Aibonite – Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
The silence that for several seconds surrounded room 1 of the Court of First Instance of Aibonito broke down this Thursday with a word that the family of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario I’ve been waiting to hear for almost a year: guilty.
After 23 days of trial, an extensive parade of evidence and the deliberation process, the jury returned a guilty verdict against Elvia Cabrera Rivera for the murder of the 16-year-old teenager, which occurred in August 2025 on the Roberto Colon detour.
The seven women and five men who made up the jury made the decision after spending their second night in complete isolation in a hotel, without access to their cell phones or the news, in accordance with the kidnapping order of Superior Judge Luis S. Barreto Altieri.
In this way, an extremely high-profile judicial process that began on May 1 with an extensive parade of evidence, which included more than 200 pieces of evidence, including witness statements, photographs and videos from security cameras, came to an end.
With the unanimous verdict, the jury accepted the theory of the Aibonito Prosecutor’s Office, focused on that Cabrera Rivera acted in common and mutual agreement with his daughter Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera, 18 years old, co-accused in the case, to perpetrate the murder of the victim.
1/7 | In a prayer circle: family and loved ones honor the memory of Gabriela Nicole. In a critical stage of the trial against Elvia Cabrera, the family of the murdered minor Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario joined in a prayer circle. – Pablo Martinez Rodriguez
In order to support its theory of the case – that the accused gave the murder weapon to her daughter and then made it disappear – the Prosecutor’s Office presented more than 60 witnesses, of which only 21 testified in person before the members of the jury.
During the trial, the pathologist Javier Gustavo Serrano Serrano stated that the victim received 11 stab wounds, including one that reached his heart and caused his death. The expert indicated that, due to the injuries, the attacker sought to cause bodily harm.
Throughout the judicial process, several witnesses stated that they saw the accused take a sharp object out of her purse and hand it to her daughter. Likewise, they indicated that, after this action, they observed the young woman allegedly attacking Pratts Rosario.
However, an important piece was the testimony of JNRSthe victim’s first cousin, 16 years old, who testified under oath that she saw Aviles Cabrera stab “Lela” and then observed the accused pick up a sharp, thin object from the scene.
“It was finite because of how she picked it up (the object). I was three feet (away). (At that moment) Elvia looked at me and said: ‘You didn’t see anything’!’
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
On Wednesday, the case reached a point of no return, when the parties had their last opportunity to address the jury during closing arguments. The Prosecutor’s Office took advantage of that moment to request a guilty verdict against the accused.
“Today Gabriela Nicole’s voice cannot be heard, but the voice of justice is in her hands”said the prosecutor Silda Rubio Barretowho, together with the prosecutors Myriam Nieves Vera and Jackeline Pizarro Gutierrez formed the representation of the Public Ministry.
For its part, the defense argued that the investigation of the case was marked from the beginning by inconsistencies and that the evidence failed to establish the guilt of its client beyond a reasonable doubt. Therefore, he requested a not guilty verdict.
“Justice does not ask for courage to condemn, it asks for honesty to be able to recognize the true facts… Sometimes the most difficult verdict is not guilty, but the correct one,” said Alberto Rivera Ramos, of the accused’s legal team.
With the jury’s determination, the case now enters the sentencing stage, where the court must set the corresponding penalty according to the crimes for which she was found guilty. The accused faces a sentence of more than 99 years in prison.
