:format(jpeg):focal(2702x1289:2712x1279)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/F3OI6OWLQNDTTBOWGYPX3EPE6I.jpg)
Five years after his death, the music superstar’s last wishes Aretha Franklin remain unresolved. A rare trial begins next Monday to determine which of his two handwritten wills, including one found between the cushions of a sofa, will guide the handling of his estate.
The Queen of Soul, who had four children, did not have a formal typewritten will, despite years of failing health and efforts to get her to make one.. But under Michigan law, it is still possible to treat other documents—with scribbles, erasures, and hard-to-read passages—as your orders.
The dispute pits one son against other sons. Ted White II believes documents dated 2010 should primarily control the estate, while Kecalf Franklin and Edward Franklin favor a 2014 document. Both were discovered at Franklin’s suburban Detroit home months after his death from pancreatic cancer in 2018 at age 76.
“Am I surprised someone passed away before they got their affairs in order? The answer is never,” said Pat Simasko, who specializes in wills and probate and teaches elder law at Michigan State University College of Law.
“This can be resolved at any time, out of court, in the middle of the trial,” he said. “And hopefully it will be. Going to a jury trial is war.”
Here’s a look at the case:
THE DEATH OF FRANKLIN
Franklin was a global star for decades, best known for hits like “Think,” “I Say a Little Prayer” and “Respect.” Treated like musical royalty upon her death, her body was transported in a 1940 Cadillac hearse to a Detroit museum where thousands of people said goodbye to her in August 2018.
“She was the diva of the people,” sociologist Michael Eric Dyson said at the time.
It was immediately known that Franklin had died without a will, meaning his four children would likely share millions of dollars worth of assets, including suburban Detroit real estate, furs, dresses, jewelry and future royalties from his works.. A niece, Sabrina Owens, has agreed to be a personal representative or executor.
“Go slow, be careful and be smart,” businessman and Franklin friend Ron Moten told the sons at the funeral.
WHAT IS THIS?
Months later, in the spring of 2019, the singer’s estate was turned upside down. Owens reported that she found a handwritten will dated 2010 in a cabinet and a handwritten will dated 2014 inside a notebook under cushions in Franklin’s home.
There are differences between the documents, although both seem to indicate that the children will share the music and royalties income, which seems to make that topic less contentious than others.
“The interesting thing here…is her legacy and the management of her legacy and her royalties and the operation of Aretha Franklin’s business going forward. That’s huge,” Simasko said.
The earlier will lists White and Owens as co-executors and says Kecalf and Edward Franklin “must take business classes and obtain a certificate or title” to benefit from the estate.
But the 2014 version crosses out White’s name as executor and has Kecalf Franklin in his place. Business classes are not mentioned. Kecalf Franklin and his grandchildren would get his mother’s main house in Bloomfield Hills, which was valued at $1.1 million when Franklin died but is worth much more today.
“It’s the jewel in the crown,” said Craig Smith, attorney for Edward Franklin.
Aretha Franklin wrote in 2014 that her dresses could be up for auction or go to the Smithsonian Institution in Washington. She indicated in both documents that her eldest son, Clarence, who lives in conservatorship, should receive regular support.
“Two contradictory wills cannot be admitted for proof. In such cases, the most recent will revokes the earlier will,” Charles McKelvie, an attorney for Kecalf Franklin, said in a court filing in favor of the 2014 document.
But White’s attorney, Kurt Olson, said the 2010 will was notarized and signed, while the latest version “is merely a draft.”
“If this document was intended to be a will, more care would have been taken than putting it in a spiral notebook under a sofa cushion,” Olson said.
INTENTION IS THE KEY
Simasko, the law instructor, said last wills can be fulfilled in Michigan through an informal will.
“If you’re sitting there on a Sunday afternoon and you start to handwrite your own will, the law allows it, as long as you follow the rules: It’s handwritten, it’s dated and it’s signed,” he said.
For five years, Aretha Franklin’s estate has been managed at different times by three executors. Owens stepped down in 2020, citing a “rift” between her children.
She was succeeded by Reginald Turner, a local lawyer who also served as president of the American Bar Association. His last accounting in March showed the estate had income of $3.9 million during the prior 12-month period and a similar amount of expenses, including more than $900,000 in legal fees from various firms.
Total assets were pegged at $4.1 million, mostly in cash and real estate, though Franklin’s creative works and intellectual property were undervalued by a nominal $1.
Since 2020 the estate has paid at least $8.1 million to the IRS, which filed a tax claim after the singer’s death, court documents show.
“IRS claims took precedence. The estate would not go anywhere until the IRS was paid,” Smith said.
