Appellate Court upholds $165,000 fine against property owner in Bahia de Jobos

Appellate Court upholds 5,000 fine against property owner in Bahia de Jobos

He appeals court validated a fine of $165,000 that the Department of Natural and Environmental Resources (DNER) imposed against the owner of a property in Jobos Bayin Salinaswhich since 2011 has failed to comply with a resolution that ordered it to remove several structures – including a pier – that it built without authorization in the maritime-terrestrial zone.

The tract of the case against Victor L. Albertorioas can be seen from the sentence issued last Friday, dates back to 2005, when the agency filed the complaint that resulted in the resolution and order signed by the then secretary, Daniel Galan Kercadoin August 2011.

At that time, Galan Kercado ordered Albertorio “to remove the pier, the platform and the ramp, as well as carry out the necessary restoration in the affected area.”

However, in March 2016, security guard Jorge M. Rodriguez Rivera, on a visit to the area where the property is located, “he realized that the Complainant (Albertorio) was rebuilding the pier,” which triggered a second administrative process that culminated last year with a fine of $165,000. The penalty is broken down into an administrative fine of $5,000 for each year in which the violations of Regulation 4860 materialized since 2011, added to another $10,000 for each year corresponding to the concept of recidivism.

The DNER secretary, Anais Rodriguez Vegaaccepted the report of the examining officer on September 8, 2022, before Albertorio was notified of the penalty on the 14th of that month.

Among the defenses that Albertorio presented to the Court of Appeals are alleged failures in the due process of law and not having recognized his seniority rights over the property, which he has owned since 1973.three years before the approval of Law 136 for the Conservation, Development and Use of Water Resources.

Given the latter approach, the panel of the Court of Appeals, made up of judges Abelardo Bermudez Torres, Giselle Romero Garcia and Jose Monge Gomezconcluded that Law 136 covers acquired rights in relation to “surface waters, groundwater and coastal waters through the system of wells or water intakes” and not over the maritime-terrestrial zone.

“Because the DNER established, through substantial evidence in the file, that Mr. Albertorio does not have DNER permission for the use and exploitation of the maritime land zone, as required by Regulation No. 4860, his argument loses validity”, adds the sentence.

The Jobos Bay area, and in particular the structures located on Los Indios road, have been under the public eye since 2022, when a legislative investigation revealed the allegedly illegal use that alleged landowners gave to spaces located within of the area designated as a nature reserve at the federal level. As emerged in the investigative process of the Natural Resources Commission of the House of Representatives, over the decades segregation and construction and filling work took place without further intervention by the authorities.

In April of last year, the DNER filed an eviction lawsuit against 12 people who had illegally occupied land in the Jobos Bay National Estuarine Research Reserve, in a case that remains pending resolution.

Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media is a News and Entertainment Website & Channel. Kumneger Media in addition to News and Entertainment it is the hub of Politics, Movies, Drama, Music, Comedy, Documentary and More!