We’ve all heard those people at the gym who make noise every time they lift weights. Do these sounds really improve sports performance or do they just distract others?
The physiological benefits
Not surprisingly, research on athletic shouting is a bit sparse. Some small studies suggest it can improve strength, power, and oxygen use, but researchers aren’t sure how it works.
Most of the benefits have less to do with the sound itself and more to do with the way we breathe beforehand, According to Mary J. Sandage, professor of speech and language at Auburn University, USAwho studies extreme physical activities and speech.
Sandage notes that some studies have found that Some people who have had their larynx removed, and therefore can no longer hold air in their lungs, have difficulty lifting heavy objects. This suggests that some of our strength may come from something called the Valsalva maneuver, in which pressure is applied to the lungs while the throat is closed (similar to pushing during a bowel movement).
“We do it to produce force. We need to make an air trap to lift or push“Creating internal pressure in the core in this way can strengthen the spine and allow for a little more power to be produced. Grunting, then, acts as a release valve for this pressure. For Sandage, the benefits of grunting likely apply only to short bursts of effort, such as lifting a weight or hitting a tennis ball.
The psychological benefits
There is, of course, another explanation for why growling is useful: it could be mostly mental.
“I also see it as a way to focus attention. As an emotional release and channeling.”says Sarah Ullrich-French, sports psychologist.
Shouting is not the only way to do it. Some prefer conscious breathing, while others may concentrate their eyes on a fixed point, but the idea is to find a mental zone where performance seems easier. In addition, the psychologist points out that focusing techniques can help you better tune into your own body and increase the benefits of exercise for the mental health.
In Japanese martial arts, for example, Athletes use the meditation and the short, shouted vowels called kiais to concentrate their energy. Making noise can also help set a rhythm, since we typically grunt at the peak of exertion, says Scott Sinnett, a cognitive psychologist who has studied vocalization in competitive sports.
Sandage agrees that the benefits are both psychological and physiological. And different types of noise might serve different purposes.
Social issues
Whether or not making noise improves your performance, it definitely affects the people around you. A good grunt can even change the way your tennis opponent evaluates your serve, masking the sound of the hit.
“If you can’t hear the sound of the ball and the spin it produces, and the weight of it, it’s going to affect you,” reflects Marjorie Blackwood, a three-time Canadian tennis champion who has spent the past 40 years training and working in the sport.
Sinnett adds that for a novice player, it can be just a distraction to hear someone growl at them.
While those same grunts and moans at the gym while lifting weights may distract your neighbor, you shouldn’t hold back the next time you want to squeeze out that last bit of energy.according to Sandage. She notes that there is a stigma around people, especially women, making loud noises while exercising. Because of this, she encourages people to use whatever tools they have at their disposal.
But if you really don’t like it, Sinnett says a loud, quick exhale can be just as effective as a grunt. Blackwood, meanwhile, believes it’s okay to make a little noise, but you shouldn’t overdo it, whether on the court, in the gym or in a peaceful national forest. “Small noises,” he suggests.
