
atlanta – US President Donald Trump has tried in many ways to tighten his control over US elections, from signing executive orders to pushing restrictive legislation through Congress. The Supreme Court’s ruling on Monday, which sided with states that accept late-arriving mail-in ballots, was the latest example showing the limits of its power.
The court decision came after back-to-back rulings last week that blocked his two sweeping executive orders seeking to change national election rules, more court rulings that prevented his Justice Department from obtaining detailed state voter data, and his stalled efforts to get the Senate to pass the SAVE Act. That measure would eliminate nearly all absentee voting, require citizenship documents to register to vote and impose photo ID requirements nationwide just before the midterm elections.
“It’s been a little bit of everything for Republicans,” said University of Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller. But the president, he added, “has mostly accomplished nothing.”
Trump’s efforts have not been entirely unsuccessful. Republican-ruled states have met his demands to redraw congressional district lines, efforts pushed by the Supreme Court by striking down a key section of the Voting Rights Act, and he has ordered his Justice Department to investigate voting and election operations, something Democrats see as a possible prelude to their turnout in November.
All the activity around how the country votes and how it organizes its elections reflects the Republican president’s long-standing fixation on his false claim that his 2020 election loss was rigged. He has been so frustrated by the Senate’s inability to pass the SAVE Act that he has refused to sign a bipartisan housing bill.
He intervened again on Monday after the Supreme Court’s decision in the mail-in ballot deadline case, stating on his social network that he is trying to “save the United States from corrupt elections.” Voting rights groups and Democrats believe he is abusing his power and trying to suppress legal voters to gain an advantage in the midterm elections, when control of Congress is at stake.
In any case, Muller indicated that Trump faces legal and political realities: The Constitution gives the states and Congress authority over elections, without granting the president a similar role.
“That’s how federalism works,” Muller said.
Below is a review of Trump’s efforts to reshape electoral rules and the options he may still have ahead of the November midterm elections.
Emphasis on non-citizens and voter data has encountered obstacles
The president has insisted that US elections are plagued by fraud in part due to non-citizen votes. Research shows that the problem is rare and represents a tiny percentage of fraud cases. Convictions are counted in the hundreds in periods in which tens of millions of ballots are issued.
Trump’s vision led to an interagency push to nationalize voter data and use federal resources to help states remove voters from rolls. The Justice Department has requested detailed records of voters from several states, data that would include dates of birth and partial Social Security numbers. Democratic and some Republican secretaries of state resisted, and federal lawsuits followed. So far, the government has lost all cases.
Homeland Security Citizenship Verification Rejected in Court
Trump’s Department of Homeland Security, with help from the DOGE initiative led by Elon Musk, revamped a government tool called SAVE (Systematic Alien Verification for Benefits). The program has been a key pillar of their efforts to purge potentially ineligible voters from state rolls.
Last week, a federal judge blocked its use as mass citizenship verification.
The government, according to its own statements, had allowed local election administrators to search for users by the thousands, using a broader range of indicators instead of identification numbers issued by the Department of Homeland Security. At least 67 million registrations were analyzed, mostly in Republican-controlled states. Tens of thousands were flagged as possible non-citizens or deceased, but some voters were wrongly identified as ineligible.
U.S. District Court Judge Sparkle L. Sooknanan ruled that Trump’s changes added Americans’ sensitive personal data in a way that could cause voters to be wrongly removed from the rolls.
“In sum, the federal government has deliberately trampled on the privacy rights of American citizens in a manner that threatens the sacred right to vote,” Sooknanan wrote in his order.
Executive orders used in lieu of legislation
Like previous presidents, Trump signed executive orders when Congress did not pass laws according to his preferences.
Trump’s first order reflected his emphasis on noncitizens. Like the SAVE Act pending on Capitol Hill, it sought to require those intending to vote to document their citizenship in order to register to vote.
U.S. District Court Judge Denise Casper placed a temporary block on the order last year while she considered the case and last week made her decision permanent. The Constitution, Casper wrote, “does not grant the president any specific power over elections.”
Trump issued a second order in March, as the SAVE Act’s difficult path through Congress became clear. He called for a national voter list using data from the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services and the Social Security Administration. Additionally, the order would have empowered the United States Postal Service to determine who receives an absentee ballot and threatened local election officials with criminal prosecution.
Absentee voting is a common feature of US elections, but Trump wrongly describes the practice as enabling fraud, even though he has used it himself. A 2025 report from the Brookings Institution found that mail-in voting fraud occurred in just 0.000043% of total mail-in ballots cast.
Democratic Secretaries of State sued, and U.S. District Court Judge Indira Talwani reached the same legal conclusion as Casper. The provisions, he wrote last week, “unconstitutionally violate the separation of powers.”
The White House has indicated it will appeal.
Even Trump says SAVE Act has little chance
Trump on Monday called the Senate gridlock “insane” and accused one of the holdout senators, Alaska Republican Lisa Murkowski, of suffering from an alleged “Trump disorder.”
It’s a new legislative tussle that led Trump to demand that Republicans eliminate the filibuster, which requires most major legislation to win the support of 60 of the 100 senators. But that probably wouldn’t matter in this case, with four of the Senate’s 53 Republicans declaring their opposition to the bill itself: Murkowski, Susan Collins of Maine, Mitch McConnell of Kentucky and Thom Tillis of North Carolina.
The president acknowledged Monday that the SAVE Act is “probably not going to happen.”
Trump still has options for the November elections
Both major parties have national operations to monitor the elections, including legal teams ready to file challenges.
Although the Republican National Committee lost the case over mail-in ballots, its president, Joe Gruters, alluded to those efforts on Monday: “We will not be deterred by this decision, and the RNC will continue to fight for the elections to end on Election Day,” he said.
Meanwhile, Trump has been drawing up a possible roadmap for more aggressive actions.
His federal prosecutor in Los Angeles said in June that he had opened several voter fraud investigations, and sent a prosecutor to the county’s vote tabulation center after California’s June primary. Six months earlier, FBI agents executed a warrant and seized ballots and other records from the 2020 election in Fulton County, Georgia, which includes Atlanta.
Muller, the law professor, said local election officials “are already having conversations about chain-of-custody disputes” over ballots as they are cast, collected, counted and stored.
He and UCLA Law professor Rick Hasen noted that warrants are required for the type of actions that occurred in Fulton County. Muller predicted that “the bar would be even higher” for any order the government seeks during an ongoing election.
Hasen added that he is working to educate judges across the country about the importance of ballot chain of custody.
“Republicans believe him when he says the election is rigged. And then when Republicans try to change the voting rules to tighten them, that makes Democrats think the election system is being rigged, too,” Hasen said. “So if what he’s trying to achieve is to undermine voter confidence in the electoral process, he appears to have succeeded spectacularly.”
This story was translated from English to Spanish with an artificial intelligence tool and was reviewed by an editor before publication.
