive order as measures to prevent non-citizens from voting in elections. He has also insisted on the approval of a law that requires proof of citizenship to be able to vote.
It has been proven that voting by non-citizens is rare and constitutes a serious crime that can lead to deportation.
Federal Judge Indira Talwani, of Boston, appointed by former President Barack Obama, decided in June to suspend the application of the measure for the November 3 elections.
His decision differed from that issued by another federal judge in Washington. Judge Carl Nichols, appointed by Trump, ruled in May that it was too early to block the order because it had not yet been implemented.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office, which is leading the lawsuit on behalf of the states, did not immediately comment on the lawsuit filed by the Trump administration. New York Attorney General Letitia James’ office also declined to comment.
The Postal Service also declined to comment on its plans to enforce the executive order while the litigation continues. In Kansas, the office of the Secretary of State, Republican Scott Schwab, reported that the Postal Service has not communicated to him what its plans are for the elections.
