Editor’s note: Visit this special site to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
The judge Juan A. Reyes Colonof the Aibonite Courtdeclared “there is no place” to the request presented by the defense of Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera to challenge the jury candidates in the trial for the murder of the teenager Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years old.
However, he declared “with place” regarding the defendant exercising her constitutional right to have her trial heard before a jury, which will have the responsibility of evaluating the evidence, deliberating and then issuing a verdict of guilty or not guilty in the case.
The jury selection process begins tomorrow at 9:00 am in Room 3 of the Judicial Center.
“The Court must safeguard said constitutional right of the accused, unless she renounces it voluntarily, intelligently and with knowledge of the consequences. In the absence of a waiver, the Court expresses that in the exercise of its discretion it will always understand and must determine the trial by jury and order the corresponding drawing of candidates.“, indicated in the resolution issued this Monday, which consists of two pages.
However, when asked to recuse the General Panel of Jury Candidates, Reyes Colon rejected it. “There is no room,” he said.
“Having examined the grounds for said request, there is no legal basis to support said request. The desaculation process is the prophylactic mechanism to discard or excuse candidates who are not suitable according to law and right to be finally sworn in as jurors. The Court and in accordance with the requests of the parties will safeguard that during said process only those jury candidates who do not meet the requirements of the law and who, according to the law, are not suitable candidates and cannot make their determination in a fair, reasonable and impartial manner are excused,” he commented.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
Regarding what the defendant’s defense alleged, that the request from six panels of jury candidates was “untimely,” since it was made more than three months ago and “it carries the wrong message that from the beginning the judge was interested or desired that the trier of fact in this case be a jury”the man indicated that “he feels obliged to point out and censor” the expression.
“As we explained previously, criminal cases with a penalty of serious crime, both in accordance with the Constitution of the United States of America and the Constitution of Puerto Rico, are mandated or presumed to be submitted and resolved before a jury. The Court ordered the drawing of the candidate panels, anticipating and safeguarding said right. It’s not about interest or desire. This ignored comment imputes to the Court a desire interest unrelated to the process and we must censure said imputation without any factual or legal basis. As a matter of fact, whether the Court, after having examined the accused (and without any legal basis to the contrary); would not have rejected a valid and intelligent waiver of said right. But, having reiterated his desire for the trial to be submitted and deliberated before a jury; The Court is aware. “That’s how it was ordered,” the judge said.
Just hours before the selection of jury candidates begins, a process that must culminate with the election of 12 main members plus alternates, Reyes Colon also clarified to the defense that the discovery of evidence was terminated on June 18, 2026..
“A page or sheet of proceedings, as mentioned in the parties’ motions, does not violate due process of law or places the accused in a state of defenselessness; as long as the defense has previously obtained the substantive or testimonial evidence that is intended to be offered against her and to which reference is made in said document; unless the defense places this Court in a position to resolve otherwise,” the lawyer stated.
In this case, Aviles Cabrera is represented by the attorneys Maria Soledad Saez Matos, Athelyn Jimenez Emmanuell and Rocio Revelles Ponceof the Legal Aid Society.
The accused and her mother Elvia Cabrera Rivera face two counts of first-degree murder and violation of the Weapons Law for the murder of Pratts Rosario, which occurred after a brawl on the Roberto Colon bypass on Sunday night. August 10, 2025in Aibonito.
The death of the minor was certified by Dr. Carla Mercado at 12:35 am on Monday, August 11, 2025, at the Menonita hospital.
