When two steel columns buckled this week inside Pfizer’s former headquarters in downtown manhattanthe incident prompted evacuations and halted work on one of the largest office-to-apartment conversions in USA.
It also highlighted the complex engineering required for adaptive reuse projects, which have become increasingly popular as authorities try to address the nationwide housing shortage by converting offices that have remained underutilized since the COVID-19 pandemic.
Plans call for converting two office buildings — one built in 1909, the other in the 1960s — into about 1,600 apartments, adding more than a dozen floors above the older structure and redesigning and expanding the other.
The deformation occurred on the 21st floor of the most recent structure, and crews installed temporary supports while authorities investigate.
Engineering experts said the conversion project is complex and presents numerous challenges, including ensuring old buildings can safely support new loads and dividing office floors to accommodate housing.
1 / 14 | Images of the emergency: a building in the heart of New York is evacuated due to possible collapse. An office skyscraper, which was formerly the headquarters of the pharmaceutical company Pfizer, was evacuated due to fear of a possible collapse of the structure. -Angelina Katsanis
However, none considered that this high-profile setback should raise doubts about the engineers’ ability to complete these types of projects.
“I don’t think this really calls into question our knowledge of how to do something like that,” said Ben Schafer, a professor of structural engineering at Johns Hopkins University.
How do you build a new tower on top of an old one?
On its website, which highlights the project in midtown Manhattan, adaptive reuse firm Collaborative Construction Management indicates that the nine-story building built in 1909 will be “pierced” by a new approximately 30-story poured concrete structure.
Schafer, who is not involved in the project, explained that the most likely approach is to allow the century-old building to continue supporting its own weight while a new structural system is built to support the additions.
“My interpretation would be that they are going to let that building bear its own load and they will simply open holes in it to be able to transfer the load of the building that they placed on top to the foundation”Schafer explained.
Schafer noted that work on the other tower presents a different challenge: opening holes in the existing slabs to allow light into the apartments, while ensuring the steel structure can withstand the new added loads.
City officials have not yet determined what caused the columns to deform. However, both Schafer and Emily Guglielmo, a San Francisco-based structural engineer, believe the failure was likely a result of the additional loading.
Spokespeople for MetroLoft, the project’s developer, did not respond Thursday to requests for comment. However, Nathan Berman, the firm’s founder, acknowledged in an interview with The Wall Street Journal that the additional weight caused by expanding the building’s top 15 or so floors likely caused the damage.
Guglielmo believes that the assumptions of the original design may have been misinterpreted, that something may have failed during the design or construction process, or that construction crews overloaded or weakened the structure.
Adding floors to existing buildings is a common practice in densely populated urban areas where land is scarce, he explained. However, the process requires reviewing the original construction documents and inspecting the building before determining how the additional floors will affect the structure.
“In cities and towns that do not have that geographical space available, we will see many more designs of this type, in which an adaptive reuse of an existing building is carried out”Guglielmo stated.
Why not just build a new building from scratch?
For many structural engineers, demolition should be considered only as a last resort.
“Tearing down buildings is a terrible waste,” said Schafer, noting that buildings and the construction sector are responsible for about 40% of the world’s energy-related carbon emissions. “From a sustainability point of view, that is a disaster.”
Beyond the environmental costs, demolishing and removing debris from huge buildings is especially costly in densely populated cities like New York.
If an existing structure can be safely reused, engineers generally prefer to do so.
James LaFave, a professor of structural engineering at the University of Illinois, said a steel-frame building built in the 1960s, like the former Pfizer headquarters, would typically be a starting point. “very good” for a conversion.
Does the incident in New York cast doubt on other adaptive reuse projects?
In recent years, authorities across the country have embraced office-to-residential conversions as a potential lifeline for city center business districts, which have faced difficulties since the pandemic.
New York, in particular, has promoted this initiative through changes in zoning regulations and the approval of tax incentives to stimulate housing construction.
A report from the New York City Comptroller’s Office released last year indicated that there are 44 adaptive reuse projects in the city that, as of early 2025, were either completed, in development or could move forward.
Pfizer vacated the building in 2023, after opening a new office near Penn Station, leaving the property vacant. Work began in 2024.
Joshua Harris, director of the Real Estate Institute at Fordham University, said office-to-residential conversions are a critical part of the solution to the housing shortage in New York and other cities, even if they come with risks.
“In some ways, it’s not terribly surprising that this happened and we should take some consideration.”he stated. “Extremely complicated surgical procedures are being performed in very old buildings.”
“This is part of the reality of addressing the housing crisis”Harris continued. “Things like this can happen. It doesn’t seem as complex as sending a rocket into space, but from a real estate point of view, building in an environment like Manhattan, on 42nd Street and Second Avenue, is extremely complex.”
Guglielmo, the California engineer, explained that the combination of building codes, inspections and experienced crews makes failures like this rare.
“We are very lucky here in the United States to not see these types of failures every day”he indicated. “We are privileged to have really strong building codes that explain to us, as engineers, how to do our designs in a safe way.”
Still, Harris maintained that the incident will likely represent a reality check for the industry, as office conversions transform business districts that were once largely deserted after hours into 24-hour neighborhoods, as has happened in recent years on parts of Wall Street.
“If this building has a problem, those responsible for all the other projects that have been given the green light will want to review them to make sure something similar does not exist,” Harris noted.
