:format(jpeg):focal(4800x370:4810x360)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/RA5CDJEODZB2TIQDB22M5H4POU.jpg)
sure you have seen images of athletes immersing themselves in icy water after training. Since it was popularized by Wim Hof, known as “Iceman”, the practice has spread in the world of fitness first, and then to other disciplines.
Preventive effects on health, stimulation of the central nervous system, improvement of muscle performance and recovery after exercise: Multiple virtues are attributed to this active recovery strategy after physical activity and it has become one of the most popular in recent years.
Although many athletes, both professional and amateur, use it, they are not always well informed about the real benefits of this practice and its effectiveness. Are ice baths, cold showers or cryotherapy chambers at -80 °C (in specialized establishments) really beneficial? Is it just a fad? Who can benefit?
Endless Physiological Responses
The most important physiological adaptation to extreme cold is undoubtedly the narrowing of the blood vessels, or vasoconstriction, which is probably intended to reduce the loss of body heat. In the short term, ice baths cause a rapid increase in blood pressure, which in turn causes an increase in heart rate and breathing.
As the blood vessels narrow, the blood flow to submerged areas slows down. This can be useful to combat excess microbleeding and microinflammation induced by certain physical activities that involve repeated blows. If exposure to cold is prolonged, the end of our nerve endings, just under the skin, can be reduced in sensitivity to the point of producing a numbing effect.
There is also evidence that swimming in cold water can modulate the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines, small proteins that activate the body’s inflammatory response, which can have an analgesic effect. But be careful: An ice bath should not be long, due to the real risk of hypothermia, which has serious consequences.
What are the potential benefits?
Considering these physiological changes, why do athletes choose this method after exercise? The most common reason is your belief that it will “heal” your sore muscles.
By reducing blood flow in submerged areas, ice baths reduce edema (swelling), aided by the effect of hydrostatic pressure. And, as we said, cold has an analgesic effect, useful in case of traumatic injury; hence the use of ice packs in case of local injuries or to relieve postoperative pain.
But be careful, the cold does not heal: the pain will return when the temperature rises again. Therefore, it should only be used occasionally and symptomatically.
And what about muscle pain that appears after an intense effort? It has been suggested that as a result of vasoconstriction of blood vessels, muscle injuries may experience a weaker inflammatory response, resulting in less muscle pain.
In the last ten years, various studies have shown that immersion in cold water can improve, to a certain extent, the treatment of delayed cramps (24-48 hours). A study of elite rugby players, conducted over three weeks of competition, found that they experienced a reduction in muscle fatigue and a slight reduction in cramps.
Other investigations have also suggested a modest positive effect on muscle soreness perceived by mixed martial arts athletes. But no performance improvement was observed.
However, youThere is also evidence to suggest that cooling is not necessarily beneficial for post-exercise recovery. The perceived benefits would be due to a placebo effect.
In one experiment, volunteers were challenged with cryotherapy (3-4 minutes at -85°C), cold water immersion (10 minutes at 10°C), and placebo after strength training. The differences were negligible, with some biological and performance markers even favoring placebo.
A meta-analysis also reported that the proposed benefits of cold water immersion (10°C and 13 minutes on average) appeared to be based more on subjective markers (perception of pain and sensation of exertion difficulty) than objective ones (blood markers). ).
In summary, Cold water immersion, primarily because of its ability to reduce tissue temperature and blood flow, can reduce muscle soreness and edema, but its effects on muscle recovery and performance are hotly contested.
The beneficial effects on recovery after exercise appear to be context-specific, and factors such as body composition, gender, type of physical exertion, and training status need to be taken into account.
Friend or foe of muscle growth?
Recent data have shown that Post-exercise cool-down can be detrimental when the goal is to build muscle mass (hypertrophy).
One study indicates that acute cold exposure reduces the anabolism of skeletal muscle proteins (allowing for muscle growth) while increasing their catabolism (leading to breakdown). This has no effect on muscle strength.
Another study examined the effects of active recovery and ice baths on adaptations to resistance training. After twelve weeks, the ice baths reduced muscle growth…and strength gains!
The acute (negative) effects of immersion in cold water appear in the long term, perhaps as a result of a reduction in testosterone circulating in the blood.. If gaining muscle mass and strength is a goal, cold water immersion should therefore be avoided as a post-exercise recovery strategy.
So, is it advisable to take ice baths?
Potentially expensive and slow, ice baths (10-15°C for 11-15 minutes) are not a panacea. They can help reduce delayed muscle soreness, but the same applies to active recovery, such as walking, which is cheaper and much easier to do.
Although in the short term there may be a faster recovery, a reduction in inflammation and cramps, in the long term cold water immersion would have no effect, neither positive nor negative, on physiological adaptations.
Above all, cold water is not suitable for bodybuilders or weightlifters who want to build muscle mass and strength. But, at the same time, it can be advantageous for them to enjoy the benefits of an ice bath after a very intense training session or a competition.
So, the use of the bathroom will depend on your sporting activity and your goals. Also, if you have high blood pressure or cardiovascular disease, an ice bath may be counterproductive. Medical advice is required.
