:format(jpeg):focal(3325x2885:3335x2875)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/OPSWAXQWPFDVFMNNKQ7MEFO63A.jpg)
Judge Abid Quinones Portalatinof the Court of Aguadilla, granted today, Wednesday, a period of 15 days to the parties involved in the case of the Sol y Playa condominium, in Rincon, to evaluate alternatives that will allow, finally, to execute the sentence that orders the demolition of an area illegally built recreational facility in the housing complex.
The defendant – the residents of the condominium – agreed to continue the efforts to begin demolition work, form a new Council of Owners and issue the necessary payments to start the work.
Meanwhile, the Planning Board (JP), as plaintiff, was responsible for evaluating a proposal presented by Camp Carey before the Department of Natural and Environmental Resources (DNER) to carry out the demolition.
“We are going to meet with the people of Camp Carey next week, obviously, subject to what our clients authorize us to do and, in 15 days, we will establish what course will be followed to comply with this sentence”declared the lawyer Alfonso Oronarepresenting the JP.
A follow-up court hearing was scheduled for September 20, at 10:00 am
If it emerges from the agreements that Camp Carey will carry out the works, the Council of Owners would be obliged to pay it for the work, according to rules 51 and 51.3 of Civil Procedure.
“I am open to all possibilities. As I told you from the beginning, my only interest is that the sentence is carried out in the best way, the fastest, but, above all, the one that causes the least damage to the environment, to the residents of Sol y Playa and to the residents of the surrounding areas“, stated Quinones Portalatin.
“Of course, at the next hearing, I don’t want to waste time… so I want proposals, I want fixed dates to start the work and how it will be done. I want to hear all of this in the room next time,” the dressed man stressed.
The graduate Mildred Sotomayorrepresenting the DRNA, said that the agency would not rule out the Camp Carey proposal if the condominium does not take steps to execute the demolition order.
JP without economic capacity to enforce sentence
During the judicial hearing held this afternoon in the Aguadilla Court, the judge presented the alternative that the JP execute the provisions of the sentence. However, Orona said that, “given the lack of transparency of the condominium,” the agency could not take the risk of taking on the demolition work.
He added that The JP does not have the economic capacity or the infrastructure to enforce the sentence. “At the end of the day, we are here because of the lack of transparency and the stubborn attitude of the Council (of Owners). First, by masking a new construction as if it were a reconstruction and, Even after the sentence became final and firm, what we have heard have been excuses, accommodating resignations and last-minute filings.”Orona complained.
“We are talking about the fact that it is very possible, as we have seen here, that the Council ends up not paying, because that is what we have seen now”he added.
Another possibility that was put on the table by the judge, but that was ruled out almost immediately, was that the Department of Consumer Affairs (DACO) appointed a trustee to manage the condominium in the absence of a Council of Owners, as has been raised in two complaints filed with the agency by residents.
However, the attorney Lisoannette Gonzalez Ruizacting secretary of the DACO, confirmed that the agency lacks a registry of trustees. “During yesterday afternoon (Tuesday), we issued an administrative order creating a bank of trustees for any casesince the Department has received several complaints – unrelated to the Sol y Playa case – requesting the appointment of a receiver,” the owner revealed.
Gonzalez Ruiz, who has been in charge of the DACO since April, said that the Condominium Law (Law 129 of 2020), although it does authorize the agency to appoint trustees, does not provide for the creation of a name bank. He added that, in 2020, under the administration of Luis Rivera Marinan edict was issued to create a registry, but there were no interested parties.
The power to appoint a receiver would fall to the administrative judge of the DACO, Pedro Gonzalez. “The purpose of the trustee, after he has been working for six months, will be, precisely, for him to choose a board of owners,” he stated, while pointing out that Law 129 of 2020 also does not provide a term for the agency to appoint an administrator.
On August 15 – after the arrest warrant for contempt issued against the then president of the Council of Owners of Sol y Playa, Maria Isabel Negron Garcia–, the other four remaining members of the executive body resigned from their positions.
During today’s court hearing, the Council’s lawyer, Amy Ruiz Goycohe indicated that there were four residents willing to join the governing body, but alleged that they were “afraid,” as a result, precisely, of the arrest warrant issued against Negron Garcia. He also stated that, in an assembly held last week, the owners formed an alternate committee to make payments necessary to begin the contracting process.
“Whoever wants to say what they want, let them say it. This is the first time that I have to make such drastic decisions in my entire judicial career and I make them without any problem… I am not here to send anyone to jail. “I am here to put the court in a position to make things move,” the judge said, meanwhile.
“Here, no one should be afraid. “Here, what they should have is the will and character to move and do things, which is what has not been here since the sentence was final and firm.”stressed Quinones Portalatin.
On February 14 of last year, the Court of First Instance ordered the Council of Sol y Playa Owners to comply with the order, which also included removing the debris and returning the land to its natural state. However, these works have not been carried out, even though the deadline was March 1 of this year.
