:format(jpeg):focal(726x248:736x238)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/DTSNSCPXHBFK7KNTEJTUSX2Z6E.jpg)
The federal case for corruption that involves the former popular collector Anaudi Hernandez suffered another setback after the guilty verdicts against the sisters Ivonne Falcon Nieves and Marielis Falcon Nieves will be set aside on appeal.
A panel of judges from the Court of Appeals for the First Circuit in Boston voided the guilty verdicts against both.
For some of the charges, revoked convictions upon finding that there was not “sufficient” evidence to support them.
While, annulled the convictions of the other charges because they understood that it was an error of the District Court not to have allowed them to have a separate trial. It remains to be seen whether on these particular charges the federal prosecutor’s office will proceed with a new trial when the case is returned to San Juan.
The Falcon Nieves sisters and other defendants were found guilty by a jury on October 7, 2016, for allegedly conspiring with Hernandez, a Popular Democratic Party (PPD) fundraiser, in an alleged corruption, influence peddling and bribery scheme. to benefit it in the awarding of central government contracts.
Ivonne Falcon Nieves was sentenced to eight years in prison, and Marielis was sentenced to three years in prison, but both immediately went to the First Circuit.
Another setback in the case
This is not the first setback for the Public Ministry in the same case, which dates back to 2015, when a federal grand jury returned 25 criminal charges against ten defendants.
At that time, Ivonne Falcon was the vice president of the Aqueduct and Sewer Authority (AAA), while another of the defendants was Sally Lopez, who served as director of the Labor Development Administration (ADL).
In December 2020, a Boston panel reversed the guilty verdict and nine-year sentence against Lopez. It also determined that he should have had a separate trial, so it ordered that it be held again. But, the parties reached an agreement to plead guilty to one of the six charges and he only served the time he had already served in prison.
The federal prosecutor’s office also dropped charges against another defendant who was facing two counts.
Judge’s Opinion
In an opinion published Wednesday of this week, the presiding appellate judge in Boston, David J Barronexplained that the panel ruled in favor of the sisters in two ways.
On the one hand, reversed some of the guilty verdicts against Ivonne Falcon by rejecting the prosecution’s arguments that there was sufficient evidence to support them in one charge of bribery, in two of the charges for electronic fraud in “honest services” and in the complaint of extortion in concert and mutual agreement.
For example, in relation to one of those charges, the judicial opinion indicates that the prosecution supported jurisdiction in a contract for the transfer of funds from ADL to PRASA, but the case record “does not contain anything to show that that amount was transferred ”.
Regarding other charges, he acknowledged that Hernandez did send him two emails from Lopez, but he did not find that Ivonne Falcon had taken any action in this regard.
The appellate panel also set aside its verdict on some of the conspiracy charges for what it called “a detrimental variant.” According to Barron, “Ivonne’s conviction of conspiracy to commit honest services wire fraud under the first count of the indictment could only have been based on a more limited conspiracy than the one alleged, and trying her for the broader conspiracy was prejudicial.
Therefore, Boston reversed the jury’s verdicts on those charges only.
Meanwhile, on the other hand, although the sisters had asked that they all be revoked for lack of evidence, the panel of judges did find that there was sufficient evidence to support the other guilty verdicts. This was the case against Ivonne Falcon in one of the three charges of electronic fraud and in that of conspiracy for electronic fraud or bribery. He also found it in the extortion guilty verdict of Marielis Falcon.
But, even when they found that there was sufficient evidence in those allegations, the judge explained that they overturned guilty verdicts on those charges with sufficient evidence.
He explained that the annulment was due to the fact that “we agree with the parties that it was an error of the District Court to deny the motions of the sisters” so that their trials were separated from the rest of the defendants.
Indeed, during the trial, the Falcon sisters had requested that their trial be seen separately from the other defendants, particularly Glenn Rivera, who was a House clerk.
Both maintained that the complaints against both had nothing to do with the allegations against Rivera for fraud against the Chamber.
Last year the parties informed the court that there was an ongoing negotiation with Rivera, while Hernandez was the first to plead guilty in February 2016 and has been a cooperating witness for the Public Ministry since then. He has not been sentenced.
