
An agent of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has been subject to disciplinary proceedings for a use-of-force incident since the start of the Trump administration, Democratic members of the House Homeland Security Committee said following a briefing Wednesday with ICE officials on body cameras, vehicle stops and training.
The closed-door briefing for commission members follows two shootings in which ICE agents shot and killed two immigrants they were trying to detain, raising concerns about the agency’s tactics at a time when it is stepping up its detentions.
The shootings in Maine and Houston over the course of a week have drawn harsh criticism for a lack of oversight by the agency key to President Donald Trump’s mass deportation program. At least ten people have died in confrontations with immigration agents since Trump launched the crackdown after returning to office, and in the Maine shooting, relatives of the ICE agent who opened fire say he had a history of violent behavior and should never have been given a badge or gun.
Representative Seth Magaziner, Democrat of Rhode Island, stated that during the briefing they were informed that 56 complaints of excessive use of force had been registered against ICE agents; 32 of them were dismissed and one was referred for disciplinary action. Magaziner noted that they had been informed that no disciplinary sanction had yet been imposed. The rest of the incidents remain under investigation, he added.
“It is simply inconceivable that, in a force of more than 20,000 officers, with all the chaos we have seen over the last year and a half, with the spikes in violence and civilians injured and killed, no one has been detected who has violated the rules on the use of force, except perhaps a single person,” Magaziner said.
The Department of Homeland Security said in a statement Wednesday that ICE agents who violate agency policies are held accountable, receive training in de-escalation tactics and take an annual refresher course on use-of-force policies. The agency also defended its agents, noting that they work in an environment where they are constantly targeted.
“In dangerous situations, DHS law enforcement professionals have relied on their training to protect themselves, their colleagues, and the public,” the agency stated.
Use-of-force numbers have increased since February, when then-acting director Todd Lyons testified before the Senate that ICE had opened 37 investigations into excessive use of force; 18 of them had been closed, 19 were still pending and one had been referred for “further action,” Lyons said.
The committee’s top Democrat, Rep. Bennie Thompson of Mississippi, said ICE officials could not discuss the Maine or Houston shootings, as both are ongoing investigations. Thompson, who said the briefing left him with more questions than answers, said he wanted to know who investigates use-of-force incidents. “Sometimes they said the FBI, other times they said HSI. Other times, they mentioned another entity.”
Officials said they were going to retrain officers who had completed a shorter training program last fall, Thompson said. In June, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin stated that the agency would increase the length of training for new agents starting this month.
Thompson said he had insisted on getting answers about how many officers had been called in for additional training and how they were being trained, but was unable to get any clarification.
Thompson said he and the committee chairman, Rep. Andrew Garbarino, R-N.Y., will contact ICE with a list of questions.
Garbarino said he was grateful that ICE had informed the deputies.
“Today was an important opportunity for Members to receive timely responses on the status of the deployment of body cameras for law enforcement in the field, training and selection standards and requirements, and current guidance on the use of traffic stops as part of immigration enforcement,” Garbarino said in a statement.
When it comes to vehicle stops, Magaziner said they had been told that current guidelines for ICE agents state that they should only conduct them when there is no other alternative, and that they should use lights and sirens. However, according to Magaziner, such guidelines have only been conveyed verbally to staff, rather than through a written directive.
Both the Maine and Houston shootings involved shots at immigrants in moving vehicles, raising questions about ICE’s training and policies regarding how it attempts to stop people while driving.
