Aibonite – Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
One of the criminal cases that has impacted the country the most returned this Tuesday to the Aibonite Courtwhere jury selection continued for the trial against Anthonieska Aviles Cabreraco-accused of the murder of the minor Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario16 years old, which occurred in August 2025 on the Roberto Colon detour.
The hearing resumed in room 3, before the Judge Juan A. Reyes Colonafter Aviles Cabrera burst into tears on July 24 while the secretariat read the accusations he faces. The episode occurred a day after a jury returned a guilty verdict against his mother and co-defendant, Elvia Cabrera Rivera.
The hearing began at around 9:39 am. The accused wore her black hair down. He was wearing a long-sleeved blue shirt with white lines, white pants, and gold shoes. She remained seated at the far left of the defense table. A few feet away, two rows behind her, her family was sitting.
After opening the work, the judge reported that potential jurors would look at photographs of the witnesses who will testify at the trial. This step serves to identify possible conflicts of interest, such as someone knowing a witness or having a relationship that could compromise their impartiality.
“There is an issue with two of the witnesses,” Reyes Colon simply said before asking the parties to approach the stand. Some time later, the robe decreed a recess. When the process resumed, more than 30 jury candidates entered the room and the judge explained to them the procedures that would be carried out during the day.
Then, Reyes Colon asked Aviles Cabrera to stand up and openly asked the candidates if they knew the accused, if they had any ties of friendship, kinship or any other type of relationship with her. When asked, two jury candidates responded affirmatively.
Subsequently, the prosecutor Belinda Brignoni Hernandez He placed the images on the projector, one by one, of all the Public Prosecutor’s witnesses. During the exercise, several prospective jurors raised their hands when identifying one or more of the witnesses who appeared in the images.
One of the candidates indicated that he knew Miriathny Aviles Rodriguez, half-sister of the accused, because she studied at a school where he worked. However, when asked by the judge, he explained that he never taught her classes or had a relationship with her outside of the school environment.
Likewise, another candidate raised her hand when the image of Lismary Torres Rosarioolder sister of the victim. “I have seen her,” he responded, while ruling out that he had shared with her or that they had any kind of relationship. “He is not related to me,” the woman stressed when asked by Reyes Colon.
Similarly, another candidate got up from the bench where she was sitting when she saw the image of Bethshaida Carattinithe victim’s aunt-in-law and one of the main witnesses in the Pratts Rosario murder case. “She was a neighbor of my stepson,” she commented when the judge asked her how she was related.
Likewise, there were other candidates who indicated that they knew, for example, agents of the Police that they were involved at some point in the investigation of the case, either because they go to the same gym, studied together, are neighbors or because they simply worked together in the Uniformed Forces.
And the fact is that, among the potential members of the jury, according to the answers they have given, there are everything from teachers and merchants to former agents of the Criminal Investigation Corps (CIC) of Aibonito. There is also a mother whose son works as a supervisor in the Institute of Forensic Sciences (ICF).
Defense presents nine witnesses
For its part, the defense of the accused presented in court images of nine witnesses, mostly doctors, as well as a photograph of the lawyer. Athelyn Jimenez Emmanuellidefense lawyer who was not present in the courtroom. The process was carried out by the attorney Maria S. Saez Matos.
Of the defense witnesses, only two were recognized by two prospective jurors. One of them explained that she knew one of the witnesses because “she works for the same system that I work for.” Meanwhile, the other candidate indicated that she had seen one of the doctors who appear as defense witnesses, since her nephew works with him.
“Did you present nine witnesses to these potential jury candidates, mostly doctors?” a journalist asked the defense.
“That’s right. That’s right. Those are doctors who, at the time, if necessary, would be used in the case.”said the lawyer Rocio Revelles Ponceof the Legal Aid Society (SALT).
New jury panels are convened for the same day that marks one year since the victim’s death
Given what had happened in the first half of the court session this Tuesday, the judge summoned, as a matter of urgency, six new panels for August 11, the one-year anniversary of the victim’s murder.
“It is urgent because one is already seeing the difficulties that choosing a jury is presenting,” said Revelles Ponce.who indicated that “at this time” the defense is not planning to change from jury trial to court by law so that it is the judge who evaluates all of the evidence in the case.
Regarding whether he trusts that they will be able to get a jury panel that is fair and can see the evidence, he answered: “This has been a case that even the governor of Puerto Rico (Jenniffer Gonzalez Colon) made statements, not about this case, but highly related. Given the above, we know that the publicity in this case has been terrible. In other words, we are going to work day by day.”
For its part, Brignoni Hernandez He indicated that he understands that it is not that complex to select a jury panel.
“That is what the questions that have been asked during these days are for and at least my perception is that we have been able to qualify and interview to know which people really cannot be there due to a health situation or because they have some conflict,” commented the prosecutor when asked by journalists.
Background of the case
The events occurred on the night of Sunday, August 10, 2025, when a brawl occurred on the Roberto Colon detour. In the middle of the incident, Pratts Rosario, nicknamed “Lela,” was wounded 11 times with a knife. Likewise, Pratts Rosario’s best friend was stabbed.
1/11 | 📷 After the verdict, Gabriela Nicole’s relatives return to where everything happened in Aibonito. After a jury found Elvia Cabrera guilty for the murder of Gabrierla Nicole Pratts, the young woman’s relatives went to the Roberto Colon bypass, where the crime occurred in August 2025. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
Both victims were transported in separate vehicles to Menonita Hospital. There, at 12:35 am on Monday, August 11, 2025, Dr. Carla Mercado certified the death of Pratts Rosario. In contrast, the other minor recovered from the wound received in the back of the neck.
At the moment, the weapon used to commit the crime has not been seized by the authorities. However, the formal accusation offers a description: “a sharp sharp object, approximately one inch wide and five inches long, with a sharp point, or a similar object” considered a knife.
