Aibonite – Almost a year after the murder of the teenager Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario16 years old, the judicial process against Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera entered its decisive phase with the beginning of the selection of the jury that will evaluate the evidence presented at the trial.
Aviles Cabrera, 18 years old, arrived at 8:38 am at Aibonite Courtaccompanied by her lawyers and without commenting, with her hair down and a white band that matched her shirt and belt of the same color, as well as gray pants with fine lines.
Once in room 3, the accused took a seat on the right side of the defense table until the senior judge entered. Juan A. Reyes Colonwho presides over the trial he faces on charges of first degree murder and violations of Weapons Law.
Both Aviles Cabrera and his mother, Elvia Cabrera Riveraface separate trials for those crimes. However, on June 11, the accusation against the young woman was amended to incorporate three aggravating factors that, if found guilty, would carry a greater penalty.
In this process, the Aibonitena, who is judged as an adult, remains in the free community after obtaining an appeal habeas corpusafter the constitutional term of 180 days to keep her under detention had expired without starting the trial against her.
Before an almost full room, where relatives of both the accused and the victim gathered, the process began with a request from the prosecutor Belinda Brignoni Hernandez to the robe to get closer to the podium for a moment and clarify “one point for the record.”
Brignoni Hernandez explained that the defense maintained in a recent motion that the Public Ministry had not completed the discovery of evidence in accordance with Rule 95 of Criminal Procedure. However, the prosecutor assured that this was incorrect.
As an example, he indicated that one of the documents mentioned by the defense – a receipt related to an Apple watch – was delivered on April 6. In his opinion, the motion “seems to mislead the court,” which is why he requested that this point be clearly clarified.
Appearance of witnesses
The parties then approached the stand and spoke briefly with the judge. He ordered the five defense witnesses summoned to stand up, who explained, in a general way, the procedure they must follow when appearing before the jury.
As part of the ordinary process, the jury must meet the witnesses to rule out conflicts of interest. For this reason, the judge gave two options to the witnesses: being in person in court, but outside the courtroom or, as an alternative, having a color photograph taken.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
This last option was the one accepted by the five defense witnesses – four women and one man. Therefore, they were excused from appearing in person at the court each time a new panel of jury candidates was formed.
At the moment, it is unclear whether these witnesses will be used in a non-prosecution defense, an approach that the defendant’s legal representation has repeatedly outlined and taken to the Supreme Court, where it received an adverse ruling.
Instructions given
With this matter taken care of, the judge proceeded to give general instructions, beginning by explaining that a “hybrid method” will be used for jury selection, in which the parties will not have to challenge candidates at this stage.
Jury challenges are requests by parties to exclude people from the jury panel when they believe they may not be impartial or meet the criteria necessary to render a verdict in the case.
Reyes Colon also reported that he has already received “several” medical and personal excuses from jury candidates who asked to be excused. He also indicated that he will not allow the Public Ministry or the defense to ask “repetitive” or “oppressive questions.”
1 / 5 | Outside the court: relatives of Gabriela Nicole Pratts demand justice. Relatives of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario arrived at the Aibonito Court to demand justice. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
Regarding the candidates who did not appear, he announced that he will issue a show cause order and that he will order the summons of six additional panels to appear in court on August 24. “Let those subpoenas be made through the sheriff,” he said.
First 27 jury candidates
Subsequently, the first 27 jury candidates entered the room, 14 men and 13 women. At 10:32 am they were sworn in, after which some presented medical and personal excuses in order to be exempt from the process.
“That will be addressed in due course,” said Reyes Colon, who added in court that, at the end of the process, 12 residents of the Aibonito judicial region should have been selected as main members of the jury, as well as six substitutes.
He added that the six substitutes will be excused once the case is submitted to deliberation. However, he specified that, if a situation arises with a main member of the jury and he must be excused, then a substitute will take that place.
Next, the robed man went on to speak to the jury about three main elements that govern the judicial process: the presumption of innocence, reasonable doubt and the weight of proof. “If selected, (it is necessary) that they be able to issue a fair and impartial verdict,” he said.
“That will be addressed in due course,” said Reyes Colon, who added that, at the end of the process, 12 residents of the Aibonito judicial region should have been selected as main members of the jury, as well as six substitutes.
He also emphasized to the jurors that “the defendant does not have to sit down and testify and has the right to remain silent.” “The defendant has a constitutional right to remain silent….they cannot infer anything positive or negative from that.”
